Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Dr. Sudit Ranade

Respiratory illnesses exerting significant impacts

The territory’s chief medical officer of health says we’re only at the beginning of a harsh season of respiratory illnesses that are stressing the health care system, pharmacies and schools.

By Ethan Lycan-Lang on December 12, 2022

The territory’s chief medical officer of health says we’re only at the beginning of a harsh season of respiratory illnesses that are stressing the health care system, pharmacies and schools.

After more than two years of pandemic regulations like masking and isolation that kept contagions more contained than usual, this fall, places around the world are dealing with a “tripledemic,” as the New York Times dubbed it – a rise in cases of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), COVID-19 and influenza.

And the Yukon isn’t immune. 

“We’re just staying very watchful,” Dr. Sudit Ranade, the Yukon’s chief medical officer of health, said in an interview last week.

“I think that many jurisdictions had a couple of weeks where their (health care) system was severely strained. And that strain seems to be reducing. We haven’t gotten to that point yet.”

Though it’s not clear whether respiratory viruses are more prevalent than they have been in the past, they’re certainly spreading more than they have in the past two flu seasons.

In fact, flu seasons practically disappeared during the first two years of the COVID-19 pandemic, when governments across the world, including the Yukon, introduced restrictions to prevent the spread of airborne illnesses.

But the Yukon, like other jurisdictions around Canada and the world, eased its public health restrictions this year. The state of emergency ended in March, along with mask mandates and vaccine requirements.

Then, in November, the territory shifted its pandemic strategy to handle COVID-19 like any other respiratory illness, reducing testing and isolation requirements.

As a result, the Yukon’s hospitals, pharmacies and schools are feeling extra strain this fall.

Ranade said it’s unsurprising to see respiratory illnesses resurge as the territory’s pandemic response changes.

“When we relaxed restrictions on the ways in which people can get together, then we’re going to see a rise in all of the respiratory viruses that would have been transmitted normally,” he told the Star.

Ranade said reinstating health regulations like mask mandates and physical distancing measures would be difficult to impose after more than two years of pandemic-related regulations.

Pandemic fatigue, he said, has reduced the public’s appetite for renewed restrictions. 

In a news conference on Nov. 25, Canada’s chief public health officer, Dr. Theresa Tam, addressed a rise in respiratory illnesses across the country this fall.

She encouraged Canadians to take precautions against the rise in respiratory illnesses this season, but didn’t signal a return to health-related mandates.

Speaking of RSV, influenza, and coronavirus strains, Tam said “there is an increased likelihood that we will encounter one or more of these viruses as we interact with others in schools, workplaces and social settings – especially indoors and if masks are not being worn.” 

She urged Canadians to stay up to date on vaccinations and voluntarily take precautions like masking up to reduce this flu season’s impact on the country’s “extremely stretched health systems.”

Here in the Yukon, shortages of hospital beds and health care workers, along with an absence of any walk-in clinic in the territory, are already making it difficult for Yukoners to access medical services. A bad flu season could make things even worse.

Influenza A is already circulating at significant levels in the territory, and several seriously ill children have had to be medevaced to B.C. Children’s Hospital in Vancouver.

More than 3,000 Yukoners are currently on the territory’s waitlist for a family doctor, meaning emergency rooms are overburdened by people seeking non-emergency services like prescriptions for antibiotics.

Ranade also said if more people need to be admitted to hospitals for treatment of respiratory illnesses, capacity could become an issue fast.

The Yukon Hospital Corp. (YHC) website has indicated that inpatient beds at Whitehorse General have been extremely limited since at least Dec. 1, though space at the Dawson City and Watson Lake community hospitals was still shown to be available earlier this week.

In an email to the Star, YHC spokesperson Isaac MacDonald said Whitehorse General’s emergency department “is seeing an increasing number of patients coming in with flu-like symptoms.

“We anticipate a significant flu season this year with higher than average respiratory illness cases,” the email said.

MacDonald added that numbers are higher than they were in the pandemic, but in line with years before COVID-19 restrictions.

