Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Environment Minister Wade Istchenko

Government rapped for inaction on dangerous dogs

The Yukon government has failed to take decisive action on the stray dog problem in Ross River – which experts call a public health crisis – despite repeated calls for help from the community.

By Sidney Cohen on May 18, 2016

The Yukon government has failed to take decisive action on the stray dog problem in Ross River – which experts call a public health crisis – despite repeated calls for help from the community.

That’s the view of the author of two government reports on the issue.

Last week, the Yukon’s chief coroner determined that a young man who died in the Kaska community in October 2015 was killed and his body eaten by stray dogs.

Indeed, feral dogs, which pose a significant danger to people, and especially children, have been an issue in Ross River, and communities across the Yukon, for years.

Dr. Richard G. Herbert, a former veterinarian and the author of the two 2010 government-commissioned reports, found that the dog problem in Ross River to be “out of control.”

He said that every Yukon community must have access to veterinary care and dog control services.

“Anything less than reasonable ubiquitous access leaves citizens and property at risk,” he wrote in one of his reports.

The documents made a number of recommendations to the government in 2010 that included improving access to veterinary services in the community, and modernizing the Yukon’s laws dealing with dogs.

Herbert was contracted to lead a dog management pilot project in Ross River.

The venture was cancelled because, he was told, the government did not have the budget and capacity to take it on.

In a signed, Jan. 31, 2011 letter from Ross River Dena Council Chief Jack Caesar to Archie Lang, then the Yukon Party’s minister of Community Services, Caesar says:

“In (a Yukon News) report, the YG (Yukon government) is quoted as saying that because of the pilot program cost of $250,000, ‘... that is not something we can do right now.’

“$250,000 represents 0.02% of the YG’s annual budget. Are our children, and children in all communities our pilot program could help by preventing dog attacks, worth more than 0.02% of one YG budget?”

Caesar could not be reached for an interview before press time this afternoon.

The pilot project flowed from a memorandum of agreement (MOA) signed by the Ross River Dena Council and the Yukon government in March 2010.

The Star was provided with copies of three letters from Caesar to Lang, all from 2011.

In them, the chief asks for the government to move ahead with Herbert’s Ross River Dena Council – Yukon Government Dog Management Pilot Program.

Herbert said if the government had followed up on his plan for dog management in the community, which had Caesar’s support, 22-year-old Shane Glada’s death may have been prevented.

“There was an agreement signed with Ross River to take care of the problem. If we had begun to work on the problem and used Ross River as a pilot project, a two-year project, we would have taken care of the problem in Ross River,” Herbert told the Star Tuesday.

“We should have been able to change the environment in terms of health and safety.”

There was a spay and neuter clinic held in Ross River the 2013-14 fiscal year. As well, a number of Ross River dogs were fixed in the 2014-15 year, confirmed Roxanne Stasyszyn, a Department of Environment spokesperson.

In 2011, the government sent a dog catcher into the community to round up stray dogs.

However, most dogs were claimed by owners, and only a small number were surrendered to be euthanized, said Mary VanderKop, the Yukon’s chief veterinary officer.

So the dog patrols stopped.

“My understanding is that there were not persistent concerns at that time,” said VanderKop.

“At this point, we’re actually quite concerned and are very interested to put some action plan in place.”

VanderKop said a “task team,” made up of Chief Caesar and volunteers from the community, was formed during a public meeting on May 9, where the coroner made her pronouncement on Glada’s horrific death.

The task team will make recommendations to the coroner, and VanderKop said she is prepared to support and implement those recommendations.

The dearth of vets in the Yukon’s communities is a persistent problem, as rural residents typically have to travel to Whitehorse or Dawson City to have their dogs spayed or neutered.

These procedures are best performed in a clinical environment, and “it’s a considerable cost to vets to take their staff and equipment out to a community,” said VanderKop.

“That’s one of the things that we’ll be talking to the task team about.”

In the legislature this week, the opposition parties have been asking what exactly the government is doing to address the serious and ongoing problem of feral dogs in Ross River.

“The facts surrounding this young man’s death have left the community reeling,” NDP MLA Kate White said Monday.

“The community, including the chief, has noted the lack of response coming from the Yukon government. The minister responsible has not commented publicly on any action he plans to take.”

White noted that the coroner and Ross River Dena Council are working together on the issue.

She asked if the government had reached out to Ross River since the coroner announced her findings.

To this, Environment Minister Wade Istchenko did not give an answer. Instead, he alluded to the May 9 meeting in Ross River, attended by senior government staff.

