Whitehorse Daily Star

Indigenous hiring preference policy extended

The Yukon government will be extending its Indigenous hiring preference policy until 2029.

By Tim Giilck on April 5, 2022

The Yukon government will be extending its Indigenous hiring preference policy until 2029.

In a news release issued Monday, the government stated it will continue its efforts to increase representation of Indigenous employees in the public service.

“The goal of this initiative is to increase the number of Indigenous employees in the Yukon’s public service,” the release said.

“The first 15 months of the pilot resulted in 78 successful Indigenous candidates across a total of 632 competitions.

This includes new employees and existing employees moving to a new position within the Yukon government.”

The pilot began on Oct. 1, 2020. It was part of Breaking Trail Together, a 10-year strategic plan to create a Yukon public service that is inclusive and representative of First Nations people.

“Overall, this initiative has demonstrated the value of having a hiring preference for Indigenous candidates but it has not increased Indigenous representation in the Yukon government to the extent that was hoped for,” the statement said

“By extending the program, the Government of Yukon hopes to meet the program goal of increasing Indigenous representation in the public service to 22 per cent.”

John Streicker, the minister responsible for the Public Service Commission, said “it is important that the Yukon government reflect the diversity of our territory and the people and communities they serve.

“The Indigenous hiring preference initiative is contributing to our goal to increase Indigenous representation in the public service and strengthen our Yukon government services and workforce.”

Preliminary findings for the project are that:

• Indigenous representation did not change significantly during the 18-month period;

• even with the introduction of the project, overall, the Yukon government experienced a slight decrease in Indigenous employees;

• there was no negative impact on broader recruitment, as there was no decrease in applicants; and

• Indigenous representation in the government was 15 per cent on Oct. 1, 2020 and remains the same as of March 31, 2021.

The Official opposition Yukon Party noted that increasing Yukon First Nations representation in the public service is one of the commitments under the land claim’s Umbrella Final Agreement, “and the Yukon Party supports efforts to do so. The Yukon Party also supports a representative public service.

“It is concerning that the government’s own announcement highlights that this program has not been successful in increasing Yukon First Nations representation in the public service.

“Any program should be audited for effectiveness, and it appears this program may not be achieving its objectives,” the official Opposition said.

The Yukon Chamber of Commerce, commenting through executive director Denny Kobayahsi, said Tuesday it “supports the extension of the Indigenous preferred hiring policy and other initiatives like the Yukon First Nations Procurement Policy that serve to increase the representation of Yukon Indigenous workers and businesses in the Yukon economy.

“Many Yukon private sector businesses proactively recruit and retain Indigenous workers that supports a more diverse and capable local workforce,” Kobayahsi added.

“In addition to initiatives like the preferred hiring policy, the government’s investment in workforce development is critically important to ensure that the Yukon maximizes opportunities to hire, train and support Yukoners.”

NDP Leader Kate White said Tuesday she believes the preference is “very important. It’s important the public service be reflective of the community.”

White said she was told during a briefing on the policy that the COVID-19 pandemic might have impacted the hiring process, with fewer Indigenous applicants trying for jobs.

She said she noticed during the briefing the policy doesn’t seem to be effective.

While she remains supportive, White said, she hopes the policy will be reviewed to see why that was the case if it continues.

Comments (46)

Up 0 Down 0

David on Jun 18, 2022 at 7:37 pm

One person here said, "Hire because you meet the requirements on the Job Description." Actually, they should meet the requirements, and if there's more than one that meets the requirement, then prioritize families that don't have at least one household member already working for YTG, as opposed to some households who have two members already working for YTG.

Up 3 Down 1

Dentist47 on Apr 11, 2022 at 6:37 pm

I wonder if First Nations citizens realize that the unfairness in preferential hiring based on race and therefore skin colour. I think that policies such as this one actually hold First Nation Citizens back because they don’t have to compete on a level playing field.

What I often wonder is when are we going to get a decent definition of a First Nations individual. In our community there are First Nation citizens whose genetic makeup is over 80 percent Caucasian, and they are eligible for preferential hiring.

Up 36 Down 9

drum on Apr 8, 2022 at 11:05 pm

I am an immigrant - I have always paid my way and not asked for special help. Do not have special categories for special people.

