Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Pierre Chauvin

EN FRANÇAIS, S.V.P.– Radio-Canada’s Brett Ballah (at the podium) moderates AFY’s French debate with, from left to right, candidates Ryan Leef, Larry Bagnell and his translator Luc Laferté, and André Bourcier translating for Melissa Atkinson at the Coast High Country Inn on Saturday.

Federal candidates square off in French

Three of the territory’s federal election candidates took part in a French-language debate organized by the Association Franco-Yukonnaise (AFY) on Saturday.

By Pierre Chauvin on September 28, 2015

Three of the territory’s federal election candidates took part in a French-language debate organized by the Association Franco-Yukonnaise (AFY) on Saturday.

Both Conservative candidate Ryan Leef and Liberal candidate Larry Bagnell answered questions in French.

NDP candidate Melissa Atkinson, however, spoke in English and had a translator repeat her answers in French.

Bagnell was also assisted by a translator to understand some of the questions.

Leef and Bagnell spoke in French for most of the debate, sometimes switching back to English for a couple of words when they were struggling.

Unlike the French debate held by Radio-Canada last week that saw some tense moments between the party leaders, the AFY’s debate was less emotional.

Candidates were asked for their stances on bilingualism, funding for CBC-Radio-Canada and the francophone community.

Other hot-button issues were brought up including hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, Bill S-6 and continuing care for senior Yukoners.

Brett Ballah, Radio-Canada’s managing editor for B.C. and Yukon, made the trip from Vancouver to moderate the AFY’s debate.

“It’s important for francophones to have an opportunity to ask questions in French,” said AFY president Angélique Bernard after the debate.

About 30 people attended Saturday’s event.

Bernard praised the efforts candidates made to answer the questions in French.

“(Though) I don’t know what people are going to take back in terms of commitments (made by the candidates),” she said.

When asked about the importance of francophones outside of Quebec – an issue completely overlooked during Radio-Canada’s national debate – candidates were quick to state their support but didn’t provide any concrete measures.

“I recognize that the francophone community here in the Yukon has a lot to offer. It’s an essential part of our community,” said Atkinson.

Leef talked about the role of the Yukon’s MP to speak in the House of Commons about bills that matter to the community.

Bagnell said he would talk to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau about francophones outside of Quebec.

The topic of CBC/Radio-Canada’s funding quickly came up.

Yann Herry, who co-ordinates francophone partnerships with the Yukon government and is involved in numerous initiatives like the Whitehorse-Lancieux Sister City Exchange Program, explained how important Radio-Canada was for his family, as a vector of development and education.

Leef maintained that the government has committed to other celebrations of the French language.

He later added that it was difficult for him to answer without the help of a translator.

Bagnell promised to double subsidies to the public broadcaster and to invest in the National Film Board.

Atkinson talked about the broadcaster’s “precarious position” and said the NDP was committed to cancelling the cuts and guaranteeing stable funding.

Both the NDP and Conservative candidates were asked why none of their campaign signs were bilingual.

“Your point is well taken, and I don’t have a reasonable excuse,” said Leef, adding that his office does have a lot of resources available in French.

Atkinson said it is her first time running, adding that she’d keep the suggestion in mind.

“I've heard your voice and I will do better to make you feel included because it's important,” she said.

Bagnell, whose signs are partly bilingual, suggested the use of First Nation languages for the next federal election.

Candidates were also asked about their positions on fracking and Bill S-6.

The bill, passed earlier this summer, amends part of the Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Act.

Several Yukon First Nations will be fighting the legislation in court, arguing it threatens the independence of the assessment board and the quality of environmental assessments.

Bagnell stated his opposition to fracking and that a Liberal government would repeal the four controversial amendments that were made to the bill without Yukoners’ consent.

Atkinson also came out against fracking. Bill S-6, she said, was one of the reasons she decided to run as a candidate. The NDP has also pledged to rescind the four amendments.

The bill is about community and economic development, Leef insisted.

Atkinson read her closing statement in French, restating part of her party’s program.

“We want an MP who will be the Yukon’s voice in Ottawa, not Ottawa’s voice in the Yukon,” she said.

Leef noted he was proud of his last four years in Parliament, and the hardship of learning a new language.

“Melissa did a great job working through French,” he said, in English.

He reiterated that the federal government, under Harper’s leadership, has invested a lot in Yukon communities, including the francophone community.

“Words are less important than the relationship I have with the francophone community,” said Bagnell, mentioning his volunteer experience at the Sugar Shack during Yukon Sourdough Rendezvous.

