Whitehorse Daily Star

Liberals laud budget; YP, not so much

Thursday’s $142-billion federal budget is receiving both praise and criticism from Yukon politicians.

By Tim Giilck on April 8, 2022

Thursday’s $142-billion federal budget is receiving both praise and criticism from Yukon politicians.

In a news release, Yukon MP Brendan Hanley picked out 10 budget highlights for the territory:

• Providing $32.2 million to support the Atlin Hydro Expansion project in B.C.

• $10 billion to increase the number of housing units, make housing more affordable, and renovate and retrofit existing housing stock.

• $300 million over five years to co-develop and launch an Urban, Rural, and Northern Indigenous Housing Strategy.

• $565 million over five years to support housing in Self-Governing and Modern Treaty Holders.

• $26.2 million over four years to raise the maximum amount of forgivable Canada Student Loans by 50 per cent for doctors and nurses in rural and remote communities.

• $100 million over three years for the Substance Use and Addictions Program to support harm reduction, treatment, and prevention at the community level.

• Intending to make significant investments that would focus on priority critical mineral deposits, while working closely with affected Indigenous groups and through established regulatory processes.

• A new 30 per cent Critical Mineral Exploration Tax Credit for specified mineral exploration expenses incurred in Canada and renounced to flow-through share investors.

• Cutting taxes for Canada’s growing small businesses.

• $29.6 million over three years to support the co-development of an Indigenous Climate Leadership Agenda to support self-determined action in addressing Indigenous people’s climate priorities.

• $4.8 million over two years to the Indigenous Tourism Association of Canada to support its operations, which continue to help the Indigenous tourism industry rebuild and recover from the pandemic.

“I am pleased to see crucial investments in housing, health, tourism, climate action, small businesses, Indigenous communities, and resource management for Yukon,” Hanley said.

“This budget reflects key priorities I have strongly advocated for in my short time as MP to date. This is a win for Yukoners and for the North.”

In an interview with the Star this morning, the MP said, “I think we did well.

“It’s a great budget for the Yukon and the North,” he said. “It’s definitely a housing budget, whereas last year’s was a pandemic budget.”

Hanley said he had avocated intensely for the government to kick in the money for the Atlin project behind the scenes. “I fought tooth and nail for it,” he said.

Premier Sandy Silver’s reaction was very similar to Hanley’s.

“We are pleased to see the federal government recognize the unique challenges facing the North in 2022 and the actions they are taking to address many of these concerns,” Silver said.

“The Government of Yukon’s 2022-23 budget includes $15 million for the Atlin Hydro Expansion Project, with a total commitment of $50 million over three years,” he said.

“We are very happy to see that the federal budget recognizes the importance of this initiative with an announcement of $32.2 million over two years, starting in 2022–23, from the expanded Low Carbon Economy Fund.”

In remarks very similar to Hanley’s, Silver added, “We are also encouraged to see the Government of Canada recognize our commitment to address housing availability and affordability in the territory.

“The $30 million for affordable housing and related infrastructure in the Yukon will allow us to work with the Government of Canada to take further action to increase housing options for Yukoners.

“Nationally, $565 million over five years will go towards supporting housing for self-governing First Nations across the country, including those in the Yukon, which will be critical in improving health and social outcomes and to ensuring healthy First Nations communities.

“This was discussed at the 2021 Yukon Days, and we are pleased to see that the Government of Canada acknowledges the importance of government-to-government relations with self-governing First Nations.”

The federal budget also acknowledges that vital mineral mining projects “are expensive, and come with a unique set of challenges that can often include remote locations, changing prices, and lengthy regulatory processes,” Silver added.

“The introduction of a new 30 per cent Critical Mineral Exploration Tax Credit for specified mineral exploration expenses incurred in Canada will contribute to the Yukon’s growing mineral industry while securing good jobs for Yukoners.”

The Yukon Party and leader Currie Dixon saw the budget quite differently, however.

“The Yukon was only mentioned 10 times, and two of those were simply re-announcing the child care agreement reached last year,” the party said in a statement.

“Canadians and Yukoners needed a federal budget that was serious about addressing defence and military capabilities in the North.