Up 3 Down 10

Chuck Farley on Apr 8, 2022 at 12:03 pm

Dekanji Brown; got that right and i discovered that the moderators, filters will not post comments that calls out the bs language used by contributors;

Up 16 Down 5

Vern Schlimbesser on Apr 8, 2022 at 11:32 am

@ missing the forest
Your first paragraph is right on, in an ideal world, and I subscribe.

Your second paragraph reveals your subscription to Cancel Culture. You realize you are so afraid of opposing views you want to outlaw them. Please come to terms with understanding that.

Up 33 Down 3

stephen on Apr 8, 2022 at 8:27 am

I see a lot of comments one way or the other on the topic but few comments from people who have lived this policy. Unfortunately I have lived in when working for a BC crown corp.

Crown corps are always rife with nepotism and cronyism but when you now added in hiring quotas for minorities, sex and special interest groups the only people losing is the tax payer.

I watched people being hired and promoted not because they had the skill but because they were one of these groups. Sad thing is then those people in power promoted from the same groups. I have seen a person working in an environmental group promoted to manager in accounts payable who has no CMA or CA training. I have seen in the supply chain group promotions based on their being a female not because they were qualified.

When I talk to people who still work there they say the lucky ones got out. When you only need to work 10 years to get the golden handcuffs(great pension) the tax payers suffer immensely.
Don't even try firing one of these people because they can't do the job as you will be called out as racist or sexist, etc.

When one says higher the best person for the job no matter their skin colour or sex or disability I agree with it. That does not make me racist or sexist or anti disabled people. What it says is give these people the training and skills to be able to apply for those jobs. Another way of doing it is to get them on a apprenticeship program and if after 6 months they can do the job then look at hiring them. If they can't let them go.

Up 17 Down 3

Archie on Apr 8, 2022 at 7:34 am

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make him drink.

Up 25 Down 5

drum on Apr 7, 2022 at 9:21 pm

Hire because you meet the requirements on the Job Description which should not be saying any special Group ie. Aboriginal. Meet the needs of the job you are applying on..

Up 32 Down 2

To Cherles on Apr 7, 2022 at 6:04 pm

But you're not First Nations...so clearly you've never NOT been hired or given a chance at a job because of your racial background, last name, or appearance. And you want to talk about equality; how about when Yukoners apply for jobs but the government/private sector just hires outside hires? Because when the government funds our Yukon students $6000+ each year for 5 years to go outside to school, get trades and uni degrees, wouldn't it make sense to hire those Yukon students after they graduate? Instead we get directors and principals and workers coming here for the 'Yukon adventure' from other provinces because they are clearly more qualified (sarcasm noted here!) Remember the director they hired for education and he was promptly fired? Hire First Nations and Yukoners first....adventure seekers from elsewhere can be considered once we get our own Yukoners of all races working.

Up 42 Down 9

comen sense on Apr 7, 2022 at 5:25 pm

In Alaska they don't have this Indigenous hiring preference policy. I see lots of First nations working and equal to the next person. There is no division created like we are doing here in this country now.

Up 57 Down 12

Anie on Apr 7, 2022 at 4:04 pm

BonfireJim - "diversity is our strength" has been Trudeau's mantra. I think he is wrong. Since he came to power, we have been made to feel ashamed to be Canadian. I think diversity is destroying any hope we might have had to be proud of our country - and there is so much to be proud of.

Up 26 Down 3

Groucho d'North on Apr 7, 2022 at 4:00 pm

@Dekanji Brown
The vote counter is working fine. On your computer you see the number when you last pushed the button. Whenever you cast a vote it refreshes the total count, so if 3 people vote before you press the button, it will update to include those 3 people.

Up 36 Down 4

Groucho d'North on Apr 7, 2022 at 9:45 am

There will always be friction in the hiring process in governments. Apart from creating a visual representation of the Yukon's demography and the bias that goes with it, there are also the favouritism concerns where the DM or a Director has already made up their mind who they want to hire - relative or otherwise - so the competition between the applicants gets tossed out the window and an unquestionable decision stands.
The context of this debate is primarily about hiring for ability or political posturing. For me as a taxpayer who ultimately pays for the staff, I would prefer to see ability as the goal for all hiring, and not just at the time of hire, periodic suitability tests would help to make sure these bureaucrats are still on the ball and have not slumped into the well-padded "waiting for retirement" work ethic that appears all too often.