Still, he said, longer emergency wait times may be coming as a result.

Case numbers for respiratory illnesses in the territory seem small – between Nov. 15 and today, the Yukon reported 84 influenza cases, 24 COVID cases and four RSV cases – but those figures don’t paint the full picture, Ranade noted.

“There are still a substantial portion of people who would have these diseases, but whose symptoms are mild enough that they would not present to a place where they would get tested,” he said. 

At the beginning of November, the total number of officially confirmed Yukon COVID-19 cases stood at 4,983.

Figures from Yukon classrooms are more illustrative of the toll this year’s respiratory season is taking on the territory.

For the first two weeks of November, about 23 per cent of students at Yukon schools were absent for at least part of the first two weeks of November, according to figures provided by the Department of Education in an email last Monday.

Those numbers are actually similar to last year’s average from the same time last year, but Ted Hupé, the president of the Yukon Association of Education Professionals, said some classrooms have been hit harder than others.

While the overall average is not unusual, Hupé  said he’d heard from rural classrooms that have had up to 80 per cent of students out sick.

That’s made it hard to staff schools, he said. 

“(When students get sick) it’s usually followed by teacher absenteeism a few days later or a week later, because schools are one big Petri dish on a good day,” he said.

That’s led to teachers covering each other’s classes in some instances.

“The system doesn’t have the capacity to cover all the bases,” he said, adding that he hopes the upcoming holiday break will help ease the spread of illnesses.

“Christmas is coming at a good time.”

Joanne Gibson, the president of the Yukon Pharmacists Association, said pharmacies are having trouble staying staffed with pharmacists out sick or having to stay home with sick kids unable to go to daycare.

She also said pharmacists are working to ensure they have enough antibiotics in stock to treat respiratory infections as more Yukoners seek treatment.

Gibson said she hopes pharmacists could bring some relief to emergency rooms and doctors later this month though.

Starting Dec. 28, she noted, pharmacists will be able to make prescriptions for minor ailments.

Though they won’t be able to prescribe antibiotics, necessarily, she hopes the new authority will take some of the burden off doctors working to treat more serious issues. (See Gibson’s column on flu shots, p. 7.)

That could be a big help because, according to Ranade, the Yukon is just at the beginning of its respiratory illness season – and Yukoners need to prepare.

Aside from getting vaccinated against COVID-19 and influenza – Health and Social Services reports only 8,610 Yukoners have received their flu shot since roll-outs started in October – Ranade recommended Yukoners take preventative health care action this respiratory season.

A balanced diet, regular sleep and exercise prepare the immune system to handle viruses, Ranade said. 

When vaccinations and a healthy lifestyle fail to stave off sickness, Ranade said, it’s important that people isolate themselves from others as best they can, and mask up when they have to go out in public for groceries and other necessities.

“I think it’s the simple, practical things that we’re going to start kind of continuing to reinforce,” he said.

“But they’re the things that I think people have been more attuned to over the last couple of years.”

Comments (20)

Up 2 Down 1

The thinks we can think if only we think… on Dec 18, 2022 at 10:35 pm

Oh, oh - Oh, the comments! on Dec 16, 2022 at 7:58 am. According to Health Canada you are wrong:

“Pre-exposure immunization for high risk persons produces rabies neutralizing antibodies. Post-exposure prophylaxis is highly effective in preventing rabies”.
Why are people given a voice to be wrong. Why do stupid people insist they are right?

According to Dunning and Krueger:

“The Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias whereby people with low ability, expertise, or experience regarding a certain type of task or area of knowledge tend to overestimate their ability or knowledge.”

Resources:
https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/publications/healthy-living/canadian-immunization-guide-part-4-active-vaccines/page-18-rabies-vaccine.html

Up 4 Down 9

Oh, the comments! on Dec 16, 2022 at 7:58 am

and the thought processes behind the comments. Douglas Martens, rabies vaccinations are about survival, not 'catching' it when bitten by a rabid animal (it prevents death in about 98% of cases, pretty effective).