“In light of Russian aggression and their illegal invasion of Ukraine, it is clear that the Canadian government needs to take Arctic security more seriously. We hope the importance of a fully built-out Canadian Armed Forces base in the North, preferably in the Yukon, is acknowledged in the announced comprehensive review of Canada’s defence policy.”

The Yukon Party had also hoped to see “specific mention of security investments and supports for the North and, in particular, the Yukon.

“Further, it is disappointing that the plan announced by the Liberals still leaves Canada far short of its NATO commitment regarding defence spending totalling at least two per cent of GDP.”

The new money fails to make up for the $12 billion shifted out of the Defence department since 2015, it added.

“With Yukon facing a doctor and nursing shortage, I was pleased to see the federal government provide student loan forgiveness for health professionals in underserved rural or remote communities, including in the North.

“We hope this will attract new doctors and nurses to the Yukon. The success of this policy and its importance for the Yukon will be largely dependent on how the federal government defines communities.”

Even the funding for housing didn’t escape the official Opposition’s wrath.

“We were disappointed to see that out of the funding available to support northern housing, the Yukon was given short shrift. The Yukon gets half the amount of money that is going to the other two territories.

“This comes as Yukon reports the highest population growth rate in Canada, and is an unfortunate reminder that the territory needs a strong representative as MP who will actually advocate on our behalf.

“In conclusion, there is good and bad in this budget,” the party stated.

“The lack of a serious approach to support for the military and vague or underfunded supports for the Yukon once again shows that the federal government thinks of the territory as an afterthought.”

NDP Leader Kate White liked much of what she saw. In a news release, she said she is applauding the results obtained by federal counterpart Jagmeet Singh, thanks to their newly signed Confidence and Supply Agreement.

“The federal agreement contains similar priorities as the Yukon NDP’s own Confidence and Supply Agreement signed with the Yukon Liberal government: action on housing affordability, publicly funded dental care and pharmacare, and 10 days of paid sick leave.

“It’s great to see that the federal NDP was able to secure commitments to get results and programs that Canadians need. I’m excited to see the roll out of publicly funded dental care and huge investments in housing in (Thursday’s) budget as the result of Jagmeet Singh’s leadership,” White said.

She said the federal NDP negotiated important budget initiatives for the territory, including:

•$5.3 billion over five years for dental care rollout, starting with kids under 12 years of age in 2022;

•An additional $1.5 billion over two years to the Rapid Housing Initiative;

•The introduction of a Homebuyers Bill of Rights;

•$4.3 billion for Indigenous housing over seven years;

•Ten days’ paid sick leave for federally regulated workers, including workers in banking, transportation and telecommunications sectors;

•$209.8 million over five years to locate, document and memorialize burial sites at former residential schools; and

•An additional $32.2 million for the Atlin Hydro Expansion project.

“This budget shows how much more we can accomplish when we work together for the good of Yukoners and Canadians,” White said.

“I’m proud of the work done by (Singh) to achieve this historic budget, and I’m relieved for Canadians who will benefit from this agreement right away,” White said.

Comments (19)

Up 2 Down 5

Groucho d'North on Apr 12, 2022 at 4:48 pm

Does anybody know what pages of the new Federal Liberal Budget show how much of our money is to be gifted to other interests around the world?

Up 6 Down 2

Cancel the new city hall! on Apr 12, 2022 at 3:43 pm

Sign the petition to cancel the new city hall and stop wasting taxpayers dollars!

https://www.change.org/p/cancel-the-new-whitehorse-city-hall

Up 6 Down 2

Disappointed on Apr 11, 2022 at 1:04 pm

It is true that Russia could strike at us with LRBM's, but military base or not we don't actually have any infrastructure (that we know of) to shoot them down. Only the Americans with their base in Alaska and ship launched anti-missile systems can destroy them. For Canada to acquire such systems would mean a huge cost for the country, and we would have much better luck putting them on our arctic vessels then in a ground forces base. Ships are mobile and hard to hit, static bases can be wiped out first with advanced strikes, like we saw in Ukraine. If money were to be put into northern defense, it would likely be best spent on navel or air based firepower. A ground invasion of Canada would be impractical for Russia, long range strikes would be the go to, which we can't really defend against.

