Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Photo submitted

SERVICE REDUCTION POSSIBLE - A Whitehorse Transit bus is seen this morning. The proposed city operating budget, released last month, would eliminate Friday evening service. Star photo by BRIELLE WILL

Keep Friday night buses rolling, council urged

Over and over again, city council was told not to cut its Friday evening transit service.

By Stephanie Waddell on February 10, 2009

Over and over again, city council was told not to cut its Friday evening transit service.

The requests came from eight of 10 people who spoke during a public hearing on the proposed operating budget at council's regular Monday night meeting.

"We count on the transit system to get to work," Bernice Montgomery said.

From her home off Range Road, she added, it's "wonderful" that she can get to Yukon College, the Canada Games Centre and the downtown core by city bus.

"I want to make sure I keep that service," Montgomery said.

With $2.5 million of the proposed $55.7-million operating budget to be spent on running the bus system in the 2009 fiscal year, the city is planning to cut its Friday night service.

As well, it will not continue the pilot downtown loop that took passengers from the city's core to the Canada Games Centre and Yukon College.

Few speakers commented on the downtown loop ending, though some, like Montgomery, said they don't use it because they can access its destinations by other regular routes like the McIntyre or Takhini routes.

Instead, council heard that many use the Friday night service to visit friends or to reach events around town they can't get to other nights because there's no evening service.

The service means that every Friday night, Porter Creek resident Cathy Antaya can make her way down to a housebound friend in Riverdale for a visit to play some Scrabble.

Without the bus service, the visit would mean a $30 cab fare home at the end of the evening, which would undoubtedly cut into how often Antaya could make it to Riverdale on a Friday night.

The bus service is used by many teenagers and adults alike, council was told. The bus service gives freedom to many people who would otherwise not have it, council heard.

Probably the most organized people in the city, transit users are able to get to and from work, shopping, social events and recreational facilities using the bus schedule.

While not always easy, "it's doable," Antaya said.

She'd like to see even more service offered during other evenings of the week so she could take part in activities and events at the Canada Games Centre or Yukon Arts Centre. She drew applause from the 10 or so people sitting in the gallery.

One speaker was quick to call on the city to extend evening service with buses until about 11:30 Friday and Saturday nights. That would mean he and others could go to a hockey game at the Takhini Arena or a performance at the Yukon Arts Centre.

Indeed, the special evening bus service added for last night's public hearing meant some got to take part in the event. However, two letters were submitted by wheelchair users Judi Johnny and Christiane Cramp (who has also brought forward a formal complaint to the Yukon Human Rights Commission over the Handy Bus).

The two women were unable to make the meeting due to transportation issues.

Both noted the need to expand the availability of the Handy Bus service and argued the regular Friday night service shouldn't be eliminated.

Coun. Dave Stockdale suggested lobbying various businesses and others to have their sessions earlier before buses stop running. However, the speaker noted it's unlikely facilities are going to change their schedule to fit Whitehorse Transit's.

Antaya was with the majority of speakers who favoured an additional charge of $70 per year to city residents that would pay for the transit system to operate without fares. For at least a couple of people, the amount seemed a "pittance" to pay for buses.

The figure was put forth by Stockdale, who said he had heard it would pay for the system. Transit manager Dave Muir confirmed the figure is likely in that range.

Only one speaker disagreed with funding the service entirely through taxes, suggesting there should be at least some part of it being funded based on use.

"To have the taxpayer subsidize everything so that it's free goes against my conservative nature," he said.

Coun. Jan Stick, attending the meeting by conference call, asked whether delegates would support having the question put to the entire community in the form of a referendum in October's municipal election.

Reaction was mixed. Some people urged council to put it forward. Others suggested it shouldn't be a question asked, but rather just added to the city's tax bills in the interest of the environment and to be fair to those who can't afford a vehicle.

Though the message of the evening was for the city to keep its Friday night service, almost every speaker praised bus drivers as being helpful and polite to customers.

Just whether the requests will result in any changes to the city's budget remains to be seen.

As Mayor Bev Buckway said during an interview after the meeting, council will review the report coming out of the public hearing before it proceeds with further votes to adopt the budget.

"Transit is always a tough, tough issue for us," she said. "Dollars are limited and the area that we serve is huge, and we're always looking at ways to improve it."

The wide range of comments means some tough deliberations for council, the maror said, acknowledging as well that if a question on how it's funded went to the public through a referendum, this would be a good year to do it.

"Because we have an election and people have to go to the polls anyway, if we wanted to do a referendum on something, that would potentially be a good time to put something on the ballot," she said.

The city would have to ensure voters received information about the exact costs for the service prior to the question being placed on the ballots, she said.

"A lot of people in town that don't use the transit don't want to pay and they don't want to subsidize it," Buckway said.

"So, of course, there were people sitting in the room here tonight who wouldn't want to see it on a referendum because they know it would get voted down."

Council will vote on second and third readings of the budget on Feb. 23.

Coun. Doug Graham was absent from Monday night's meeting.

Comments (5)

Up 0 Down 0

Jason McRobb on Feb 19, 2009 at 1:03 pm

Wheres Andre Bourcier on this issue? There should be french buses to french schools at all times of the day!!!!!!!!!!!!

Up 0 Down 0

Ingrid on Feb 19, 2009 at 10:11 am

The transit system is an important issue in many people's lives - parents, teenagers, students, seniors, intoxicated people, people living with health issues (inability to walk long distances) or financial issues. Not to mention, less people driving is good for the environment! It's hard to participate in life (CGC, events, weekends) and live within the confinements of the city determining a lousy schedule. I can't afford a taxi. If the city made decents bus schedules, I'm sure it would be used more often - sit on the bus and talk to us - we can't get to city hall meetings - the buses don't match up for when a meeting is called!

Up 0 Down 0

David Bruce on Feb 14, 2009 at 6:53 am

It boggles the mind that cutting transit service on Friday night is even being considered! Whitehorse is a major urban centre in the North, and the Territorial capital to boot! Get with the current century!

Up 0 Down 0

k on Feb 11, 2009 at 5:51 am

Part of the reason the Bus service lack ridership is because to me its more of a tourist attraction. Its operates monday to friday with a reduced schedule on saturday no service on sundays. Many peoples dont work 9-5 jobs monday to friday.

SO when planning on transportation City Transit just isnt it. To take a bus one day cab it the next is senseless. I think youd see an increase in service if Whitehorse transit operated every evening and had service on Sundays. This will make it an actual option for transport and not just a gimmick.

Up 0 Down 0

Judi Johnny on Feb 10, 2009 at 2:26 pm

I would like to set the record straight. We couldn't make a presentation because the lift in City Hall wasn't working properly. Ask Robert Fendrick. His staff only discovered this in the afternoon of the Public meeting

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.