Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Mark Page

PREMIER URGED TO GO TO THE PEOPLE – Nine months into his premiership, it’s time for Ranj Pillai to seek his own mandate from Yukoners, says Opposition Leader Currie Dixon, seen last Wednesday.

‘It’s time for an election,’ Dixon says

As the Yukon legislature’s fall sitting began today, Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon says it is time for an election to let the people have a say about whether Ranj Pillai should be premier.

By Mark Page on October 4, 2023

As the Yukon legislature’s fall sitting began today, Yukon Party Leader Currie Dixon says it is time for an election to let the people have a say about whether Ranj Pillai should be premier.

“He took over the mantle midway through a mandate (last January),” Dixon told the Star last Wednesday.

“I think it’s incumbent on him to follow the Canadian political convention and seek his own mandate as premier from the people of Yukon.”

This was the overarching message as Dixon laid out his preferred agenda for the upcoming legislative term, contrasting his policy positions with those of Pillai and the governing Liberal party.

Top of his mind is the cost-of-living in the Yukon and the fact the territory has led Canada in inflation rates for eight of the last nine months.

“Unfortunately, the response from government has been meagre at best; we haven’t seen any new initiatives, any new policies put forward by the government to address that huge challenge,” Dixon said.

For their part, Pillai and others in his government have argued they have used things such as energy rebates to help ease the burden from inflation.

When talking about the cost of living, Dixon focuses on housing and transportation as two areas where he thinks action needs to be taken.

On housing, he says the Yukon needs deregulation for landlords and that building lots need to be opened up for development faster.

The development piece is pretty much universally agreed on by the three political parties, though the Yukon Party still says the Liberals have not been acting quickly enough.

“We haven’t seen any urgency from the government to get lots out to market, we haven’t seen any urgency around the supply of new rental units,” Dixon said.

He does agree with the federal Liberals’ new plan to remove the GST from the construction of new rental units, but said these policies take time to take effect and this should have been done when first promised seven years ago.

“If they had done it back when they said they were going to do it, I think it would have actually helped,” Dixon said. “Unfortunately, I think it’s a little bit too little too late.”

He further contrasts his view with that of the other two parties in his criticism of recent rental caps and eviction protections passed by the Liberal government, which he says are disincentivizing people from wanting to be landlords.

“We continue to hear from landlords that the imposition of the new policies that come out of the Confidence and Supply Agreement (CASA) with the NDP are causing landlords to flee the market rather than enter the market,” Dixon said.

“And that’s unfortunately just the wrong direction.”

Another part of the cost-of-living equation is the cost of food and other supplies that are trucked into the Yukon.

To alleviate these costs, Dixon says the elimination of the carbon tax and a territorial gas tax holiday will help.

Considering there was a $50-million budget surplus in the spring, Dixon said the territory could easily afford the temporary gas tax holiday.

He would also like to see the carbon tax removed from the cost of heating fuels.

This runs counter to the Liberals’ agenda as laid out in their Our Clean Future plans.

“Unfortunately, the government hasn’t taken a single one of our suggestions and continues to provide inadequate support when it comes to the cost of living for Yukoners,” Dixon said.

Another theme for Dixon’s criticisms of the Liberal government – and an area in which the NDP is in agreement with them – is the lack of services in rural Yukon.

Over the summer, rural Yukoners have dealt with intermittent closures of several rural health clinics, reductions in EMS services, the closures of highway rest stops and the planned closures of several rural waste transfer stations.

Dixon called this an “over-arching lack of connection with rural Yukon.”

“We think that’s really unfortunate, and we intend to raise that as a serious concern when the legislature resumes,” he said.

On energy, Dixon says the territory needs to focus on permanent infrastructure and stop relying on temporary diesel generators, which he blames for rate increases proposed by the Yukon’s electricity utilities.

After outlining his position and what he says is a needed change in direction, Dixon said if Pillai doesn’t call an election, the NDP should abandon the CASA to 
force one.

The Yukon Party and Liberal party are tied for number of seats in the legislature, but the NDP has an agreement with the Liberals – signed last Jan. 31 – allowing them to form a government.

“Ultimately, I hope that (Pillai) does that on his own but if he doesn’t, it falls to the NDP to stop propping up the Liberal government and let Yukoners have a say in the way we’re going to move forward,” Dixon said.

“It’s time for an election.”

Comments (11)

Up 2 Down 0

Junior Moose on Oct 10, 2023 at 5:53 pm

If Curry can muff this up, what else is he capable of?

Up 3 Down 1

joe on Oct 10, 2023 at 4:07 pm

@ doug and dan.. I believe you miss the point, although our archaic political system allows a non elected premier to be a premier, and our archaic system allows two minority parties to collude and rule doesn't mean its right and, it is time to call an election as the Yukon is a mess and no one voted for the current political mess were in.

Up 6 Down 1

KC on Oct 10, 2023 at 3:54 pm

Dan Davidson - Thank you for explaining the technicalities of parliamentary democracy for me. Thankfully I was able to infer "how the system actually works" from the fact that Mr. Pillai has been able to govern for the past nine months (and clearly intends to do so for the foreseeable future). I, on the other hand, with a single vote and a single voice will decide for myself what I regard as a 'mandate', who I regard as having a right to govern and who I hold personally responsible when they exceed that mandate. The "system" does not decide what is 'right" for me.

Up 11 Down 22

Doug on Oct 6, 2023 at 5:59 pm

Hardly a good idea. The man was duly elected and as he became the party leader, and Premier, following the rules of a Parliamentary Democracy there is absolutely no logic in a call for an election. Really, anyone is entitle to make such a call, but there is absolutely no reason for the Premier to heed the call.

Up 10 Down 18

Dan Davidson on Oct 6, 2023 at 5:03 pm

Re: I also resent the fact that the Mr. Pillai decided to rule without a mandate.

The party gets the mandate, not the leader. Not saying that I'm especially happy with the current situation, but please try to grasp how the system actually works before you cry foul. Don't copy Dixon's mistake.

Up 98 Down 18

KC on Oct 5, 2023 at 12:39 pm

It is indeed time for a change. I am ready to be done with our current crop of political leaders, and I don't want the NDP to have a say in policy anymore as the price of confidence in the legislatures. I actually don't have much against the Liberals ideologically but they are unimpressive as managers, I also resent the fact that the Mr. Pillai decided to rule without a mandate. It was legal but not right. We should have gone to the polls in the spring.

Up 80 Down 23

Groucho d'North on Oct 5, 2023 at 10:48 am

A democraticaly elected government is long overdue. This political alloy currently in place does not serve Yukoners as well as it serves the political participants.

Up 31 Down 73

David on Oct 4, 2023 at 5:56 pm

I hope they don't call an election, as we need more time for a fourth option (a fourth party) to become a reality. The unanimous position of all three existing parties to the 1 Million March 4 Children shows we need one.

Up 79 Down 23

SIGH on Oct 4, 2023 at 4:09 pm

Currie, I support the Yukon party, but I do not think you and your party are capable of good governance. The first two years will consist of.. the Liberals did this and they did that. blah blah. I would have far more respect if your criticism were constructive... I know, but the Liberals would steal the idea... who cares as long as it is for the betterment of the Territory and Yukoners.

Up 33 Down 61

Dan Davidson on Oct 4, 2023 at 3:52 pm

Since the electorate doesn't actually vote for the Premier, anymore than they would have if the Yukon Party had won, isn't this rather irrelevant?

Up 81 Down 29

Ben on Oct 4, 2023 at 3:18 pm

Yes please. It's long overdue. Should've happened in 2020.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.