Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

HOME AGAIN – Dr. Xiu-Mei Zhang, seen in her Whitehorse office in July, will no longer be forced to practise in the Northwest Territories after changes were made to Yukon legislation.

Physician was ‘shocked' to hear good news

A Whitehorse doctor forced to move her practice to the Northwest Territories is once again able to practise medicine in the Yukon thanks to changes to the Yukon Medical

By Ashley Joannou on September 2, 2011

A Whitehorse doctor forced to move her practice to the Northwest Territories is once again able to practise medicine in the Yukon thanks to changes to the Yukon Medical

Act which came into effect last week.

Among the amendments is one which allows physicians who receive full licensure in any province or territory to be accepted to work in the Yukon.

The changes come almost six months after Dr. Xiu-Mei Zhang was forced to relocate her practice to the Northwest Territories after her special licence to practise medicine in the Yukon expired.

Zhang was trained as a medical doctor in China before moving to Whitehorse 20 years ago with her husband, Jim.

Once in Whitehorse, she practised Eastern medicine at the pair's East West Health Centre. In 2005, she added Western medicine to her practice thanks to the introduction of the special licensing program.

The program allowed foreign doctors to work five years in the territory, but they must successfully complete a two-day College of Family Physicians of Canada exam to keep working after that.

Zhang said she was not aware of the exam.

In 2006, the territory suggested she attend the Western Alliance for Assessment of International Physicians, a Health Canada program, billed as a way to help foreign doctors get practice-ready.

After passing those tests, Zhang thought she had done everything the government required. So when she was told she needed to take the national exam, she was unprepared and failed.

A second attempt to take the test came days after her mother died, and she failed again.

However, since each province and territory sets its own policies regarding foreign-trained doctors, Zhang chose to begin working in the Northwest Territories. There, her experience was enough to get her fully licensed without the national exam.

After months working away from home, Zhang received a phone call Wednesday from Dr. Bruce Beaton, chair of the Yukon Medical Council, letting her know her Northwest Territories licence is now enough to allow her to work in Whitehorse.

"I was shocked. I wasn't prepared to hear the news like that,” Zhang said Thursday from her home in Whitehorse. "I am so happy to be back.”

Since moving to the Northwest Territories, Zhang has been commuting back and forth between her work and her family in Whitehorse.

She said she hopes to be back in the Yukon permanently by the start of 2012 and return to the downtown Whitehorse clinic where she worked before leaving.

"The clinic was so supportive during all this, I really appreciate everything they did for me,” she said.

Meanwhile, patients are relieved and excited to have their doctor back.

"I just about jumped up and down when I heard,” longtime Whitehorse resident Michael Brine said Thursday.

Brine called the veteran doctor's forced departure "absolutely crazy,” adding that Zhang provided an important service to Whitehorse thanks to her knowledge of both Eastern and Western medicine.

"We should have the free will to decided how we want to be treated,” he said.

When the news first broke that Zhang was leaving Whitehorse, angry patients, upset their doctor could practise in one territory but not the Yukon, sent a petition with more than 150 names to the territory's top politicians calling for a change.

From there, Zhang's story has appeared in media across the country as well as in four daily newspapers in China.

Health and Social Services Minister Glenn Hart insists changes to the act were in the works for years, and not prompted by public pressure created by Zhang's story.

"We began public consultation on the act from April to May 2008,” he told the Star Thursday.

Hart said the changes bring the Yukon into compliance with Canadian labour mobility provisions under the Agreement on Internal Trade.

"What it does do is it allows us to recruit and retain quality physicians from across the country,” he said.

Currently, all provinces and territories except Nunavut have accepted the principle that a fully licensed physician in one jurisdiction should be eligible for a full licence in other jurisdictions.

Back home, Zhang is just happy to move forward with the life she always intended to have in Whitehorse.

"Although I had many, many loss in one aspect this year, the love I received and the life experiences I had gained I treasured very much,” she said in an e-mail sent to friends following the news.

"... my heart is filled with the comfort and warmness of my family, friends and patients' support, now I (that) am called back.”

