Photo by Whitehorse Star
John Streicker and Yvonne Clarke
Photo by Whitehorse Star
John Streicker and Yvonne Clarke
If it wasn’t cold enough already, thousands of Yukoners were left without power for hours on Monday evening.
If it wasn’t cold enough already, thousands of Yukoners were left without power for hours on Monday evening.
Despite a week-long forecast full of extreme cold warnings, Yukon Energy had not anticipated the electricity demands that came with the numbing cold.
The outages began at around 5:30 p.m. Monday in Whistle Bend, Laberge, Crestview, Kulan, parts of Takhini and Range roads, the Alaska Highway West and the Klondike Highway North. The temperature was -40 or even colder in some areas.
According to ATCO Electric Yukon, 3,360 customers were without power after a breaker at the Takhini substation overloaded, tripping protection settings.
ATCO said in an email to the Star that power was restored to all customers by 9:50 Monday evening.
The outages caused a stir online, with people praising frontline workers who braved some of the year’s coldest temperatures.
However, they pointedly asked the Yukon Energy Corp. (YEC) why power had failed in the first place.
“Please hurry. It’s cold,” reads one response to ATCO’s initial tweet saying crews were responding to the outage.
Yukon Energy spokesperson Lisa Wiklund told the Star Tuesday the corporation had the supply to provide electricity Monday, but had not anticipated the demand.
“Demand for electricity is increasing and increasing, and we hit a new record peak,” she said.
The territory hit a new record for electricity demand Monday afternoon, spiking at 117.1 megawatts. That was five hours before the series of outages began, however.
Wiklund said peak energy use in the areas impacted Monday began when people were getting home from work, a usual high demand time.
Wiklund said safety settings had been readjusted and YEC does not expect a similar outage in the future.
YEC’s breaker was reset quickly, she said, but ATCO Electric crews then had to go out into the cold to reset the utility company’s breakers.
That took anywhere from one to just over four hours, depending on the neighbourhood.
Two other power failures, unrelated to Monday night’s, also occurred Tuesday. One was in Porter Creek and another in Pelly Crossing, where some residents were in the dark for as long as six hours.
ATCO tweeted at noon Tuesday that an unplanned power failure in Pelly Crossing was being responded to by power crews – some of them the same crews who had been dealing with Monday night’s failures in the Whitehorse area.
At 7:30 p.m., the company tweeted again to say the failure was resolved and power had been restored.
At 9:35, another tweet said some Porter Creek customers had lost power; ATCO posted at midnight that power had been restored there.
The Star reached out to ATCO this morning, but the company was unable to provide a reason for the failure before press deadline.
With high electricity demands, Wiklund said YEC is encouraging Yukoners not to use too much electricity during peak hours – 7 a.m. to 9 a.m., the lunch hour, and 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. – to decrease strain on the system.
“Not running major appliances, turning your thermostat down one to two degrees, that will definitely help to ensure that this doesn’t happen again,” she said.
The Yukon Party, meanwhile, criticized the territorial government for its response to Monday’s outages, as well as its investment in rented diesel generators for backup power in the winter months.
The official Opposition said Tuesday the incident proves the generators are unreliable.
“The flawed energy policies of the territorial Liberals has left the Yukon with a dangerously vulnerable electrical grid, and the recent blackout has given Yukoners a sense of what that means for them,” Scott Kent, the party’s energy critic, said in the release.
“The Liberals have stubbornly refused to make the necessary investments in reliable power supply. Instead, they have banked Yukon’s energy future on uncertain projects like the Moon Lake hydro project, which is likely at least a decade away,” Kent added.
Yvonne Clarke, the Yukon Party MLA for Porter Creek Centre, called the lack of communication from YG “very concerning.
“While ATCO Electric Yukon was providing ongoing updates on social media and responding to Yukoners’ direct concerns, Yukon Government has been silent on the matter,” said Clarke, whose riding encompasses Whistle Bend. Most of the hundreds of homes built there are heated by electricity.
“There was never any communication about where Yukoners who had to leave their homes should go, or whether centralized warming centres were being planned.