Up 16 Down 46

Sheepchaser on Apr 7, 2022 at 8:57 am

Programs like these always get knickers in a twist. It’s a fear thing. They see more and more of their supremacy slipping away. Blame for their own lot in life goes everywhere but in the mirror. Only thinking you are inherently superior could lead to disagreement with looking for pathways to address systemic bias. A rising tide raises all boats. Or drown under the weight of your personal fear baggage, your call.

Up 20 Down 14

Dekanji Brown on Apr 7, 2022 at 7:31 am

The vote system here is broken- it gives two vote when I upvote or downvote certain comments- one to both up and down. Seems to be locked into a ratio. Is this deliberate, to keep certain opinions muted or diluted?

Up 60 Down 11

Cherles on Apr 6, 2022 at 7:51 pm

If I were a First Nation person hired while this policy was in place, I would continually wonder if my co-workers thought I was a diversity hire rather than having been hired based on being the most qualified for the job.

I also wonder if this policy discourages qualified non-First Nation people from applying now because they see that the hiring policies are rigged against them.

Up 28 Down 9

martin on Apr 6, 2022 at 6:57 pm

@bonanzajoe ; I'd like to offer my views on that. They don't work in the service industry simple because they don't like it. It is not in their nature to fit in that environment. I am surprised when I read about FN "creating/getting" into Tourism; it is not what they excel into.

Up 9 Down 36

Affirmative hiring on Apr 6, 2022 at 6:54 pm

Look at DOE policy on hiring. Preference is just for Yukon First Nations (and they deserve top priority, esp. for their traditional territories but really anywhere in the Yukon). HOWEVER, I am not Y. First Nations but I am Indigenous. I think DOE's policy should be: 1) Permanent Employees transferring 2) Yukon F Nations 3) Indigenous 4) Local Yukoner teachers, esp. if trained here 5) All other applicants. NDP USED to have a local hire policy in 1990's. That was because we had all kinds of YTG leader's friends from down south coming up and taking all jobs. More relevant in my mind is to get ALL YUKONERS working first....and also focus on Indigenous representation (good for everybody! esp RCMP, doctors, nurses, lawyers, teachers). But just try to have a policy like this come out and watch all of the non First Nations cry foul. You foul cryers are the same ones criticizing if F.Nations aren't working--you can't have it both ways and affirmative action is guaranteed to get some F. Nations representation in the work force.

Up 9 Down 2

martin on Apr 6, 2022 at 6:50 pm

@BonfireJim: Very well constructed sentences, but -in my opinion- do not reflect reality.

Up 31 Down 11

bonanzajoe on Apr 6, 2022 at 5:17 pm

Jillian Chown, It's only racist when the comments are from the "white race" eh? I should know, I get the memo at least half a dozen times a day.

Up 37 Down 9

Shenanigans, you are the victim of a political ill will… on Apr 6, 2022 at 4:59 pm

@ JC on Apr 6, 2022 at 7:07 am:

Your comment is a disingenuous polemic. There is no presumption that an indigenous person is less qualified. It is simply that we want the most qualified for the position… Society is safer this way!

However, given the gong show of the YEU/YG sanctioned managerial excesses and abuses, the intentional stirring of workplace conflict, and the general ineptitude of our Legal system it is clear that we need to do more to police their racist practices because it is not the policies or the laws that are racist, it is the application of them that is - Next time you see a law maker say to them in the most sarcastic tone you can, Thank you for your service!

Because you know what? It is the Judges who do sentencing, not me, not you, based on their interpretation of Parliaments will - Not you, not me, and the collective will of the people either.

They created this mess, used you as an excuse, and hung the blame around your neck to indicate your crimes, never having committed them, but they are yours because the system (cough, cough), meaning the politicos are racist but they have the power and authority to protect their image - You do not.