By ASHLEY JOANNOU

Star Reporter

Comments (9)

Up 0 Down 0

Lucy B on Sep 11, 2011 at 10:11 am

Dr. Zhang never "whinnying" anything as my understanding while I watched her story closely. In fact, I was amazed that she always seemed to accept her situation peacefully and went on with her life by working at NT. It was her patients who started speaking out how unfair for themselves - Dr. Zhang can work at NT, but leave her own patients here with no family doc...

It is her own choice to decide whether taking further exam or whether coming back to work. Although she is able to receive a Yukon license now, currently she still chose to work at NWT as a MD since she is happy with her work there. However, nobody can stop her from coming back if she wants to since Yukon finally caught up with the national labor mobility agreemment. In fact, nobody can stop any other MDs, who have the same qualification as Dr. Zhang's, to work in Yukon under this new agreement or new law. It has nothing to do with Zhang's exam or her patient's complaints. It is the national law which had been worked by YTG for the last 3 years and now it finally went through.

I surely wish Dr. Zhang will come back to work soon. I saw her a few times for myself and my kids. We all liked her and I can't wait to see her again!

Up 0 Down 1

Steve E on Sep 10, 2011 at 10:10 am

I personally would like to see how badly Zhang flunked the first two attempts she made at the exam before she started whinnying about the medical licensing process even though she was granted a third opportunity to write the same exam.

Up 0 Down 0

Jeff. S on Sep 9, 2011 at 1:40 pm

I am so happy for her! Many MDs practice family medicine in Yukon and/or other parts of Canada never need or never pass this exam. It is not a qualification exam which required for MD to practice medicine in Canada. It is an exam for becoming a certified member of The College of Family Physicians of Canada. Some doctor chose to be members and some don't; some become certified members who have CCFP in their titles( passed this exam ) and some are non-certified members ( without the exam, has CFPC titls ). Yukon require this exam mendatorily for some of the foreign physicians only. It is not required mendatorily by AB, BC, NT or many other provinces.

Any family doc who practices family medicine has to pass 2 parts of qualification exams before they can gain a license. My family doctor didn't have CCFP in his title and I trust him 100% since he did a great job for me and my family!

Up 0 Down 0

anonymous on Sep 6, 2011 at 7:23 am

So for five years it doesn't matter if they have passed this exam but after five years they have to pass this exam or they are not good enough to keep their practice open?!? LOL. Which is it? They need to pass this exam or they do not...you can't allow them to practice for five years no questions asked AND THEN ask them to pass an exam. Whitehorse is getting worse and worse. LOL.

Up 0 Down 0

jasmine b on Sep 5, 2011 at 9:16 am

Why do they have exams then if you don't need to pass them to practice? It seems strange. Will the Government be liable for allowing an unlicensed physician to practice if she makes a mistake? She must have made a few mistakes on her exams, why couldn't she make those on me?

Up 0 Down 0

Steve E on Sep 2, 2011 at 6:08 pm

Bottom line on this fiasco is that Zhang did not pass the appropriate exam and it looks like she never will, even though she has been given three opportunities. Amazing what can be accomplished as far a regulations go with elections looming on the horizon, eh Glenn. Mind you, Mr. Hart apparently insists changes to the act were in the works for years and not prompted by public pressure created by Zhang's story.

Up 0 Down 0

bobby bitman on Sep 2, 2011 at 11:46 am

'Health and Social Services Minister Glenn Hart insists changes to the act were in the works for years, and not prompted by public pressure created by Zhang's story.

"We began public consultation on the act from April to May 2008,” '

God forbid that the Yukon Party should give the impression that public opinion had any effect whatsoever on their decision to get moving on this file they have been 'consulting on' since 2008! We all know already what they think of the opinions of the public.

Authoritarians see compromise and listening as weakness.

Up 0 Down 0

Jerry Johnson on Sep 2, 2011 at 10:03 am

I am very glad to read this. Dr. Zhang is a fabulous doctor. I can hardly wait for her to be back

Up 0 Down 0

Lynn Alcock on Sep 2, 2011 at 8:42 am

I'm thrilled to hear that Dr. Sue is once again able to work in Yukon. We are so fortunate to have her and her husband here, and able to teach us about alternate ways of healing body and spirit.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.