“I’ve heard from constituents that had to pack up young children to join friends or families that had heat, because they were worried about the temperature dropping in their homes,” Clarke added.
“While Yukoners are extremely thankful for the response of ATCO crews that braved the extreme cold to restore power, many are wondering why this happened and what is being done to ensure it doesn’t happen again,” the Yukon Party said.
John Streicker, the minister responsible for YEC, said Tuesday afternoon he believes communication was appropriate and timely on Monday.
ATCO had been informed promptly once the YEC breaker tripped, and the electric utility then informed the public through social media with regular posts, he told the Star.
The City of Whitehorse was informed at 6 p.m. and connected with the Emergency Measures Organization (EMO).
Power failures lasting longer than four hours, Streicker noted, necessitate an emergency response. But since the electricity was restored to all homes in four hours and 15 minutes, no emergency action was taken.
A city spokesperson told the Star the city has an emergency plan for such situations.
The Emergency Operations Centre would have been activated and the Canada Games Centre would have been converted into a large warming centre for those without power.
Streicker said the failures said nothing about the effectiveness of rented diesel generators, as the power losses were not a matter of supply but poor anticipation.
He said YEC president Andrew Hall told him the corporation should have been better prepared for the demand, as there was enough power to supply electricity uninterrupted during the peak.
Streicker also said Yukon Energy, ATCO and the City of Whitehorse conduct “after action reviews” when a “significant event” like this occurs to ensure they are better able to respond to mounting energy demands going forward.
On the afternoon of Dec. 8, more than 9,000 people lost their power in the Whitehorse area, Tagish, Carcross and Johnson’s Crossing and the Mayo Road.
ATCO’s Wiklund said a sensor had tripped at the Whitehorse Rapids Dam – causing the loss of three generating units and some of the liquefied natural gas units.
One Sunday afternoon in January 2006, during another period of -40 weather, thousands of Yukoners in Whitehorse and around the territory were plunged into the dark and cold after a prolonged power failure that lasted for as long as eight hours in some areas.
In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.
Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.
Comments (38)
Up 13 Down 0
John on Dec 27, 2022 at 2:30 pm
It is safe to say that if you want surety of supply when it comes to keeping your home warm at minimum you should have two to even three sources of heat. You should not rely on others to keep you warm due to a lack of preparedness on your part. Inverters are a good example of hooking up as an emergency back up to your heating appliances, but alas pretty damn near cost prohibitive if your only source of heat is electric. The other alternative is a generator that you can either activate or have it activate for you (the later is a tad more costly). Most homes can get by quite easily with a 7000 watt generator. You may not be able to use the heavy demander's, like dish washers, driers, electric ovens, etc. The other cost is the hook up to your meter. All the can be arranged by some of the shops in town. Word of advise. If you are going to get a generator spend a little more and get quality. My experience with the CT & HH specials is that are not reliable and usually fail in cold weather to start. I have a 6500i Honda that will start at even -40. Honda make great equipment. Fuel capacity is good for 8-10 hours depending on the demand. The trick of course is the battery making sure it is either heated or quickly accessible to boost from a portable booster. Also use synthetic oil.
In our home with have 3 sources of heat - and the fall back is wood of the three. The advantage you will have with wood is that you can cook your meals on it if need be. For us it is critical to have a generator as we have a well and septic system. Both of these require electric for water pump and also the heat trace to both so they don't freeze. We can even plug a vehicle in to run constantly (but sorry no electric vehicles you would need a larger generator - big bucks).
Old time Yukoners know the value of what I am saying. When the Faro mine was running we could guarantee several power outages a month - some lasting 4-6 hours. Folks need to remember where we live. We are geographically disconnected from our southern neighbours. If we have a catastrophic event with the grid we need to prepare for at least 72 hours before help will arrive. In fact I would go beyond that benchmark and be prepared for double that. You don't want to suffer the same fate as is happening in Buffalo and Quebec right now.
Think and plan ahead. Yup you may not need it, but I can tell you from living here all my life that it will happen - it is just the when.
