Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

EXPLAINING THE MECHANISM – The process of establishing a First Nations School Board is discussed at a news conference in June 2021. Left to right are Vuntut Gwitchin First Nation Chief Dana Tizya-Tramm, Education Minister Jeanie McLean; Grand Chief Peter Johnston of the Council of Yukon First Nations; Nicole Morgan, the deputy minister of Education; Melanie Bennett, the executive director of the First Nations Education Directorate; and elder Nia Breton.

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

Vote results called ‘a momentous occasion’

History was made Thursday as seven out of eight Yukon school districts voted in favour of creating a new First Nations School Board.

By Tim Giilck on January 28, 2022

History was made Thursday as seven out of eight Yukon school districts voted in favour of creating a new First Nations School Board.

For the last two weeks, Yukon residents in the eight districts have been voting – even through COVID-19 pandemic restrictions – in a referendum on whether they wanted to join/create a First Nations School Board. Elections Yukon organized the referendum.

In Whitehorse, the tally was 135 to 100 for the Grey Mountain Primary School. At Takhini Elementary, the numbers were 141 to 49.

The new board is expected to be in operation by the start of the 2022-2023 school year.

Little will change initially, as the schools will continue to operate as normal under a new administration, according to Katharine Sandiford, the director of communications for the First Nations Education Directorate.

She said the immediate next steps for the new board will be to organize an election of trustees to operate it.

Those trustees will then pick a chief executive officer, who will be the sole full-time permanent position, at least initially.

The new board will operate under the same British Columbia curriculum that every school in the Yukon uses, Sandiford said.

She doesn’t expect to see any staffing changes to start with, and perhaps none in the near future.

The sole difference in operations will be in administration, and in programming, Sandiford explained.

While the same standards will be maintained, how the lessons are carried out may differ substantially.

Sandiford said, for example, a lesson in mathematics might consist of plotting a route to a lake where the students were planning to meet with an elder. Or, the class might simply be taken outside.

Education Minister Jeanie McLean said in a statement, “Last night marked a historic moment in the Yukon, as we received the preliminary results of the referendum on the First Nation School Board.

“These results show that seven school communities have voted yes to have their schools operated by the new Yukon First Nation School Board,” she said.

“The official results of the referendum process will be announced on Jan. 31, and we will have more information to share at that time.

“This is a major step in the right direction as we move forward in advancing the path to reconciliation,” McLean said.

“A path that was started 49 years ago with the historic document Together Today for our Children Tomorrow. The establishment of a Yukon First Nation School Board will contribute to and improve the educational outcomes for all students across the territory.”

As Yukoners, McLean said, “We should be proud of the milestone we have achieved today.

“This is a momentous occasion, and I congratulate all schools that will be joining the new First Nation School Board.

“We remain committed to working collaboratively over the days and months ahead as the school board is established and these schools make the successful transition.”

The process of establishing a First Nations School Board has been formally underway since last June. The announcement then outlined a nine-step process to establish the board.

“Signatories to the agreement, representing 10 Yukon First Nations and the Government of Yukon, seek to address longstanding concerns about unacceptable education outcomes for First Nations students,” the statement added at the time.

The new board will emphasize culturally-based programming, including on-the-land sessions. Elders will play an important role as well.

First, school councils need to hold discussions and pass a resolution supporting the creation, she told reporters.

Byelections for school council members would be next, then a host of more technical requirements, including curriculum approval and geographic locations would be required.

In 2018, the Chiefs Committee on Education was re-established to negotiate a framework agreement for First Nations education.

In 2019, the committee and the government agreed to explore the creation of a Yukon First Nation School Board under the longstanding provisions of the Education Act. This collaboration resulted in the Framework Agreement to establish the Yukon First Nation School Board.

The results will be finalized on Monday.

The only community to reject joining the new board was Mayo. The numbers there were 116 to 33 in declining the board.

Voters in Old Crow voted 44 to four in favour.

In Watson Lake, the vote was 96 to 60.

In Beaver Creek, the vote was unanimous amongst the 14 voters.

In Ross River, the numbers were 56 to one.

In Haines Junction, the votes were 215 to 153.