In any pandemic there are about 85-90% of people who will take vaccines, or clean their water, or whatever the 'cure is found to be. Of the remaining 10-15%, about half will take a 'wait and see' attitude for more evidence. And the remaining 5-7% will decide they won't trust anyone, and will give money to grifters for magical cures (or become a grifter themselves), and loudly defend their choice, whether on a soapbox or letters to a newspaper or (now) social media. So with covid, and the cray-cray percentage, guess we're right on track

Up 41 Down 13

Douglas Martens on Dec 13, 2022 at 2:14 pm

if you had your favorite pet vaccinated for rabies and six months later it got rabies, would you have any questions for your veterinarian?

Up 29 Down 9

John on Dec 13, 2022 at 11:43 am

North of 60 - You are absolutely wrong. Influenza is viral. Studies suggest that people with low blood levels of vitamin D are more likely to get sick.
A far cry from what what you have stated.
Maybe lay off the Wikipedia and consult a credible source before posting such dangerous nonsense.

Up 32 Down 7

Rick S on Dec 13, 2022 at 10:25 am

For all the parents out there, in Moderna's pediatric trials there was a 400% and 300%+ increase in RSV and pneumonia, respectively, in the vaccine vs. placebo group. These increases were not associated with the vaccine, in the opinion of Moderna's own investigator employees. At the same time, the FDA stated Moderna should continue to monitor these signals (duh!).

https://www.fda.gov/media/159611/download

Up 38 Down 27

Anonymous on Dec 13, 2022 at 9:08 am

I still can't fathom how masks can be mandatory in restaurants, but you can take them off when sitting down at the table. The same goes for curfews, as if Covid only spreads during certain hours of the day. It's a complete farce. Laughable.

Unvaxxed: get covid
Vaxxed: still get covid, also get mycarditis and a list of 1000 other symptoms

Up 37 Down 32

DL on Dec 12, 2022 at 8:36 pm

Oh really? The jabs reduce illness? Since they are claiming that the majority of Yukoners have been jabbed for covid, then explain why more people are sick this year?

I'm an unjabbed senior, and for the past two years I never followed restrictions, and did not wear masks. I socialized closely with like-minded folks many of whom had travelled outside the Yukon (by car). Yes, we had indoor dinner parties and we hugged. A lot. We also took extra Vitamin D, and Ivermectin, as preventatives. And we're doing fine healthwise to this day. Looks like we're doing much better than the jabbed.

But hey, why leave us guessing... be specific! The CMO has a professional and moral obligation to tell us how many among these new cases have been jabbed for covid and/or the flu. Because right now it looks like these shots weaken the immune system, and it's better to stay away from that stuff.

We don't need mumbo jumbo about 'science'. Give us specific illness DATA as per categories of jabbed and unjabbed (which is what real science is about). When are reporters going to ask these questions. It's about transparency. Might even be a matter of life and death.

Up 21 Down 15

Guncache on Dec 12, 2022 at 8:03 pm

Dr Sudit Ranade, our new Liberal leader

Up 30 Down 21

bonanzajoe on Dec 12, 2022 at 7:26 pm

Forcing children and adults to wear masks for so long, it is not surprising that respiratory illnesses are on the increase. But, notice now how the Liberals are trying to worm their way out of any responsibility and blame.

Up 28 Down 15

JohanG on Dec 12, 2022 at 7:08 pm

Yes, Influenza is a vitamin D deficiency disease. This is proven by tens of thousands of empirical studies by medical scientists far more qualified than the few 'down-thumbs' who can't follow a link and read the truth. Don't let ignorance keep you sick every winter, educate yourself and be healthy.
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Influenza++vitamin+D+deficiency+&btnG=

Up 28 Down 14

Matthew on Dec 12, 2022 at 6:47 pm

Funny how EVERYTHING was Covid for 2 years straight. Now the flu is back with another RSV too.. hmmm.. maybe, all 3 were there all along...

Up 24 Down 14

J2 on Dec 12, 2022 at 6:21 pm

If the flu is due to a vitamin D deficiency, why is it also found in Mexico, the Caribbean, Central America, Florida, etc.?