“The coroner is still working on this ongoing case. Once the report is complete, we will review the recommendations carefully,” he said.

Liberal Leader Sandy Silver pressed the point Tuesday, calling out the Yukon Party for failing to call Chief Caesar after the May 9 meeting.

“This is a very disturbing incident, and it’s hard to imagine something happening in Canada, let alone in the Yukon — but I am quite surprised, honestly, that no one from this government has spoken to the chief,” said Silver.

“The chief of the Ross River Dena Council has described the situation in the community as ‘dire.’ I appreciate the fact that the government intends to reach out, as the minister said, but there’s a lack of urgency here.”

White pointed out Monday that on July 4, 2012, when five-year-old Jaedyn Amann was killed after being struck in the head by a falling soccer net in Watson Lake, “this government reacted with compassion and support toward both the family and the community.

“They quickly introduced legislation to ensure that it would never happen again,” she said.

“This government has the opportunity to take similar swift action.”

Comments (16)

Up 2 Down 0

John gould on May 25, 2016 at 11:14 am

Come on if you've been to Ross River then you will clearly see it is a breeding ground for wild dogs and of course all owners are responsible. You really want to blame the government because of some starved out dogs? What about chief and council? These Kaska blame everyone for their problems yet take no accountability for their community or its pets. Give me a break - this is 2016. You see wild dogs and do nothing then blame yourself, don't blame the government.
Take some action and deal with the issue. This topic is sad yet points out the fact that the Kaska people are not willing to act as governing bodies yet want to be recognized as governing bodies. It insults normal people's intelligence. In fact this boy would still be alive if someone took the innovative to either dispose of these dogs or here's one, feed them.

Up 0 Down 2

67scotty10 on May 24, 2016 at 10:11 pm

I thought Elders were listened to and they taught respect for all animals. What happened to the poor dogs in Ross River?
What have they done to deserve being kicked, tortured, starved and now probably shot. Maybe we should get an Animal Rescue group from the south to come in and save them all. I think we should contact them and let them know that they are needed in the Yukon because we cannot look after our dogs. The dogs ancestors helped Aboriginal people hunt, protect their homes and were respected and taken care of. What happened!!!!!!!!

Up 0 Down 2

drum on May 24, 2016 at 9:55 pm

Last time I checked people are responsible for their pets. Dogs are pets. Why are those poor dogs in Ross River - sometime those poor animals were brought into the community. Why did they bring them into the community if they did not want to look after them. They were not cared for, not neutered or spayed, not fed or loved. It has nothing to do with the community being a reserve or having finished their land claims and saying because of this they have no responsibility and that YG have to take care of their problem. If you cannot take care of your dogs how can you ever take care of anything else. Take responsibility for those loving animals now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Up 1 Down 1

ignore the 'moose in the room' on May 24, 2016 at 9:32 pm

Almost everyone is pretending to ignore the 'moose in the room' with their political correctness regarding small village politics. If the people who are not looking after their dogs and letting them run loose are related to the village leaders, then excuses are made, nobody knows anything, nothing gets done and scapegoats are found. In many cases it's 'traditional'.

The dog situation in Ross exists because people allow it to, and have no motivation to change it.
There's always the government to blame it on and the chance of more money in an election year.

Up 4 Down 17

Ban the trolls on May 24, 2016 at 8:16 am

Not sure how many of you know, Ross River is not a "reserve", is not the responsibility of the RRDC, dog control does not fall under the Chief's duties, nor does RRDC receive funding for dog control.
Ross River is a Yukon community, hamlet, local improvement area, municipality or whatever it is called, at the end of the day Yukon Territorial Government receives the funding for dog control and should have been doing something about the situation in Ross River.
Get your facts straight before firing off accusations that are far from accurate.

Up 19 Down 1

yukon 56 on May 20, 2016 at 10:25 pm

As a boy in Mayo the RCMP announced that any dogs running free would be killed. This was due to the young girl I believe that was killed by a pack of feral dogs in Whitehorse

Up 6 Down 7

Josey Wales on May 19, 2016 at 5:23 pm

Hmm...Trevor the Dog(s)..Scads-O-Trevor the humans..all inclusive nnnKay Theresa the human. Folks these things are not fig-newtons of my (insert chosen word) mind but are omni-present from coast to coast to yup..the other coast too. What do they all have in common?
None of the above are at fault, always the fault of everyone else, funny that eh?
The favorite blame locale ins of course because they pay better and pander to the whims of the PC Crusaders and revisionist history snobs a.k.a."consultants".