Up 6 Down 0
North_of_60 on Dec 27, 2022 at 2:13 pm
Fifty years ago electric utilities controlled hot water heaters during peak demand times; it was very effective even with the relatively primitive control tech at that time. DHW mgt. pilot projects in the Yukon met with success, but YE didn't implement this simple, cost effective means of reducing peak demands. All the money invested in solar, wind and batteries doesn't do much good to address the real problems of winter electricity demand.
Up 9 Down 8
Nathan Living on Dec 26, 2022 at 11:17 pm
Many good comments here.
I do think YE should expect peaks when it's colder than minus 37ish C. They did assume responsibility which is good.
And yes, homeowners should have a wood stove or other form of backup if they have electrical heating.
Capacity planning is lacking. There needs to be more capacity than current demand loads by a factor of 1.5 times minimum. The little capacity increases here and there approach is not getting us there anytime soon.
Frontline workers are awesome, capacity increases not meeting the mark.
Would it help if the City formed an energy committee? Not a great question for sure and yes it's provocative.
Up 25 Down 1
Groucho d'North on Dec 26, 2022 at 8:30 am
I imagine if YG hired a couple people to each night roam through their buildings and shut off all the vampire electrical gear (computers, printers, copiers) and underdesk heaters and lights. The money saved would pay for their wages and benefits, and reduce strain on the supply side of the energy equation.
Up 18 Down 1
EndureOvercome on Dec 25, 2022 at 8:50 pm
I find it sooo convenient that the drivel on the opposite side only yaps when they don’t have an original idea. How hilarious is it that the maroon complains but lives in Whistlebend aka Electricbend.
All the moaning from life long Yukoners is equally hilarious. If you live up here, prepare for the winter.
For the CEO….you are hypocrite and zealot. To say what you have does not diminish your incompetence.
To the government, I may work for you and voted for you but this is a total FU.
Come on….figure it out Premier Pillah
Up 23 Down 1
Heathen on Dec 24, 2022 at 4:53 pm
It is truly a wonder with the number of government staff (YG, Fed, FN, City etc) that an issue as fundamental as power generation in a Northern Territory has been left to languish for years. Oh, yes some well heeled consultants from down south will come around to pitch YG or to an FN gov on wind power, unicorn farts and the like. None of these alternatives are capable of generation to scale needed for even a small jurisdiction such as ourselves. Atlin hydro appears promising but even with that project there has been significant fumbles.
Given the above it is downright worrisome to hear YEC say they weren’t prepared. Are they not familiar with Yukon winters or the history of usage? For so many incidents to occur in the span of a few days certainly portends a wider problem whether staffing, infrastructure or power (or all three?).
Up 23 Down 2
The Power on Dec 24, 2022 at 1:10 pm
I bet out of a hundred Yukoners maybe five can competently explain how Yukon Energy is run as a crown corporation. Start there and work back a few years if you want to figure out who is responsible for the decisions leading us to the reality of today: inadequate foresight and generation for the demand of the population. Compound that with rosy notions of electric cars and home heating, I suppose only government accounting can make those add up.
Instead of these do-nothing, pacify the woke, piecemeal projects (the battery, all wind), why are plans not being made for the long term? If we build another dam with First nations as partners, what if we end up in a situation where we have power to sell? A neighboring jurisdiction might be more receptive to footing the infrastructure bill - wouldn't you rather a powerline rather than pipeline or trucks with diesel up and down the highway?
I dont know about you, but my community could sure use a couple hundred bucks in the bank instead of more riders and surcharges.
Up 24 Down 2
Captain Obvious on Dec 23, 2022 at 8:09 pm
I'll throw my 2 cents in here as it's Friday night and I am on my 3rd scotch.
A) We need to have a secondary source of heat in our homes, be it wood, propane or oil. Electricity is all good an well until it stops flowing.
B) Please have a look at potential second and third hydro generating locations. It would be good to have a little more Mega Watts in the bank so to speak.