Up 9 Down 1

Al on Apr 11, 2022 at 11:07 am

Amend my previous note of Apr 10, 2022 at 2:17 pm:

Nothing like recognizing an error and having the opportunity to fixing it
I inadvertently repeated 1 & 3. I apologize. So the article also needs to be amended to read four biggies.
Still does not take away the messages overall point - promises made and not kept.

As a side note both of the Wellness Program and addictions were a commitment way before the budget. So really it should not be include as anything new.

Up 20 Down 1

Mitch Holder on Apr 11, 2022 at 8:06 am

You suck at spending our money; Give it back.

Up 41 Down 3

Nice Jackpot win. Enjoy. on Apr 10, 2022 at 3:15 pm

Hmm...

• $300 million over five years to co-develop and launch an Urban, Rural, and Northern Indigenous Housing Strategy.
• $565 million over five years to support housing in Self-Governing and Modern Treaty Holders
• $4.8 million over two years to the Indigenous Tourism Association of Canada to support its operations, which continue to help the Indigenous tourism industry rebuild and recover from the pandemic.
•$4.3 billion for Indigenous housing over seven years;

So hold up, this is over $5 billion (with a B) for first nations? The same first nations that keep saying they are their own sovereign nations? The same ones that constantly criticize Canada and say how racist we are and how bad they are treated?

Maybe start acting sovereign nations, or is that only convenient when fighting development through "your land" when not enough cash is handed out (ie. consultations). Heck, if you think there is no racism in government, just look at these payouts to these people simply because of their background. Jackpot city indeed.

Up 26 Down 4

Al on Apr 10, 2022 at 2:17 pm

So, now that the Liberals have finished patting themselves on their collective backs let us have a look at what they promised for this budget vs what they failed to not only deliver, but not even mention.

First before I mention the five biggies they missed, we need to note that in this budget there is a 31 billion increase over the past budget in new spending (mostly to keep their buddies, the NDP happy) – that is right 31 billion spread like mustard over 5 years.

First – The Liberals promised billions to hire more doctors – fact to the tune of 3.2 billion promised to the provinces and territories to hire 7,500 new family doctors, nurses and nurse practitioners starting this fiscal year. How much was identified – zero.

Second – There is no new money for long-term care systems which they promised to deliver 1.8 billion starting this year over four years. Also included was a promise to raise the wages of personal support workers to at least $25/hour. As well to train an additional 50,000 more workers to prop a faltering system. How much was identified – zero.

Third – Liberals promised billions to hire more doctors. By hiring an additional 7,500 new family doctors, nurses and nurse practitioners starting this fiscal year. A total of 3.2 billion was promised to the provinces and territories. How much was identified – zero.

Fourth – The budget doesn't include another promised policy for seniors — a $500 increase to the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) for low-income seniors and $750 for couples. That nearly $4.2 billion commitment over 4 years was supposed to take effect this fiscal year. How much was identified – zero.

Fifth - Mental health care transfer is missing from budget. Their promise was an investment of 4.5 billion starting this year over five years. Instead, the document said the government "intends to engage with the provinces and territories" before possibly allocating funds to such a program. In other words, it has been shelved (so much for the big promises made by Hanley on all these items – who by the way thinks this budget is “…a great budget for the Yukon and the North”). How much was identified - the budget does include $140 million over two years to keep the "Wellness Together Canada" online portal functional, huh? There's also another $100 million over three years for Health Canada's substance use and addictions program. So, the issue of Trudeau saying, “Canadians deserve the right support, and that includes mental health." Turn out it is BS. How much was identified for Mental Health – zero.

Lots of promises – zero deliveries on the most critical file they have...

Up 36 Down 9

Juniper Jackson on Apr 9, 2022 at 4:21 pm

I'm so sick and tired of the Liberal lies and bullsh**. Josey Wales is 100% right.

Up 13 Down 10

John on Apr 9, 2022 at 1:01 pm

@red scare

Every heard of LRBMs? Best you do some reading. It is the fastest way of dealing a blow.
Oh for those that don't know the acronym: Long Range Ballistic Missiles. You don't piss around with ground forces. They can also be launched by Subs.

