Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo Submitted

Coun. Dan Boyd and Ramesh Ferris

Snow-clearing issue put to bed – temporarily

After six long weeks, the City of Whitehorse has finally resolved its ongoing snow and ice control policy – after a fashion.

By T.S. Giilck on December 12, 2023

After six long weeks, the City of Whitehorse has finally resolved its ongoing snow and ice control policy – after a fashion.

Coun. Ted Laking introduced a motion Monday evening during the last regular council meeting of the year that put the matter to rest – at least temporarily.

Laking’s motion replaced one by his colleague Michelle Friesen, that has been on the books for some time, dating back to October, when the controversy first arose with council.

Friesen withdrew her motion in favour of Laking’s, which proved to be popular amongst virtually all of the councillors, with the exception of Kirk Cameron.

Laking’s motion called for the city to move $220,000 to the provisional budget to begin paying for increased maintenance on accessible parking spots and associated ramps and curb cuts.

The motion also earmarked an additional $30,000 to study the issue further, and report back in May 2024.

The motion, which drew praise from his colleagues for its simplicity after weeks of debate, also didn’t generate the usual amount of discussion that previous meetings had seen.

Coun. Dan Boyd said he was looking forward to supporting the motion.

For some years, he said, the city has been “having difficulty” in maintaining its accessible parking spots.

“It got particularly bad a few years ago when we got the extra snowfall.”

It’s continued to be a problem since, Boyd said.

The city need to treat the problem holistically, he added, rather than a series of individual challenges.

Coun. Joecelyn Curteanu said she was also looking forward to supporting the motion.

She said the city “needs action” now so the issue can be dealt with immediately.

Friesen asked when the work on the accessible spots would begin.

City manager Jeff O’Farrell said it would take at least two weeks for staff to prepare a plan on how to “apply” the $220,000.

He suggested the changes would likely begin in early January.

“That would be the city moving at lightning speed.”

When she withdrew her motion in favour of Laking’s, Friesen said, “It’s a way forward for action now.”

“It’s not fair that we keep putting people in this position. It’s been years. The policy as it’s written is failing our community.”

The text of the motion reads as follows:

“BE IT RESOLVED that council direct that the provisional 2024 operating budget be amended by allocating an additional $220K to provide additional resources to address accessibility concerns with respect to snow and ice removal and enforcement in respect of parking stalls, crosswalks, para-ramps, curbs, and bus stops, and sidewalks; and

 THAT council direct that the 2023 capital budget be amended to include a new project titled ‘Snow and Ice Control Accessibility Review’ for the purposes of completing a review of the Snow and Ice Control Policy, the Maintenance Bylaw, and the motion titled ‘Snow and Ice Control Policy Accessible Stalls’ using an accessibility lens, in the amount of $30,000, funded from the general reserve; and

 THAT administration be directed to return to council with the results and recommendations of this review by the end of May 2024.”

Boyd successfully proposed an amendment to the motion adding in sidewalks.

Ramesh Ferris, a leading advocate for proper snow and ice clearing on accessible spots, particularly downtown, wasn’t too impressed with the decision.

It’s only a start, he told the Star Tuesday.

Ferris said he’s concerned the money is guaranteed only for 2024, adding he considers the $30,000 to study the issue basically a waste of money.

Since the city has shown it’s capable of swiftly clearing active transport routes and trails around the city quickly and efficiently, he said, it’s shown it has the resources to do the same thing with accessible parking spots.

There’s nothing in Laking’s motion that prioritizes when those spots and associated ramps and curb cuts will be cleared, Ferris said.

He was also critical of how the money could be spent. He’s worried a considerable chunk could go to city bylaw officials and their campaigns to educate business owners on their responsibilities for clearing their properties.

“It falls short” of addressing the systemic issues facing people with disabilities, Ferris said.

He appeared before council as a delegate once again Monday, where he has spent several weeks trying to lobby the city to improve its clearing policies.

Ferris said the city is treating accessibility issues like a buffet – picking and choosing when disabled people can access various locations around the downtown core in particular.

Comments (8)

Up 10 Down 1

Anie on Dec 18, 2023 at 3:12 pm

COW used to have a committee to give advice about accessibility rights. People put their names forward, did the homework, made recommendations, and then quit in frustration, some complaining that those recommendations could not get past administration and so never got to the attention of council.

Up 17 Down 4

Guncache on Dec 15, 2023 at 6:52 pm

I was by the double lane bicycle path today. Nicely cleared and graveled. You couldn't slip if you tried. The cyclists are holding COW hostage. But wait, I've yet to see throngs of cyclists on the 2 lanes.

Up 5 Down 11

L Cabott on Dec 13, 2023 at 3:59 pm

The COW s moving quickly in the right direction, however, we have to do much more to ensure that people with mobility issues can easily get around our City.

Many issues have not been effectively dealt with by previous Councils. City Administration and Council are actively addressing these issues.

Recent record snowfall levels and the Clay Cliff landslides are related to Climate Change; our response is consistent with dealing with the Climate Change Emergency that the City of Whitehorse has declared.

Up 58 Down 9

Carmen on Dec 12, 2023 at 3:40 pm

Ramesh stated he’s also critical of how the money could be spent. He’s worried a considerable chunk could go to city bylaw officials and their campaigns to educate business owners on their responsibilities for clearing their properties.

You’re very right Ramesh. Very very accurate. The Bylaw department likes to waste money, time and resources by completing numerous types of “campaigns”, but when it comes to the actual completion of work for sidewalks and accessibility parking, the bylaw department never actually shows up and enforces these issues.

Up 72 Down 5

Heather on Dec 12, 2023 at 3:22 pm

Be it resolved that 30,000 is an absurd amount for an accessibility study in a town this size.

Up 46 Down 4

Nathan Living on Dec 12, 2023 at 2:25 pm

In my opinion, the issue of providing accessible parking areas and freedom of movement in Whitehorse for people with disabilities should not be an issue of dollars and cents.

Mayor and Council should direct Administration to consult directly with the affected parties and come up with a priority list of parking areas, sidewalks, and streets that should cleared after each snowfall.

Yes, their may be a tiered ranking, but many areas deserve the highest priority level to ensure that people with disabilities are afforded the highest level of unobstructed access.

Up 42 Down 7

Politico on Dec 12, 2023 at 2:25 pm

This has been the problem all along. Instead of actually solving the issue Council sticks a bandaid on it and passes on to the next Council. How about solving the issue but why would they. Continued employment and grandstanding!

Up 50 Down 12

Resident on Dec 12, 2023 at 1:57 pm

Just clear the downtown sidewalks and attach part of the cost to adjacent land owners because they directly benefit and the rest to general taxes because the general public benefits.

Don't like this idea? Complain to your fellow citizens who are too damn lazy and inconsiderate to do their part to help out each other. But then again that's a running trend lately, freedom without responsibility.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.