C) Did this current government speak with the BC government about possibly getting a line up to the Yukon from Site C when that comes online? With that project producing 1100MW our requirement would be a drop in the bucket. Spend some dollars, build transmission lines and some booster stations.
https://www.sitecproject.com/about-site-c/project-overview
D) please don't crucify me for this... but SMR would be a good idea as well.
https://www.energy.gov/ne/advanced-small-modular-reactors-smrs
Anyways,
Keep warm and help out your neighbor if you can. Home backup generators are a good investment too.
Merry Christmas all.
Up 10 Down 21
ecofriendly on Dec 23, 2022 at 7:56 pm
Here's a thought:
Turn off unneeded electronics during the deep cold. Your gaming PC's, your ridiculous TV's, your hairdryers, your fancy gadgets.
Power use keeps going -up-. How about reducing the amount of power you need?
Also, for f**ks sake, it's a power outage, not the end of the world. I can't believe the shitstorm people brew up for a few hours of inconvenience.
Up 35 Down 2
drum on Dec 23, 2022 at 3:07 pm
You specify Pelly as being treated badly by power outages on one of the coldest nights of the year. How about the rest of us. You are not just the only ones treated like second class citizens - I pay my own bills!!!!!!!!!
Up 40 Down 4
Yeti on Dec 23, 2022 at 2:18 pm
Drone by YEC the other day, permanent fixtures present North 60 oil truck, finning service truck, anything that could generate power was maxed out. This was at -38. Forcing people into green homes with electric heat is bonkers. The best heat up here aside from wood is oil, it’s been that way for a 100 years yet this government would rather spend millions on oil at YEC.
Up 31 Down 4
Pingo on Dec 23, 2022 at 2:14 pm
That’s the heavens when the conservatives were in power they has the wherewithal and vision to build the LNG plants, I remember some of the ill informed with signs upset of the decision. Without that decision today we would be constantly in rolling black outs.
Up 32 Down 1
Vlad on Dec 23, 2022 at 2:12 pm
Notice: North 60 Petro has moved….from Industrial Road to Yukon Energy. That’s some Green going on.
Up 39 Down 9
A door knob on Dec 23, 2022 at 1:21 am
John is:
-short sighted
-idealistic
-unaccountable
-rude
John isn't:
-thinking about the future
-worried about the future
-good at his job
-deeper than a puddle
Up 45 Down 8
Joe on Dec 22, 2022 at 4:22 pm
One thing is for sure, the liberal government can't accomplish anything. And now due to an unelected coalition, we are forced to live with an NDP sponsored unelected premier. What a joke
Up 46 Down 5
In the vacuum of L-NDP politics… on Dec 22, 2022 at 11:55 am
I was going to stay warm in my smart car but I could not fit into it with my winter gear on and the battery died. I was going to light the car on fire like some people do to keep warm but then I remembered that there are toxins released by the blaze and thought I better be climate change responsible and burn some firewood to stay warm but there was no wood available…
I was going to go to the woods and get some firewood but I am not legally allowed to cut trees… So, I sat in the dark and thought warm thoughts about the great reset. Hopefully, there will be toilet there… I’ve used the last roll now in a makeshift heater… The flame is about to snuff out… And as the air around the flame starts to contract as the flame dies the snuffing sound reminds me of the vacuum of L-NDP politics - It all sucks.
Anyway, I am wondering when the reset will happen? I need to poop!
Up 49 Down 1
Executive Evasion on Dec 22, 2022 at 10:52 am
Competence comes from consequences. The CEO who failed to be the strategic planner they are required to be in their position should be fired immediately. They won’t be because this territory’s governments are entirely captured by the monopolies they complicity prop up. Who would the govvie-muckity-mucks work for after losing an election if they’d bothered to hold some of these entities to a reasonable standard? Expect this to keep happening.
To the Yukoners trapped in new all-electric builds, you’re going to need to form a very strong association to force accountability.
To the real workers, the power crews out there fixing things, you should get the CEO’s yearly bonus handed over and split up between you. You all are the ones who actually deserve it.
Up 45 Down 6
Jeff Bikaboom on Dec 22, 2022 at 10:10 am
This story should be a reality check for anyone who thinks green energy is a viable replacement for our current heating sources. Every electrically heated home in the Yukon should have a backup wood stove, propane heater, oil furnace, or gas powered generator. What if the power was out for longer and water pipes froze in hundreds of houses?