Up 35 Down 20

I am Medicus on Dec 12, 2022 at 6:11 pm

Yeah, it’s funny how cutting off their oxygen for two years running and leveling their immune systems lead to respiratory problems. I wonder if it’s also tenuously related to the emergence of childhood heart attacks, strokes & dementia? I don’t know about you sheeple, but I ❤️ Oxygen.

Up 37 Down 21

Juniper Jackson on Dec 12, 2022 at 5:32 pm

I am reluctant to give any credence to politicians like this one. He is actually saying, with a straight face, we didn’t have any flu for 2 years because we were forced to wear masks. The truth is, we had flu ok..but it was all written off as Covid-19’. It probably still is. All of these attention seeking comedians/politicians are constantly skating around locking us up again, forcing masks..you know, reducing personal freedoms. Canada has already lost its top 10 standing as a democratic country and is now described a the 13 th most corrupt country in the world. If the Liberals are bucking for last place, woo hoo..they finally win at something.

Up 26 Down 34

Roy on Dec 12, 2022 at 5:28 pm

how do the "masks don't work / we don't need any restrictions or changes in behaviour" freedumb fighters explain the drop in flu, cold, and RSV numbers during the past two years?

what caused these numbers to drop?
No need to mention covid or the vaccines or the liberals or inflation or truckers in your answers - those are obvious attempts to distract and pivot away from the question:

What caused the significant decrease in respiratory infections during those two years?
press thumbs down if you don't want to answer because it will upset your fragile world view

Up 28 Down 18

Jeff Bikaboom on Dec 12, 2022 at 4:39 pm

"A balanced diet, regular sleep and exercise prepare the immune system to handle viruses, Ranade said"
It took three years but they finally said it. Don't forget experimental gene therapy, you need that too.

There are a lot of sick people everywhere right now and most of them have something in common. There is, however, a certain demographic that is fairing much better than the rest of people and putting less strain on the health care system in Canada and world wide. Congratulations to these people.

"Here in the Yukon, shortages of hospital beds and health care workers"
Then perhaps now is not the time to be focusing on gender affirming services. Should resources be put towards free tracheal shaves, facial feminization, body contouring, and vocal surgery when the system is so strained that the idea of bringing back medical tyranny is being entertained? By all means allocate resources for the mental health of these people.

"Pandemic fatigue, he said, has reduced the public’s appetite for renewed restrictions."
Correct. As more people are disillusioned, their appetites are now for accountability. It must be a rude awakening for those with perceived authority when they realize the majority of people don't care what they have to say.

Up 27 Down 29

Politico on Dec 12, 2022 at 4:31 pm

@ DR Richard Smith As usual anti vaxxers provide no credible evidence of their claims. Just take their word for it, they wouldn't lie. Time to get out the bleach and the ivermectin.

Up 28 Down 10

Groucho d'North on Dec 12, 2022 at 4:11 pm

Just under a month ago there was a story about children's medications being very hard to acquire influencing today's situation. There was no mention in the article above if these medications are now available to the public. What's the story today? Anybody know?
https://www.whitehorsestar.com/News/details-of-emergency-medication-shipments-remain-unknown

Up 40 Down 42

North_of_60 on Dec 12, 2022 at 3:51 pm

Influenza is a vitamin D deficiency disease, but not one mention here of the widespread vitamin D deficiency among Yukoners every winter.
But hey, taking cheap and effective vitamin D won't make BigPharma and their lapdog vax-pushers rich will it?
Masks only work to reduce the spread of infection to others from coughs and sneezes when you are sick.

Up 53 Down 51

Richard Smith on Dec 12, 2022 at 3:29 pm

This article of massive respitory illnesses fails to answer the question on everybody's mind - "what percentage of these sick people received vaccinations and boosters for covid?"
There are many reports most are vaccinated.
The fact that the medical community fails to release these stats is an admission the covid vaccines are causing these respitory illnesses or, at best, they don't work at all.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.