Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker

Renewable energy plans spur brusque exchange

The general ambience of snarkiness permeating the Yukon legislative assembly was on full display recently as Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker presented a statement on the government’s renewable energy projects.

By Tim Giilck on October 25, 2021

The general ambience of snarkiness permeating the Yukon legislative assembly was on full display recently as Energy, Mines and Resources Minister John Streicker presented a statement on the government’s renewable energy projects.

“The purpose of today’s ministerial statement is to provide an update on some of these community renewable energy projects,” Streicker said.

“These projects include: the four-megawatt wind farm project on Haeckel Hill that is now under construction; the proposed 2.85-megawatt solar project in the off-grid community of Watson Lake; and the currently operational 940-kilowatt solar array with battery system in Old Crow.”

In this fiscal year, he said, the program is supporting a variety of different proponents, including:

• the Klondike Development Organization for a 309-kilowatt solar project in Dawson City;

• the Solstice Clean Energy Cooperative for a community-owned solar farm; and

• Mgrid Energy for a feasibility study that will look at converting former brownfield in Carcross into a solar project.

“The initiative supports the territory’s goal to have 97 per cent of our energy generated from renewable sources and to have independent power production in all off-grid communities by 2030,” Streicker said.

“These goals are part of the territory-wide Our Clean Future strategy. The strategy is our Yukon approach to tackling the climate crisis, and this initiative will play a key role in helping to meet our targets.”

It didn’t take long for the discussion to turn sarcastic.

“This Liberal government continues to pat themselves on the back for their green energy project work, but the results are limited,” Yukon Party MLA Geraldine Van Bibber said in response to Streicker’s comments.

“This announcement today appears to be more of the same. It’s a new study to study the old study on green energy.

“It’s like a Russian nesting doll, where every study leads to another study, but we never see action.

“At the same time, we see the Liberals constantly increasing our electrical rates for Yukoners,” Van Bibber added.

“Under this government, we saw the Liberals increase electrical rates by 12 per cent in 2019. This year, the Liberal government is seeking to increase them even further by 11.5 per cent.

“According to the Yukon Energy application, Yukoners could see that increase applied to bills this December 1, 2021, with potential retroactive payments included. This means that the Liberals are giving Yukoners a lump of coal for Christmas with a brand new rate hike.

“Can the minister guarantee that his announcement today won’t result in additional rate applications to increase power rates?”

Streicker said: “I’ll just mention some of the projects that are not about planning; they are in the construction phase. Haeckel Hill wind farm — they are up there today, up at the top of the hill, working to install four megawatts. I got some recent reports on the work that is ongoing. They are actually putting up the work as we speak.

“The Dawson solar, I think, is electrifying next week, so it’s here.”

As noted by Van Bibber, the minister said, the Old Crow solar and battery project started this past summer.

“It is great that there are times now when we don’t have the diesels running in Old Crow. I think that’s a great thing.”

As for power rates, Streicker said, “I took a look at the rates that she is talking about and I saw that increase.

“I asked — to try to dig into that a bit — to try to understand what the cause of that rate increase was. The largest factor that I saw was the LNG plant, which came before I was ever elected into this legislature (in 2016).

“The challenge is that it didn’t go to rate right away. The members opposite actually pushed those rates down, and I think that’s the wrong thing to do.

“We need to make sure that we allow the costs that are being accrued to come to rate over time so that we don’t get big jumps,” Streicker added.

“I think the point is that we need to see the work being done and decided upon by the Yukon Utilities Board, Yukon Energy, and through the 10-year renewable plan and Our Clean Future — that, over time, we see those changes.”

He said he will research the answer to the question about the diesel generators.

“Of course, it is our goal to get off of diesel generation. It is stated in Our Clean Future.”

NDP MLA Emily Tredger said, “Last summer, the diesel generators in Old Crow fell silent for the first time in 50 years. That is real leadership in moving away from fossil fuels.

“First Nations and communities continue to lead the way. Projects in communities from across the Yukon have applied for funding through the Innovative Renewable Energy Initiative to develop proposals and get them off the ground,” Tredger added.

“Because of their work, we’ll see more wind and solar projects across the territory. That means less fossil fuels burned, less fuel trucked along the highways.

“I hope that soon, across our communities, diesel generators will power down one by one, leaving room for the sounds of nature instead of the sounds of machines.”

These are the kinds of projects required to reach the target of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 45 per cent, Tredger said.

Comments (9)

Up 4 Down 3

JC on Oct 29, 2021 at 7:14 am

99% of energy is needed when there is limited daylight?