Up 8 Down 11

unReal on Apr 9, 2022 at 11:29 am

the eeYore Party is at it again!

Up 33 Down 6

Groucho d'North on Apr 9, 2022 at 10:30 am

It looks like another Liberal Santa Claus budget. It's easy to spend lots when you don't have to pay it back- That task will be for subsequent governments & tax paying Canadians to deal with.

Up 33 Down 11

Josey Wales on Apr 9, 2022 at 7:23 am

Budget eh? Well this post may be as big as the budget... Some idiot out east said that “budgets balance themselves...”
That said, what do ya get when you pollinate a groupie socialist with a communist?
Why the 23rd Prime Minister of Canadastan is what.
If y’all have not be able to see and hear for yourselves what I see and hear, I suspect it is because you choose not to bear witness to your country falling.
The damage that Teflon coated jackass has done and continues to, is far greater than just “the other team” crap.
For all you willfully blind minions, just image that pendulum that is state pinned to far far left...is “allowed” to ever swing again nnnkay?

The day may come where that pendulum gets pinned to the far far right?
Might get a metric 2nd amendment in place, open carry sidearms across the country, maybe some castle laws to aid in thinning the herd of re offend scumbags and ensuring more folks die of old age Vs. failed liberal policies...which are most!

*the horns were not what made them fear, it was the masses of common folk, the unwashed masses, the regular canuks, the angry new canuks, the actual folks in a cue watching Roxam rd QC morph into an exodus of BOGUS refugees outta the USA, serving and retired military whom actually defend us from megalomaniacs...and many many more folks were there being loud and proud.

In Canada today, you can not be a loud and proud Canadian waving a flag!
You can however be as loud and as proud as you desire during what is soon to be pride month. Any public deviance is to be tolerated by the fullest extent of the law with no exceptions.
Canada today is an absolute effin mess!
Is it all that Blackface idiots fault?
Nope, it is not, it has had much help in the decades before its coronation.
His mothers husband did a good number de-nutting our citizens, absolutely gutted our national defence, created the race war within, opened the prisons, torched the gates on our metaphorical fence with a tsunami of 3rd world to follow...by design of course.

Up 14 Down 9

Red Scare on Apr 8, 2022 at 9:57 pm

@Bozojoe

You do realize that there will not be any ground forces coming over the top of the arctic circle in some kind of invasion for at least 100 years or so? You do get that right? What we need is a naval/air base since jets and subs are the only things that will violate our space.

During the summer, the polar area is way too unstable with too much open water which is only getting worse with climate change. In the winter, it's too inhospitable with 24/7 darkness, intense blizzards and temperatures in the -50s. Imagine travelling thousands of miles in that over barren land and ice with no roads. Not to mention we would see them slowly coming over the top for weeks before they would ever make it to Canadian territory.

Up 31 Down 7

TMYK on Apr 8, 2022 at 6:53 pm

I see a lot of money for 20% of our population. I guess the other 80% don’t really matter to this government.

Up 19 Down 8

drum on Apr 8, 2022 at 6:48 pm

Ha Ha - we have a Liberal Government here - of course they supported Ottawa.

Up 36 Down 13

bonanzajoe on Apr 8, 2022 at 4:44 pm

BonfireJim. Well, I'm sure you voted for him. Live with it. And next time be careful what you wish for.

Up 53 Down 15

bonanzajoe on Apr 8, 2022 at 4:42 pm

Well, looks like the indigenous people won the lottery again. And don't expect the Liberals to put in a permanent military base in the north. JT will be the first to shake the hand of welcome of the commanding officer of the Russian invasion force. Think I'm kidding?

Up 48 Down 17

Glen on Apr 8, 2022 at 4:07 pm

That's nice, lift the mandates.

Up 58 Down 14

BonfireJim on Apr 8, 2022 at 3:36 pm

It is sad to see the lack of support from the Liberal Government for the Yukon.

In a rare turn I believe that Currie is right and we should be beefing our northern defense and Military. the support for actual Yukon issues is missing and I am deeply disappointed in Brendan Hanley.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.