How will the Yukon handle thousands of electric cars, and the planned charging stations along the highways? How do the electric cars perform in this winter weather? How will the Yukon handle the needs of the next phases of whistle bend?
I suspect we have a choice between the billion dollar power line to Site C, or a technocratic management of resources allocated through surveillance and digital ID. The latter being feudalism, but with energy instead of land.
Or we could leave well enough alone because the Yukon switching to green energy is as useless as banning paper bags.
Up 22 Down 5
Dale on Dec 22, 2022 at 10:03 am
Pelly was without power for extended time, it was minus 50. It was a mess, we are used to being treated like 2nd class citizens in the communities but that was cold.
Up 35 Down 5
Salt on Dec 22, 2022 at 9:13 am
Ideologues are in full control of all levels of Western societies. They do not have the competence to manage the complex systems that they inherited from their predecessors. The inevitable result is decline. Due to leftist politics, YEC has been relying on luck the last five winters and the base load (gov driven immigration/electric heat) is only growing.
Up 48 Down 2
Alternative on Dec 22, 2022 at 7:26 am
I’ll never understand why nuclear energy is never explored as an option. The Russians own the north with their nuclear power, and here we are using hydro in one of the coldest climates on earth 🤣. Also the government making oil heating more expensive, making it harder to purchase wood. This country will never advance. There’s no hope at this point.
Up 48 Down 0
Margaret Brady on Dec 22, 2022 at 6:46 am
The major, widespread outage that lasted more than 4 hours actually took place on Sunday 18 not Monday. Minister Striecker is wrong. Communication from YEC an consumers was not appropriate. Also, it’s significant that YEC is aware that there are many newer homes, especially in Whistle Bend that rely on electricity for heating. Many (like ours) are not allowed alternative sources of power. This was ridiculous, as was the statement by the head of YEC that they were ‘surprised’ by the demand. That’s their job - to anticipate demand and provide a reliable supply. It’s NOT their job to be surprised at the demand during winter months.
Up 46 Down 2
Xristian Wolfe on Dec 22, 2022 at 12:35 am
Trying to be green without planning. Government forced people to give up wood and gas burning furnaces and replace them with electric heating without setting up the necessary replacement infrastructure.
Up 43 Down 4
Dan Nock3 on Dec 21, 2022 at 8:13 pm
And now add electric vehicles to the already overloaded grid!
Up 30 Down 3
But electric only is the way to go. It’s for the environment on Dec 21, 2022 at 7:54 pm
Maybe the government in power at the time, I believe YUKON party (so, not Liberals doing the evil for once) shouldn’t have made the decision to have a complete electric subdivision.
I wasn’t surprised at all when they went out during the coldest day at the peak hour of electricity (aka dinner time and house being warmed).
Are there any electric alternative houses in Whistlebend yet? Maybe they should be considered.
Up 31 Down 12
EJ on Dec 21, 2022 at 7:47 pm
“While ATCO Electric Yukon was providing ongoing updates on social media and responding to Yukoners’ direct concerns, Yukon Government has been silent on the matter,” said Clarke,"
Hearing from the power company is exactly who people should be hearing from. Directly from the source. There is no need to have government and politicians trying to quarterback the comms for such an occurrence. Grow up Yvonne and stop trying to use incidents like this for political gain.
Up 17 Down 18
Mark on Dec 21, 2022 at 5:48 pm
The one good thing about a power outage during an extreme weather condition is that some - at least for a period of time - are aware of their consumption and vulnerability. It is, however, to easy to resume back to the exact same consumption when the power returns, hence re-creating the same condition that may have caused the initial power outage.
As I write this, I am noting that 7 out of 10 of my neighbours closest to me have outside lights on AND during this peak usage time. What exactly is the utility of having these lights on when the street and front yards are lit up by street lights? Will it deter a break-in, are you expecting company, are politicians expected to be knocking on your door, will your vehicle be scared in the dark?
