Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Health and Social Services Minister Tracey-Anne McPhee and Whitehorse Centre MLA Emily Tredger

NDP questions COVID-19 public health measures

The territory’s New Democrats have detected impediments to the COVID-19 vaccination system that they want removed.

By Whitehorse Star on November 8, 2022

The territory’s New Democrats have detected impediments to the COVID-19 vaccination system that they want removed.

“Many public health experts are predicting another wave of COVID-19 this fall and surging case numbers over the winter as people head back indoors,” Whitehorse Centre MLA Emily Tredger said during question period Monday.

“This government, though, appears to have given up on public health measures to protect Yukoners from the virus.

“Vaccination rates have stalled. Only 55 per cent of Yukoners have received three doses or more, and less than 10 per cent of children under five have had their first shot.”

According to yukon.ca, Tredger noted, “access to booster shots remains by appointment only – and kids under 12 can’t get an appointment until at least November 17.

“Will the minister commit to streamlining the booster shot campaign and reducing the barriers to vaccination?”

Tracey-Anne McPhee, the minister of Health and Social Services, responded, “Public health measures continue with respect to providing service and safety for Yukoners. I can indicate that I do disagree with much of what has been said in this question.

“It is clearly a fact — and Yukoners know this — that they have risen to the challenge of vaccines here in the territory,” McPhee said.

“We have had an amazing response to vaccines and the availability of vaccines across the territory to communities delivered throughout the Yukon Territory, sometimes by just amazing fly-in teams to make sure that our most remote communities were well protected with respect to vaccines.”

Whitehorse is one of the few large communities in Canada where waste-water testing for COVID-19 is not conducted.

Last April, Tredger recalled, McPhee told the legislature that waste-water testing “‘may become a useful surveillance tool here in the territory in future.’

“That was more than six months ago. While the government has taken time to figure things out, others are stepping up and filling the void,” Tredger said.

The Champagne and Aishihik First Nations and the Village of Haines Junction have implemented their own waste-water surveillance program, she reminded McPhee.

“Their data show rising viral load. What little public data we have for the Yukon show the test positivity rate rising sharply last week.”

Tredger called waste-water testing “a solution that works in other northern communities. It would allow this government and all Yukoners to make decisions based on information, not guesses.

“Why hasn’t this government implemented waste-water testing for COVID-19?

McPhee said the government will “take our public health guidance from our chief medical officer of health.

“We have in our territory a new chief medical officer of health, Dr. (Sudit) Ranade, who is working with his team with respect to new methods, a new perspective, a new vision for the territory.

“We are working forward with his guidance and the guidance of his team.”

McPhee called waste-water testing “one of the opportunities that is being considered, but what Yukoners should know is that waste-water testing for the virus that causes COVID-19 continues to evolve.

“It could become a useful tool. It is not currently being used here in the territory.”

She said the government is closely watching the waste-water testing pilot project in Haines Junction.

“We continue to work with our partners, including Health Canada, the Public Health Agency of Canada, First Nations, and municipal governments to explore whether or not that’s an option that is supported by those communities,” the minister told the House.

Last June, Tredger recalled, the Public Health Agency of Canada announced it would stop distributing rapid tests for COVID-19 to the provinces and territories.

“In the absence of available PCR testing, many Yukoners still rely heavily on rapid tests to make decisions,” she pointed out.

“Should they go to work today with a runny nose because they can’t afford to stay home again? Should they send their kids to their first birthday party in two years?

“These are the kinds of questions that many Yukoners are struggling with,” Tredger said.

“Without access to affordable rapid tests, many Yukoners will be left to guess.”

She asked McPhee how many rapid tests the Yukon has left, and whether the minister will continue to supply them free of charge beyond 2022.

The message for Yukoners, McPhee said, is that “they are spreading it to their friends and family throughout their communities — is that, if you are unwell, you should remain away from your workplace or away from school.

“You should remain at home until you are feeling well again,” McPhee added.

“The truth of this situation is that we have learned that going to work with symptoms of illness is not helping any of our community.”

Since March 2020, the minister added, the territory has provided lab-based PCR tests — at that time — to symptomatic patients.