Up 48 Down 14

Preferential Hiring… Just Liberals conspiring… on Apr 6, 2022 at 2:39 pm

In response to - y'all are missing the forest though the trees on Apr 6, 2022 at 11:31 am:

Your position is an excellent example of the racism that is posted in these forums. Giving one group of people an advantage in hiring practices and the right to voice their opinions over those of others is racist!

You might as well have shouted, “shut up all other races, especially whites, it’s our turn”. It is absolutely galling that you, Richard Mostyn, and the other members of the Liberal cabal cannot admit to it, you cannot own it.

There is already a law that states all are equal before the law… Now you have turned that concept in its head… All are equal but for the law. This is the problem with governments, especially Liberal governments, they get drunk on power and cannot keep the ship between the rocks.

So they overcompensate… My ship is bigger than yours, and they make more laws, policies, and procedures that over-correct the course of the ship to hit yet more rocks.

It is precisely because of “their” application of the law that there is systemic discrimination and it is not a will of the people thing. However, these Decepticon Politicos have been more than happy to transform the discourse to this current misdirection of the bio-evolutionary processes, namely the distortion of notions of implicit biases.

But here we are in a diversity delusion assigning greater value to one’s skin colour over that of another’s. The pressures created by the political climate in the Liberal Social Credit scheme create conflict and essentially force employers to hire Indigenous peoples first - Regardless of competency. We are seeing the impact of this dysregulation everywhere.

But don’t worry about it… You will own nothing and be happy, because you will become the mental equivalent of the cat chasing a laser light… What pretty colours… Can I have some more catnip (marijuana) please… FFS!

“Legally, we want the system to be color-blind; we want everyone to have the same rights. But socially we understand that people don’t want their racial or gender identities to be ignored. They want them to be recognized and respected. People take a civic pride in having a racially diverse workplace or educational institution. It’s just that many would rather not contemplate too closely the means used to achieve it.”

Just because some Politician, Tribunal, or Judge rationalizes the inherent racism of affirmative action as not being discriminatory because it’s intent is to correct a past wrong… Not a current one, but a past one. The silliness of political doublespeak makes social and economic life like a Monty Python sketch… A rehearsed absurdity of Liberal impulses.

Up 20 Down 58

Jillian Chown on Apr 6, 2022 at 1:37 pm

I agree with "y'all are missing the forest though the trees." Most of these comments are racist, and scream of bigotry. Not sure how we can change this...sure more bigotry to come...

Up 72 Down 11

How would this play out? on Apr 6, 2022 at 12:37 pm

As a small business owner, when I hire someone I look at their credentials first. If they seem like they have the appropriate skills, they get an interview. If they seem like a good fit and check all the boxes they get the job and 3 months probation to prove they can do said job.

Nowhere in my job ads on yuwin or indeed do I list their heritage as a hiring preference.
My background is German, can you imagine the shitstorm if I ended my job ad write up with "preference will be given to German people".

But hey, it's not racist when the government does it with First Nations preference, even though as stated in the article, this policy is ineffective, so hey let's continue you with it.

Up 70 Down 11

bonanzajoe on Apr 6, 2022 at 11:55 am

Shortage of jobs? Then why do they have to bring in temporary foreign workers, to fill the shortage? I think there is a name for potential Naturalized Canadians who won't go after these jobs - "laziness". social assistance/welfare is too inviting.

Up 66 Down 12

bonanzajoe on Apr 6, 2022 at 11:46 am

BonfireJim: " Diversity is our strength." Then how come it's not working? Why does the government have to discriminate against the white race and give favour and priority to the others? JTs Diversity is our strength. is becoming a recipe for national disaster.

Up 25 Down 89

y'all are missing the forest though the trees on Apr 6, 2022 at 11:31 am

I think the point your are all missing or intentionally ignoring is that preferential hiring practices are a means to address systemic discrimination within hiring processes. This does not mean that less qualified people get positions based on skin color. it means that among equally qualified people, hiring preference is based on addressing other discriminatory factors. if we don't address inequity, we cannot address inequality.

further, Whitehorse Star. Your comment section really emboldens bigots to come out of the woodwork. as evidenced by some straight up racist comments on this very article. Do you think about this? Do you even care? Do you not feel a social responsibility to address this?