He outlined his past experience with the federal government as Yukon’s former MP.

Green Party candidate Frank de Jong was absent from the debate. He had originally confirmed his attendance but couldn’t make it.

De Jong, who works as a teacher in Faro, told the Star today that he was in Dawson City at a rural camp with children over the weekend.

“I was driving a bus full of kids at the time,” he said.

Comments (15)

Up 4 Down 1

NDP is slipping away every where on Oct 4, 2015 at 9:38 am

Don't waste your vote on the NDP they going down down.
It is a horse race between liberals and conservatives.
Mulcair intentionally wants to open up the constitution and cause lots of problems not solve anything.

Up 4 Down 7

Joe on Oct 2, 2015 at 3:28 pm

I assure you the people I hang with are not unemployed, more likely your bosses and such, and, I'm not sure what a trendy coffee shop is, I boil tea on my MSR. That being said, there is no value in debating the inevitable outcome online. I encourage you to talk to people outside your fixed group and you will soon discover the extent in which yukon residents are fed up with failed promises. Only one choice with no baggage. Might want to read up on " new way of thinking".

Up 22 Down 6

Just Say'in on Oct 1, 2015 at 2:19 pm

@joe We all feel the same way. All the people I talk to would never vote NDP. You must be hanging out with the unemployed at one of those really trendy coffee shops. I hang out with the working folks.

Up 10 Down 16

Joe on Sep 30, 2015 at 6:08 pm

@moose- my info comes from people I speak to, and I speak to a lot of people, 5 out of 10 say they will vote for Melissa, a few die hards are willing to give Larry another chance and, well Leef gets some interesting comments!

Up 16 Down 14

Moose on Sep 30, 2015 at 12:18 pm

haha nice try Joe. "Real life on the streets of Yukon poll" = I spoke with a few of my friends and made some numbers up.
Even the Conservatives know that Larry is winning - which is why all of their attack ads are focused on him while they pay no attention to the NDP.

Up 7 Down 26

Joe on Sep 29, 2015 at 7:29 pm

Real life on the streets of whitehorse poll:

Melissa( no baggage) 50%
Larry (already tried)20%
Ryan (self explanitory)15%
Undecided -15%

Up 18 Down 14

Donating on Sep 29, 2015 at 4:39 pm

I'm so sick of the attack ads on Larry that seem to shift everyday but have the same tired theme of the gun registry!! I am going to donate $5 to Larry for every stupid Conservative attack I hear on the radio. Every Sunday I will tally up the number of ads and make my donation. Maybe if attack ads start to backfire, they will give them up.

Up 14 Down 13

Environics Poll for Yukon Riding on Sep 29, 2015 at 3:55 pm

Our local riding :

Bagnell: 39%
Leef: 27%
Atkinson:28%
De Jong: 4%

Make of that what you will!

Up 28 Down 23

CBC TV news at noon today on latest polls on the Federal elections on Sep 29, 2015 at 12:51 pm

NDP at 23%
Liberals at 27%
Green at 3%
Conservatives at 47%

Up 4 Down 4

pas chance on Sep 28, 2015 at 11:28 pm

Il n'a pas chance…lol

Up 56 Down 57

Francis on Sep 28, 2015 at 8:31 pm

What is the BS all about, a whole evening dedicated to les french, make no wonder our nation is a mess, playing the bilingual card in a territory that is basically under siege by a group that represents less than 10 percent of the pop. What a joke!

Up 44 Down 10

Wunderer on Sep 28, 2015 at 7:01 pm

June try this : Non bonne chance pour Monsuier Leef.

What I'm wondering is will there be a debate in Southern Tuchone as they are the real #2 culture here and the First Nation of the Territory?

Up 17 Down 6

PierreBierre on Sep 28, 2015 at 5:52 pm

'Volunteer experience at the sugar shack' ? Er, Larry, I'm generally on the same page as you, but is sucking down a chunk of maple taffy the best way to demonstrate solidarity with the Francophones? Having your mouth gummed up with candy also doesn't exactly assist with translation. Alors !!!!!

Up 21 Down 17

Thomas Brewer on Sep 28, 2015 at 5:21 pm

"First Nation languages for the next federal election." Hey, why don't we include Tagalog too? Or maybe just stick with Canada's two official languages, ok?

Up 62 Down 33

June Jackson on Sep 28, 2015 at 3:39 pm

How do you say.. "Leef doesn't stand a chance" in French?

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.