Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

THE LAST STRAW – Robert Ryan stands outside the Farmer Robert’s store following last month’s flood caused by a ruptured water main. The 10-day forced closure was the last straw for the store’s survival, Ryan said this week.

Farmer Robert’s entering its final harvest

Fewer than three years after Robert Ryan opened the doors of the Farmer Robert’s store to customers,

By Stephanie Waddell on March 28, 2018

Fewer than three years after Robert Ryan opened the doors of the Farmer Robert’s store to customers, he will be shutting the store down permanently – and looking for a business that wants to rent the space off Quartz Road.

“It’s never been financially viable,” Ryan said in an interview Monday afternoon.

He spoke shortly after announcing the April 28th closure on social media.

The focus of the store was on selling locally made goods, meat and produce, along with a complement of organic goods from Outside.

A lunch counter inside the store also provides a number of noon-time options made with the goods the store sells.

Ryan said the concept of a store that focused on selling local goods from area farmers and others is one he thought would be embraced more than it has been.

While the store has its share of loyal customers to whom Ryan is grateful, he said it’s just not enough to keep things going.

The store’s been good at “scraping by” for about 18 months, he said.

In February, a flood that swept through the store from a nearby broken water main saw the store shut for 10 days.

Ryan said that’s not the reason for the closure, but “probably the straw that broke the camel’s back.”

As he noted, with the exception of the store’s local eggs that other businesses agreed to sell for him, the store was without any cash coming in for those 10 days.

Perhaps more importantly, it also caused him to take a closer look at the finances, and finally conclude it was time to close the doors.

Though he fully recognizes the city played no role in the store’s closure, he criticized city officials for not sending anyone to speak with him directly about it.

It would have been nice to have received some support from the city, he said.

He did draw support from owners of neighbouring businesses who let him to use their parking areas and sold eggs from the store for him.

As well as the flood, Ryan noted the opening of another major grocery chain since Farmer Robert’s opened also likely had an impact on business.

“They’ve watered down the market,” Ryan said.

More of the major stores have started carrying more local products since his shop opened, he pointed out, and that wasn’t largely available previously.

Ryan said it’s positive to see local goods more widely available.

For his shop, however, he wasn’t able to achieve as much as he wanted to getting the products to go further.

He noted there seems to be a difference as well in those who buy local and those who purchase organic goods.

Some customers were also looking for specific products. They weren’t interested in buying other items there, and that too had an impact.

He noted that because local products are not mass-produced and are of a higher quality, the cost is higher, and many don’t seem to understand that necessity, Ryan said.

He acknowledged as well that his skills are not in managing a grocery store as was required. That makes it difficult to compete with the larger chains.

“That’s one of the failings of the store,” he said, noting he is more of an entrepreneur than a manager.

Opening the business as a way of providing a year-round place where local farmers could sell their goods meant a lot of additional work as well – creating an egg grading station that needed to be federally inspected, for example.

With a staff of four, Ryan said, he’s grateful for those who have worked at the store, noting they have been “incredibly supportive” and understanding about its demise.

As the store heads into its final month of business, Ryan said he’s hoping faithful customers will visit and say hello.

While his focus is on the closure and selling off the store’s equipment, he noted he will eventually rent the space and decide what other endeavours he might pursue.

On social media, many Whitehorse residents are expressing disappointment with the closure.

They’re noting they will miss picking up some of their favourites at the store – lunch time soups, eggs, local quality produce and more.

Comments (7)

Up 2 Down 0

Capitan on Apr 3, 2018 at 10:18 am

@Local Businesswoman, it's not really fair to condemn this business, or any other, for wanting to cut their losses. It's true, I'm sure, that it takes awhile to realize any profits, but when you're continually only breaking even or slightly less, it could be just smart to want more for your life. Figuring out the grocery market in this town must be quite a trial. It couldn't have helped when Save on Foods opened, though he doesn't say anything about that. When you get past all the hype about city growth and so on, there's only so many people who live here. I know I wasn't missing a third or fourth or fifth grocery story, whichever number Save on represents. And Farmer Roberts didn't have a nationwide corporation to buffer its first few years. We never get to know how those chain supermarkets do up here year to year (do we?) It might give us a more realistic picture.

Up 2 Down 0

LocalBusinesswoman on Apr 2, 2018 at 8:12 am

Sad to see this place go out of business, like any other place. The problem is people are not willing to lose money, which most business do for the first 0-5 years before turning a profit. I ran a business for 13 years and shut it down in 2001 when the landlord wanted at that time $6,000 month rent which was outrageous, Bottom line if you want to make money, be willing to lose it first otherwise don't waste time and effort.

Up 6 Down 2

ProScience Greenie on Mar 31, 2018 at 9:53 am

Civic pride and responsibility runs high in Juneau and it shows when one visits that wonderful city BnR. In CoW there is some pride but it comes in second behind quick real estate and development profits ego-driven low quality city planning.

Whitehorse is no longer a quaint and pretty little city it was a mere 15 years ago. Especially this time of year when the garbage, needles and filth melt out of the snow. I truly want to love Whitehorse again like I once did but just can't. Thankfully I still get that feeling of pride when I visit Dawson, Mayo and the rest of our small towns where people are still real and quality of life trumps quick profits.

Up 10 Down 0

BnR on Mar 29, 2018 at 6:43 am

PSG, how on earth can you equate YXY to a “random no-name oil patch city”? The Yukon is a government territory. If anything, we’re a lot like Juneau; mostly gov, some random resource extraction.

Up 8 Down 2

Dentista on Mar 28, 2018 at 3:50 pm

I really appreciated your effort. I remember when Canadian Tire came and Nelson's Hardware shut down.

I wouldn’t describe Whitehorse as an “oil patch city”, as The Greenie does, but it sure has changed since I first moved up here in ‘73. It reminds me of a small southern city in British Columbia that has had the personality sucked right out of it.

Fortunately I live out of town where things are pretty much the same as they were 45 years ago.

Up 11 Down 1

Sillig on Mar 28, 2018 at 3:11 pm

PSG...a better question is how can anyone afford food at prices higher than at the box stores with every single facet of life in the Yukon at inflated prices to those in the south...with the exception of Vancouver..or Toronto.
When a mortgage is taking 50% of a monthly income folks ought to start looking there for some answers, and cures.

Up 4 Down 9

ProScience Greenie on Mar 28, 2018 at 2:41 pm

A big loss and too bad as it is/was a cool store. How does a small player compete in a town with an economy entirely based on a billion plus annual welfare payment from Ottawa and huge corporate big box stores and fast food joints. Sad seeing our fine little town turn into a clone of some random no-name oil patch city.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.