Up 61 Down 10

Groucho d'North on Apr 6, 2022 at 11:07 am

Interesting timing on this topic. The National Post has a story up on this matter at the federal level.
"...People should not be barred from jobs because of their skin colour, or their gender. We call that “discrimination” — and it’s generally considered a bad thing. It’s also bad that universities across Canada are refusing to hire white men for various research positions, simply because they’re white, male and don’t claim to have any disabilities.
https://nationalpost.com/opinion/jamie-sarkonak-why-canadian-universities-are-refusing-to-hire-able-bodied-white-males
When does woke become insomnia?

Up 33 Down 13

Reality is calling… It wants its sweater back! on Apr 6, 2022 at 9:53 am

Thank you - Juniper Jackson on Apr 5, 2022 at 4:36 pm;

We agree - There should be no social credit score system ( Made in China) based on the lie of group identities. Denny Kobayashi designs ugly building exteriors and now somehow, without the benefit of education or research, it is suggested that the workforce is more “capable” due to this supposed diversity? Seriously?

It is a gross distortion to commit society to a course of nascent emotionalism and the impulses that come with it. Human judgment and decision-making is not something people do in their own best interests - This Liberal/NDP wrecking ball alliance is imperilling us all… It’s just plain ugly.

You sir, have contributed to a much uglier world in the surrounding physical environs and the psychological commons. Your abrupt colour contrasts and architectural oddities are a grotesque abstraction of the modern politics of diversity… An actual perversity of diversity.

Up 20 Down 66

JC on Apr 6, 2022 at 7:07 am

All of the comments immediately assume the Indigenous candidate for hire is less qualified. This is exactly why these policies are needed because before the candidate even gets a chance to be considered for a position, prejudice prevails.

Up 55 Down 3

Yukonexe on Apr 6, 2022 at 7:02 am

Didn't Mayor Larua Cabott proclaim March 21 as International Day for Elimination of Racial Discrimination in Whitehorse?

Up 8 Down 15

Walks like a duck… on Apr 5, 2022 at 11:19 pm

To Mitch Holder on Apr 5, 2022 at 4:15 pm ~ I am trying to get a sense of your meaning with regard to your reference to the clarity of the ice on the bike trails for 10 months out of the year. It should be obvious given the timeframe involved in your reference that it cannot be that you intend clarity to be a stable construct. Is that not then in the other direction from clarity itself?

There are also a lot of people who bike year round, and there are those who walk on them. People drop litter on them, spill their drinks on them, animals pee on them, they are sanded, it freezes, melts, freezes, new snow compacts on the ice etc… It doesn’t seem likely that there is any real prospect for clarity at all.

It seems to me that this lack of clarity in your words and in the system is intended… Governmental system of classism - Absolutely agreed! They call it the need for diversity while it creates the discriminatory practices that give preferential treatment to one group over another. Then it Implements an anti-racism campaign here and there to combat the systemic racism it in fact created while blaming all of you… You are implicitly biased and it is this implicitness that blinds you to what you really are - RACIST! Thus, the government is chasing its own tail vicariously through its manipulation of you. The narrative proof is incontrovertible.

Up 78 Down 15

Jason on Apr 5, 2022 at 11:19 pm

This is appalling. I have always seen on job postings that First Nations will get preference. This left me thinking why? We are all equal and even more so in 2022. Hiring an individual or giving preferential treatment solely based on their race IS racism. Choosing someone who is brown over someone who is black despite having equal qualifications just because they’re brown is literally racism. If you even mention this in a public setting you’re branded a racist. Lord help the White Men/Women who publicly voice their opinion against this. What a disgrace this government policy is. You ship in people from Ontario, temporary foreign workers, and shun the local White/Black/Asian Male and Females because they don’t fit the bill even if they’re just as or overly qualified.

Disgusting

Up 75 Down 8

Guncache on Apr 5, 2022 at 9:46 pm

If I had a business/factory, I would hire whoever is best qualified for the job. I don't care if they are male, female, pink, white, brown, etc. Show up to work on time, be productive for 8 hours and don't whine.

Up 21 Down 60

I left YG on Apr 5, 2022 at 8:09 pm

You have to qualify for the position in order for the preference to apply. Trust me when I tell you they are not doing Yukon First Nation citizens any special favours to get them screened in.