I do understand that not all power outages are caused by a supply issue, but based on the news article we are certainly heading in this direction. We can agree that no one wants rolling power outages or worse.
Can I ask that you take an inventory of what lights you have on now and consider that turning one or two off may contribute to a nice evening for all in our community.
Up 11 Down 33
iBrian on Dec 21, 2022 at 4:56 pm
@Yukoner
Salmon are worth more then the electricity generated from hydro dams.
People need to reduce their electrical consumption.
Those EV cars need solar panels on every square inch of up facing surface.
People need to reduce the sq Ft of living space, easier to heat, less energy to consume.
But, no
Up 29 Down 4
J2 on Dec 21, 2022 at 4:53 pm
"The official Opposition said Tuesday the incident proves the generators are unreliable."
Did they miss the fact that it wasn't the generators that caused the problem?
YEC, I suggest you add "reset protection settings" to your checklist of "things to do when it's going to be cold".
Up 40 Down 6
bruce bark on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:49 pm
Brilliant, we are maxed out on power, yet our illustrious liberal government are pushing electric snowmobiles, electric cars, and heat pumps. One would hope our politicians would have some critical thinking skills.....obviously not?????
Up 43 Down 2
Groucho d'North on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:48 pm
Perhaps this situation will tap the brakes on YG's over the cliff drive to get everybody converted to electrical power? Or not.
Up 21 Down 21
The sky is falling! on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:45 pm
Yvonne Clarke AKA Chicken Little
The power was out, no one froze, it was a minor inconvenience. Why is she so cringy about everything, she doesn’t even live in the riding.
Up 25 Down 6
It’s not an accident on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:38 pm
Freezing in the dark: all according to plan.
Up 33 Down 3
bonanzajoe on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:38 pm
Well, accidents happen. At least YEC got it fixed in a reasonable amount of time. Some times we don't give front line workers enough credit. Good job guys.
Up 33 Down 2
Unbelievable on Dec 21, 2022 at 3:17 pm
Un-effin-believable that they failed to anticipate the load. Un-effin-believable. Fb page says reliable energy… might want to change that claim. Who the f*** is on first? And how much is he/she getting paid to put Yukoners at such serious risk? House in PC went down to +10 last night with a brand new baby in it. Completely unacceptable!
Up 25 Down 5
another Yukoner on Dec 21, 2022 at 2:44 pm
This is all part of carbon emissions and reducing the footprint. What is that money your stealing from us doing? Oh so people should all put off doing dinner for their family, bathing their children for bed etc should put it off until midnight? HELLO glad you are nice and toasty and maybe you need to give people some money so they can all have a generator connected to their homes ( 10,000 plus) and that will run the basics like oven, heat and "some" lighting....
The next 40 below in January WILL YOU BE PREPARED NOW? or will we be left in the cold again...
PS, more outages occur in WINTER months that they do in SUMMER - WHY?
Up 29 Down 4
YXY on Dec 21, 2022 at 2:34 pm
“The Yukon Party, meanwhile, criticized the territorial government for its response to Monday’s outages…”
Of course they did, because that’s all the YP is capable of these days; endless outrage.
What did the YP do while in power to expand and update our grid?
Instead of endless criticizing, how about some productive collaboration. I mean, if you’re working for the Yukon, work with the party in power.
The libs aren’t any great shakes these days, but the YP aren’t any better and many of their members reached their best before date aeons ago.
We need some serious action on our electrical grid. As of today we were using 34MW of thermal. If Atlin is 8MW reliable power, that’s still a 26MW shortfall. That’s not going to get made up by wind generators or solar. We’d need another 4 Atlins (or Drury lakes) to meet that.
And seriously, YEC wasn’t prepared? I was prepared for this for God sakes, I just had to look at the forecast and our usage history.
Time for Mr Hall to be replaced.
Up 159 Down 13
Yukoner on Dec 21, 2022 at 2:03 pm
Build another large dam.. unfortunately none of our politicians have what it take to get us to a renewable reliable power supply. Endless consultation and useless stop gaps like the battery project, solar, Atlin, Haeckel hill turbines, on and on.