“With the arrival of new rapid-testing resources, we have shifted lab-based PCR testing resources to focus on populations with the highest risk of negative impacts.

“At-home rapid tests are readily available for Yukoners throughout the territory in pharmacies, local businesses, and community health centres.”

They are free of charge and will remain available, McPhee added.

Comments (16)

Up 1 Down 0

North_of_60 on Nov 14, 2022 at 11:22 pm

People who are overweight and obese are more likely to catch C0vid, and more likely to be hospitalized and die, than people who are fit and healthy.
That's not discrimination, that's a medical fact proven by real-world data. C0vid severity is directly related to Body Mass Index.
https://www.science.org/content/article/why-covid-19-more-deadly-people-obesity-even-if-theyre-young
It would be wrongful discrimination only if they were refused treatment, and no rational person is suggesting that.

Up 1 Down 4

How about mental health? on Nov 13, 2022 at 10:34 pm

Look everyone! How about physical health? on Nov 9, 2022 at 7:09 pm picking on obese people. That’s discrimination that this forum has given voice to. What about those who are obese comorbid to depression, cancer, or some metabolic dysregulation?

Can they wear a symbol or something to show that they are not obese due to poor choices or something? Should we not focus our prejudices rather than just casually generalize with them? You know, to avoid concerns with discrimination and stuff… Maybe?

How about you just think it through for a moment?

“In recent weeks, many news outlets—and a few scientific journals—have sent the same frightening message. A study posted on a preprint server last weekend by researchers at New York University provided fodder for the latest round of this reporting: “Obesity appears to be one of the biggest risk factors related to Covid-19 hospitalizations and critical illness,” Newsweek claimed on Tuesday.”

“Yet this rhetoric is based on flawed and limited evidence, which only exacerbates the stigma that larger-bodied people already face in society and our health care system. That stigma is what truly jeopardizes their health, not weight itself—a fact that’s only more important to consider in the midst of this pandemic.”

Maybe read a book or two and slow your mind. We have enough hate coming from Ottawa these days. Be decent and find a way to positively contribute to society - We need you.

Besides, everyone knows:

“It's worse to be 'Skinny Fat' than it is to be OBESE: research shows that one in FOUR skinny people are 'metabolically fat' because of diet soft drinks, lack of sleep and unhealthy habits”.

There are a lot greater health risks for “skinny-fat” people:

'Skinny Fat' describes a person who may appear skinny but is unhealthy. People who are skinny fat are likely to neglect their health because they assume they are well due to their appearance.

“One in FOUR skinny people who have pre-diabetes, are 'metabolically obese'”
“Skinny diabetics have a higher mortality rate than obese diabetics.”

People who express discriminatory attitudes based on their discomfort at others appearances tend to be bottom up processors, reactive, responsive, stimulus seekers lacking full executive control. I have concerns about this tendency. It reeks of identitarian semantics and irrationality.

Resources:

https://www.wired.com/story/covid-19-does-not-discriminate-by-body-weight/amp

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2842250/amp/It-s-worse-Skinny-Fat-OBESE-research-shows-one-FOUR-skinny-people-metabolically-fat-diet-soft-drinks-lack-sleep-unhealthy-habits.html

Up 3 Down 3

Scapegoating, or ‘goating’ the scape? on Nov 12, 2022 at 7:09 pm

At How about physical health? on Nov 9, 2022 at 7:09 pm:

So now you want to openly discriminate against obese, substance abusing, nicotine addicted, individuals? Seriously, did we not learn anything from the discrimination perpetrated against the antivaxxers, and Caucasian males? Oh, wait - We’re still doing that!

Is this one of those identity things? Are obese persons the ones who “look” obese? Or, are they the ones who identify as obese? What if the obesity is not their fault? What if they were born that way? Or, do we label them and then they adopt that label out of shame? It worked well against the so-called racial minorities so why not the obese too?

I am concerned by a society that solves the problem of discrimination by changing the target. It seems so scapegoatish!

Anyway…

The Supreme Court of Canada found that a "handicap" may be actual or perceived and, because the emphasis is on the effects of the distinction, exclusion or preference rather than the precise nature of the handicap, the cause and origin of the handicap are immaterial.