“The results are a testament to the dissatisfaction that Yukoners have with the education system,” Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon told the Star at noon today. “But it’s an exciting time for education in the Yukon.”

“It’s a reminder that the status quo isn’t good enough, especially for First Nations students. The status quo isn’t working.”

NDP Leader Kate White posted her excitement at the news on social media.

“Wonderful and exciting news to start the day! Eight Yukon schools will be joining the First Nations School Board. This is an amazing moment in history for Yukon First Nations and Yukon Schools!”

Ted Hupé, the president of the Yukon Association of Education Professionals, said he had spent some time looking over the agreement on the new board, and saw little to concern his members.

They will remain union members and government employees, he said, while simply serving under a new administration.

“There will be some growing pains,” he told the Star. “But things will continue as usual. For our members, nothing has changed.

“We always considered this as an evolutionary inevitability,” he added. “We knew it would come someday, but we didn’t know when.”

Result will be unofficial until Monday.

See letter.

Comments (17)

Up 12 Down 3

Jim dandee on Feb 3, 2022 at 9:05 am

What is next, Jim Crow laws? I find this segregation of schools based on ethnicity profoundly disturbing.
Every bureaucrat and politician has to put on their progressive hat for this issue without thought to the long term consequences for our society and the educational outcomes of the students involved. This has been poorly thought out as witnessed by the inane comments we have seen by some of the proponents. The poor educational outcomes for FN kids is a multi factorial issue. It will not be solved by segregation, identity politics and lowering standards.

Up 9 Down 6

Spirit Bear does not like racism! on Feb 1, 2022 at 10:14 am

To - Let’s divide our efforts further on Jan 30, 2022 at 2:29 am

Spirit Bear can be a force for good. A rallying point for Caucasian Pride and Unity!

Due to a recessive gene, 20% of the Kermode bear population in North America are born with white fur. These bears are often termed to look ghostly in the dense rainforest due to their white fur. As a result, they have named spirit bears (or the White Kermode) as a tribute to their ghostly white fur.

According to native legends, spirit bears could swim deep underwater and lead people to magical places. Legend also has it that Raven, the Creator, made every tenth black bear on one island white as a reminder of the last ice age, which was 10,000 years ago.

Spirit Bears are genetically defective. This gives them their white appearance. The parallel between whiteness (Europeans ) and their ability to swim/dive to magical places and their arrival on Turtle Island (North America) in ships is a metaphor for contact between First and Second and Third peoples.

The aboriginal inhabitants of Turtle Island saw the link between whiteness and recessive genes as indicative of whiteness as defect/anomalous - It was the first racism non-white to white racism in North America… As far as we know.

Anyways, Spirit Bear, has a lot to offer the education system in terms of correcting racialized attitudes… Every non-white culture has some sort of embedded anti-white sentiment. For example, the slaughter of Albino Africans, the Arab hatred for whites and on and on…

Hate is not colourblind… Hate sees all colours - Pink, white, red, brown, black, yellow etc. Spirit Bear is a reminder for everyone of the implicit reminder of racialized attitudes against the Caucasian minorities!

Up 17 Down 0

Groucho d'North on Feb 1, 2022 at 9:41 am

It's a rare opportunity that I agree with Mr. Living's comments here, but I am fully in support of his comments below regarding the value and the purpose of our education system. I sincerely hope the goals and objectives of this modified education curriculum is to produce students who have the skills and knowledge required to advance into the fields they may wish to pursue. The next generations are depending on decisions being made today - let's get it right for them.

Up 46 Down 1

Nathan Living on Jan 31, 2022 at 3:14 pm

I do hope this works.

What exactly is teaching children to study water? My understanding is that this type of study requires a sound baseline of mathematics, biology, chemistry and physics.

Students graduating from our schools should be able to go onto college or university without upgrading. This should be a principle of any change.

Please do not create a program that does not prepare students for an academic or employment life outside of the Yukon.

Up 31 Down 3

Rick S on Jan 31, 2022 at 11:52 am

Presumably, the majority of activist types who wanted this came to vote. I wonder how the silent majority of parents who didn't vote will vote in the real world when the rubber meets the road. I predict high registration demand in the unchanged districts.