For those saying it’s not fair, chances are you’re not a Yukon First Nation citizen, nor have you bothered to read Together Today for our Children Tomorrow.

Up 37 Down 11

Holy f@$% on Apr 5, 2022 at 5:55 pm

Check with WCC, lots there.

Up 61 Down 15

bonanzajoe on Apr 5, 2022 at 5:42 pm

One has to apply for a job to get one. And how come I don't see any indigenous people working in the fast food and retail businesses? Let's get an answer to these questions before legislating laws of racial discrimination.

Up 49 Down 14

drum on Apr 5, 2022 at 5:27 pm

The best qualified should get the job. Not just someone who qualifies because of soecial needs. ie. They happen to be a minor member of a special group!!!!!!!!

Up 43 Down 12

Patience, my child on Apr 5, 2022 at 5:13 pm

Don’t worry, Mr. Facts. White employees have been flocking to s**t jobs for years already after being shut out of competition & jobs for which they qualify.

Up 112 Down 24

Juniper Jackson on Apr 5, 2022 at 4:36 pm

I do not like or approve of preferential hiring practice. I think the best qualified person for the job should get the job. It doesn't matter what the color is of the persons applying. The only thing that should be considered is their ability to perform the job.

In Ottawa, people were hired, based on their reproductive parts. If you don't get the best person for the job, you don't get the best performance in that job.

How many excuses? I didn't get the job because I'm black, I didn't get the job because i am a woman, I didn't get the job because I'm a senior, I didn't get the job because I'm too young, I didn't get the job because the interviewer went to school with the other candidates and likes her/him best. and the ever popular.. I got the job because I'm FN, Black, Asian, Latino, Mexican, etc. and i can learn how to do it once i get into it. It is not complimentary to a person, no pride in employers being forced to hire you.

Up 128 Down 10

Karl on Apr 5, 2022 at 4:34 pm

Headline should read: Government Concludes Policy Ineffective, Extends Policy Anyway.

Up 81 Down 13

Mitch Holder on Apr 5, 2022 at 4:15 pm

"I make like, uh, I dunno, like 250?....."

Would you like me to put a name to that quote? I am all for diversity of the workplace, provided the individuals obtaining employement are:

a)able to operate in the same common language
b) the obviously most qualified candidate for the position, based on the criteria of said position and
c)believes the same two above mentioned points the rest of us do.

Anything other than that is detrimental in the long game. Call me what you want, I know I am not a racist, if anything, I am more critical of anti-racism than most precisely because I DO want it to work out. Be careful who arbitrates what is equal, the track record speaks to those in positions of inequitable have's dictating to have nots - and the have nots are simply too numerous to diminish by race, orientation, ethnicity or religion.

In short folks, follow the money all the way to the governmental systemic classism. It is as transparent as the ice on the bike trails we can't use 10 months of the year. Nuff said.

Up 29 Down 113

BonfireJim on Apr 5, 2022 at 3:38 pm

I am glad we are fighting for equal representation in this day and age.

Too many years of discriminatory hiring practices have set us behind. Diversity is our strength.

Up 108 Down 17

Thomas Brewer on Apr 5, 2022 at 3:27 pm

There's parallels in this article
"People should not be barred from jobs because of their skin colour, or their gender. We call that “discrimination” — and it’s generally considered a bad thing. It’s also bad that universities across Canada are refusing to hire white men for various research positions, simply because they’re white, male and don’t claim to have any disabilities."

https://nationalpost.com/opinion/jamie-sarkonak-why-canadian-universities-are-refusing-to-hire-able-bodied-white-males

Up 126 Down 21

Mr Facts on Apr 5, 2022 at 2:49 pm

While having a proper representation of our population is a good thing, hiring someone that might be less qualified based on their skin color is straight up discrimination and is bound to create problems. Imagine this policy at a fast food restaurant? "Well, yeah there's a lack of Caucasian employees, so I think we need a bit more diversity" . Yeah, I didn't think so, lol.

Up 147 Down 25

Matthew on Apr 5, 2022 at 1:53 pm

Like it or not, this IS racist. Just think, hiring upon race. Imagine a company only hired white people.. EVERY news outlet in the country woild throw them under the bus, think about the double standard here..

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.