However, conflicting treatment in cases nationwide show the issue is far from decided. A BC decision from the Council of Human Rights found obesity was a disability because it was perceived as such, and this decision has been followed since. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal found obesity was not a disability if it did not result from a medical condition.

“Based on more recent case law, it is important for employers to recognize that human rights legislation is being interpreted much more broadly and is considering issues of discrimination and disability in a more pragmatic way and with social context in mind,” Casey Dockendorff, an employment lawyer with Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti, said.

Stop “phat” shaming! It might be the law?!??

Up 22 Down 1

Joe on Nov 10, 2022 at 5:48 pm

NDP have no identity and have lost their way. Kate at the helm propping up the liberal mess were in to add up some pension time and then tries to pretend they make a difference by bringing useless issues and acting tough. May well be last of the NDP Yukon.

Up 29 Down 1

ElleEye on Nov 10, 2022 at 7:54 am

Tredger and Media - Move On!!

Up 29 Down 5

How about physical health? on Nov 9, 2022 at 7:09 pm

Sooooo 2.5 years and the only viable way that's scientifically proven to decrease the severity of COVID is being healthy and fit. If you're obese, a smoker, heavy drinker or participate in other unhealthy acts, you increase your likelihood for complications, hospitalization or death. Not a peep from anyone in Yukon healthcare or government communications. How about promoting people to get off their collective fat a$$s, do some pushups and squats, eat a salad and stop pounding a sixer and doobie every night. Vaccines are PART of the method to prevent severe COVID, not the be-all-end all of preventing spread. This is a respiratory virus, its basically impossible to prevent the spread.

Up 23 Down 3

For your consideration on Nov 9, 2022 at 4:57 pm

Or we could remove the barriers to little things like food, firewood, accommodations, and gas.

Up 8 Down 28

Anonymous on Nov 9, 2022 at 10:43 am

Why aren't people getting vaccinated anymore? Oh, I know. It's because it can only be done by appointment now. Yes, this is the primary reason why people won't get a third dose. Simple logic.

Up 42 Down 6

Juniper Jackson on Nov 9, 2022 at 9:19 am

Tredger- Must be a slow day at the office? This issue is kinda dead these days.

Up 46 Down 6

Dallas on Nov 8, 2022 at 8:22 pm

Tredger go get your shot if you are worried about it and as for the rest of us we will do the same…or not …ffs politicians are dumb.

Up 32 Down 13

bonanzajoe on Nov 8, 2022 at 7:22 pm

So who's drinking and bathing in waste water? And I think many Yukoners by now are convinced that this untested vaccine may be a hazard to one's health. I have done a lot of research and I am now one of those. No more vaccines for me. And that's final.

Up 51 Down 9

Fringe Minority with Unacceptable Views on Nov 8, 2022 at 6:26 pm

Lol many of us got the first 2 only to keep our jobs since you threatened us with unemployment and no EI. It’s really funny you think we’ll go get more willingly.

Up 48 Down 5

give it up already on Nov 8, 2022 at 4:11 pm

I've had two shots and one booster. I did not feel that there were any 'barriers'. What Tredger talking about? A 10 day wait to get kids in for a vaccine? I guess that's it because that's all she mentioned.
Enough already. After 2.5 years of this nonsense people are well aware that they are free to go get more vaccines, wear a mask, stay home, whatever. Most of us are interested in contributing to our community by going to work, and are feeling fine. I think the NDP are just creating drama, as usual.

Up 31 Down 13

No way jose on Nov 8, 2022 at 3:40 pm

It's over so get over it government keep pushing the scares in to small minded sheep.

Up 97 Down 14

Done with that on Nov 8, 2022 at 2:00 pm

The C0vax shot is freely available to Yukoners who still believe it does any good in keeping them from getting sick. No further govt action is warranted or necessary.

Up 99 Down 21

Mr Facts on Nov 8, 2022 at 1:30 pm

Tredger - People have moved on with their lives.

"Vaccination rates have stalled." So let's continue beating this dead horse and waste even more money on nothing. I'm just trying to virtue signal as hard as possible.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.