Up 31 Down 6

Crunch on Jan 30, 2022 at 5:44 pm

All I can say is when the "whole language program" came into effect we had to teach our kids how to read and write at home. The experts really laid one on us with that brilliant piece of wisdom. Lord help everyone if this is the same.

Up 56 Down 9

Jim B on Jan 30, 2022 at 6:48 am

Looks like super low voter turnouts... hard to understand how a 10-20% voter turn out is enough to base decisions affecting the course of peoples lives on. Would have liked to see the results if it was joined with a territorial election.

Up 68 Down 13

Let’s divide our efforts further on Jan 30, 2022 at 2:29 am

I stopped listening when ‘spirit bear’ appeared in my son’s science text. I thank God my kids are through school in Yukon.

Up 49 Down 7

Vlad on Jan 29, 2022 at 12:01 pm

Hmm why wasn’t Elijah Smith included in this FN initiative? Why would Grey Mountain be included, doesn’t make sense from a demographic perspective.

Up 44 Down 8

iBrian on Jan 29, 2022 at 11:54 am

I did not find it appropriate that we had to put our names on the ballots we submitted. I also found it very odd that this was not more widely advertised that all people in the school districts were permitted to vote.
I hope for the best. I hope they increase the level of expectation. Have had student workers who were top grade students and still needed to do 2 years upgrades at Yukon College to get into a College in Ontario for environmental studies.
I hope they create special needs classes for the students that need the extra help.
For now on natives will not be able to accuse Cultural Appropriation when a non native sings in their tonge or draw in similar format. When all the children will be learning the same way.
I hope for the best.

Up 51 Down 7

martin on Jan 29, 2022 at 11:27 am

I wonder: if 10 years down the line, and this experiment doesn't work, are they going to revese it back?

Up 22 Down 43

Jack Smithe on Jan 28, 2022 at 8:42 pm

@Matthew. Just sounds like Matthew should have spent more time in school. We cannot afford a society with more Matthews.. yay, that's what we don't need, right..

Up 61 Down 10

Mr Facts on Jan 28, 2022 at 4:47 pm

"Something, something colonialism" OK, got it. #redtape

Up 85 Down 12

Concerned Citizen on Jan 28, 2022 at 4:33 pm

So Yukoners were asked to vote on and make a monumental decision, with no plan on how this will be funded, by whom, for whom, what will happen for staffing if the school board has control despite staff being under a collective agreement (remember - it was announced the board will have authority to hire, fire and demote), and no articulated plan - at all - as to what changes to curriculum will actually even look like. Blind voting. Brilliant strategy.

Up 49 Down 16

Poor little Paulie’s gone crackers! on Jan 28, 2022 at 4:29 pm

Currie, Currie, Currie… A handful of votes spread throughout the territory signal nothing… Other than perhaps, as exemplified in the current matter the imbalance of power between the gets and the get-nots.

Most people who are not under the experiential, touchy-feely, education as infotainment, kids will learn through osmosis delusion are very upset with the dumbing down of our education system.

Wow! Just wow! Kids need to learn but we don’t do that anymore. They must feel, and behave according to their whims… As it is at home so shall it be at school too… Chaos, pandemonium, executive dyscontrol… And messy spaces with adults picking up after them little-shyts!

The education system has done some significant psychological and intellectual damage which had been amplified through governmental incompetence; lockdowns, mask mandates, bankrupting the middle class, inflation, and the sociopathic sequelae associated with governmental incompetence.

The education system needs to return to its former days of learning… In the days before the insanity of wokeist politics where failing was allowed to happen so did learning. Now it’s, what do I need to know that for… In those days critical thinking was a learned skill. Today critical thinking has given way to the impulse of whatever makes you feel good!

Up 68 Down 9

Groucho d'North on Jan 28, 2022 at 3:33 pm

I hope the planing for this new educational direction includes waypoints were measurements are made to confirm if things are going to plan or not. Good performance means you have to stop and check the oil from time to time.
Best wishes to the folks involved in making this work.

Up 86 Down 32

Matthew on Jan 28, 2022 at 2:23 pm

Just sounds like printing more money we can't afford to do.. more people to ask before things get done.. yay, that's all we need right now..

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.