Like I said folks at every posted opportunity, I lost a brother to the exact same cavalier "who cares" not my fault ideology.
Shane paid the price recently with it, who next? More importantly why do we as a collective get so so scared to discuss....The Moose in the room?

Kowtowing to a bunch of politically correct (they feel) social justice freaks?
to them I say the same to those telling me to eat my greens...

Up 40 Down 2

yukoner on May 19, 2016 at 4:17 pm

Live traps are available In various stores and locations in the Yukon. 22 bullets are also available and cheaper than a trap. If that young man was a member of my family every unwanted, starving dog would be gone. It's about time all members of the Ross River community took responsibility for the dog problem that they created by one getting a dog they don't want, two letting that dog breed with other unwanted dogs and three leaving these unwanted dogs to fend for themselves. These poor animals are doing what they can to survive. End the suffering and get rid of them. I am not a dog hater I have four well fed and neutered dogs that I pet and love every day.

Up 25 Down 7

Nimble navigator on May 19, 2016 at 3:11 pm

Hmm, it's almost like irresponble people taking "care" of animals and children leads to issues. It's the YG's fault? "Self government"? Failed Latino states (i.e. Venezuela) look terrific compared to Yukon communities.

Up 37 Down 3

Common Sense on May 19, 2016 at 2:30 pm

The RRFN needs to hire a Dog catcher. Shoot all the feral dogs. Problem solved. Stop playing the blame game and do something before a child is hurt or killed. Open your eyes people.

Up 49 Down 3

ben on May 19, 2016 at 8:23 am

This is getting stupid; not the tragedy that occurred to Shane Glada and his family, but the series of articles and the RRDC chief blaming government for the dog issues in Ross River (and directly and indirectly the death of poor Shane Glada). Are these dogs owned by YG or the federal government? Were the unsprayed/unneutered ancestors of the feral dogs owned by YG or the federal government? If that's the case, then please blame the government, but it's not the case.
What I read from the articles is that the coroner and chief veterinarian, and probably every other YG department involved is offering to carry out actions on behalf of Ross River citizens, they just want the decisions about what the community needs to come from the community (which is very respectful I think). In one of the articles it sounds like the chief veterinarian is willing to bend over backwards to help.
The community needs to take responsibility for a problem that the community has created, and make some decisions about what has to happen from here on in to deal with it, and it sounds like YG officials will support those decisions. And please.......stop pulling the race card (as was pulled in one of the CBC articles), it's irrelevant.

Up 5 Down 32

Ban the trolls on May 18, 2016 at 8:44 pm

Hey troll you know not of what you speak. Don't criticize another person until you have walked a mile in their shoes.

Up 34 Down 7

westofbelfast on May 18, 2016 at 7:01 pm

"The community, including the chief, has noted the lack of response coming from the Yukon government. The minister responsible has not commented publicly on any action he plans to take.”

Ounce of prevention...pound of cure. The people in this community know very well of the situation and their lack of action is the reason for this...this blame the government BS has no basis in reality.

Up 41 Down 5

cameron on May 18, 2016 at 5:55 pm

Situation ::::DIRE:::::: so the Chief says- where has he been for the last few years!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Who caused this terrible situation. The poor young man was killed because the people in that community will not take any responsibility for anything- they blame the world for everything - that gets them off the hook for being responsible human beings and joining the civilized society. Why would they think that anyone else should come into their community and sort it out. Take your poor dogs into your homes where they belong and feed them and water them and care for them as our maker told us to do.

Up 13 Down 45

Very friggin sad... on May 18, 2016 at 5:45 pm

It is pretty sad when the Yukon Party only caters to Whitehorse and the non-native population for votes while Ross River suffers with Feral Dog issues that does not concern the Yukon Party one bit, even after a Native Youth is killed by these Feral Dogs.

Maybe the Yukon Party should hang onto the transit funds they received from Ottawa for all the lawsuits that will be coming their way as a result of negligence towards the Ross River community.

Up 108 Down 19

Plywood on May 18, 2016 at 3:58 pm

Same old story. People in communities make no effort. They have as many dogs as they please, don't control their pets and foster a culture of negligence and cruelty on these animals.

When it blows up, they blame the Yukon government of course. Why not the Federal government while we're at it.

Should the government also hire a maid service to come and clean people's houses and yards? Someone could step on a broken bottle and it would be (of course) government's fault.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.