Gliding past the requirement to define "limited" in this context, this is just an absurd statement. We're using 62% of the power in June that we use at peak in February. That's still a lot of power. Moreover, anyone who pays attention to, oh, I dunno, the SKY, knows that there is plenty of daylight, even in winter. It's really just October-February where we see the deep darkness, and even then, there is still daylight. Ask anyone with solar panels or evacuated tube heaters.

BiNgOoOoOoOoOo

Up 6 Down 3

JC on Oct 29, 2021 at 7:06 am

Hey BananasJoe

Most Yukoners are out of work or in low paying jobs?
Gonna need a citation for that, fella

Up 11 Down 8

North_of_60 on Oct 27, 2021 at 6:58 pm

Everywhere across the world wind turbines fail to provide the power expected for the 20-25 year lifetimes that wind power proponents base their economic analysis on. After 10-12 years almost all wind turbines experience bearing and blade degradation that reduces their power output to about half. At that point they don't produce enough revenue to pay for their upkeep, and expensive bearing and blade replacements are not economically justified.

The documented history of wind farms shows they don't produce enough electricity to pay for their manufacture, installation and ongoing maintenance. The extra cost of decommissioning and salvage is passed on to ratepayers and taxpayers. The newer, cheaper Chinese wind turbines have even shorter lifetimes, which is not surprising to anyone who understands the Chinese attitude toward quality control. By the time the Haeckel Hill wind farm fails in 10 years or less, the MLAs and government bureaucrats who foisted this wind folly on Yukoners will be gone and living comfortably on their generous pensions. They don't care; it doesn't affect them.

Up 18 Down 4

Groucho d'North on Oct 27, 2021 at 9:54 am

Again all the chatter about potential technologies for meeting Yukon's energy needs into the future and the nuclear option is not even on the table for discussion. So when Streicker or any of his ilk say they are studying all the options- don't believe them.

Up 26 Down 9

Bingo on Oct 26, 2021 at 12:59 pm

Not a bad idea to offset the summers with Solar and the like BUT we require 99% of our energy when there is limited daylight, limited hydro and a huge rise in the consumption of diesel, that's why there are 17 mobile gen sets strategically placed all over the Yukon to make up for the demand which increases with every "green" house built in Whistlebend. Optically sensitive Governments aka Left wingers will spends billions which will not make one dent in the Global evolution.

Up 30 Down 3

Oya on Oct 26, 2021 at 11:55 am

@ Nathan. What he’s saying here is: increases are ok in his mind. The issue is spacing them out so people aren’t hit too hard in one year. He may be honest, but he’s allowing these EXORBITANT increases without going to bat for Yukoners. My electric bill went from $130/mo to $170/mo (and we turn all lights off and conserve as much as possible). Now he’s saying the rates will increase that much again so I can soon expect power bills in the $200-210 range (not electric heat so no comments please about how low my bill is compared to Whistle Bend people).
This is highway robbery and this government is facilitating that hardship for Yukoners. Soon, only politicians with secured pension will be able to afford living in the Yukon! John is a great person, I agree, but he’s NOT making things better for Yukoners!

Up 16 Down 11

Wilf Carter on Oct 26, 2021 at 7:55 am

I like the direction we going in but here some interesting opportunities for Yukon:
Climate change is not a crises in Yukon according to real science like George Moore one of the founders of Green Piece and strong environmentalist on climate.

We need more environmental friendly hydro projects all across the Yukon.
We need energy banks of solar and wind on each house in Yukon connected to the grid.

The wind mills going up on Heckel hill are not environmental friendly and cause more damage than diesel. Interesting part is they use a lot of oil to keep them running all the time. Second they are only 33% reliable far as producing energy goes as hydro is 90% and LNG 100%

LNG reduces carbon much more than diesel and we have gas right under City of Whitehorse. Cost would be much less for lower our energy rates if we used our own gas but government is not thinking through all the great opportunities for Yukoners future.

Why not water run hydro project where you don't use dams but just divert some water to create energy. It works great.
There are so many better opportunities out there but we should be working with Alaska, BC and western Canada as a team to develop a cost effective energy supply instead of going it on our own. Why are we not doing that politicians?

Up 23 Down 13

bonanzajoe on Oct 25, 2021 at 9:13 pm

With most Yukoners out of work or in low paying jobs - with the exception of the high paid government workers, how does this mentally dysfunctional Liberal government expect them to pay for high priced "renewable energy"? I guess they haven't figured that one out yet. And can they tell us how many jobs will be created in this field. Afraid to touch that topic I'm sure. Don't want to distract attention from "climate change".

Up 26 Down 49

Nathan Living on Oct 25, 2021 at 5:06 pm

John Streicker is an honest person. Please let him do to his research on why ratepayers will be faced with rate increases.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.