Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

City councillor Kirk Cameron

Councillor seeks clarity on mining within city

City councillor Kirk Cameron has asked for some clarification as to the city’s responsibilities and control over mining activity in the city – particularly the recently-approved permit for Gladiator Metals Corp.

By T.S. Giilck on January 23, 2024

City councillor Kirk Cameron has asked for some clarification as to the city’s responsibilities and control over mining activity in the city – particularly the recently-approved permit for Gladiator Metals Corp.

“I want to very carefully return to a topic that has been front and centre with the council over the last few weeks, and that’s about the Gladiator Metals activities in the southern parts of the city,” Cameron told his council colleagues Monday evening.

“There have been many pieces of input, good questions, thoughts, put forward about what’s appropriate for the city where mining and exploration for mining. There’s a very difficult balance.”

Cameron said he wanted clarification on the city’s responsibility for managing water.

“I’m trying to get a fix in my mind as to where our responsibilities lie to look after the interest of water quality for citizens.”

Cameron was told by city staff the territorial government “largely” has authority over the subject.

Mike Gau, the director of development services, said the permit provided to Gladiator came under Yukon government authorization.

“They set the thresholds of the activity that can be carried out,” he said.

“The legislation is within the Yukon government. They are the regulator. That has all been completed, we’re doing ongoing monitoring and we’ve done site inspections.

“We work collaboratively. We are not anticipating any significant impacts from the drilling exploration project that Gladiator is carrying out.”

Cameron responded to that information by asking, “So we’re comfortable with what the Yukon government has in place now and we’re going to get the detailed data that there will be substantive information that can go into the process to determine that there are environmental details here that has to be given serious attention? We’re comfortable they are doing their job?”

Cameron said some citizens are saying it’s more the city’s responsibility to make sound decision-making than the government’s.

“It’s our city,” he pointed out.

Gau said the exploration is a “data-gathering exercise” to find out if there are enough resources for Gladiator to expand its operations.

“There will be years of subsequent approval if the company deems it appropriate. At this time, it is a simple data-gathering exercise.”

The exploration permit for the city’s south end has stirred opposition from residents and the group Yukoners Concerned.

Comments (6)

Up 7 Down 1

Peter Lougheed on Jan 29, 2024 at 1:08 am

"Don't contaminate our water it's the most important resource we have." (Previous Alberta real Premier) "More important than oil."

Up 16 Down 4

North_of_60 on Jan 24, 2024 at 7:33 pm

Mining operations within city limits could be permitted in areas previously mined and zoned industrial.

Claim staking should not be permitted in any residential zones within city limits.

"Resident on Jan 23" makes good points, I concur.

Up 34 Down 24

Bruce Bark on Jan 23, 2024 at 6:38 pm

"Gau said the exploration is a data- gathering exercise." Gau is 100% correct with that statement, in fact their has never been an exploration project carried out that wasn't data collection. For those of you who are confused, the purpose of exploration is to find out what is down there. Really the only way do that is to drill a bunch of holes, log the holes (determine rock type, mineralization, strike and dip of the mineralization, etc. etc. ). After this data is collected, through tried and tested scientific methods a general calculation of the size of the deposit can be determined. This is what Geologist get paid to do. Can anyone point out a reason why we wouldn't want to know what is down there? Would it not be beneficial to everyone to have some sort of inventory of the mineralization that exists in the Yukon? Our future is going to depend on this inventory if we hope to carry out the EV dream, continue having cell phones, continue building windmills, continue bringing energy to our homes, and on and on.
So why don't people quit complaining, let the exploration company do their job, and then if results look favorable,( about a .01% chance that will happen), then we can have the discussion about whether it should be mined or not. Their are already a huge amount of hurdles to cross when or if that time comes. Meanwhile lets just see what's down there, the environmental impact is minimal.

Up 20 Down 13

Nathan Living on Jan 23, 2024 at 3:54 pm

From my perspective, Council does not seem to understand the overlapping nature of their own many bylaws.

It would be most appropriate for the City to just initiate legislative change that stops claim staking and mining within City limits. Unfortunately there seems to be intense conflict and animosity between the City and GY so who knows how effective the City may be.

Up 22 Down 3

Resident on Jan 23, 2024 at 3:18 pm

The City controls zoning. It can determine if the requested use is appropriate for the requested zoning and if the requested zoning is appropriate for the requested area.

If the City doesn't want mining inside city limits, it can remove mining-related activities as a primary use in all zones and request that YTG withdraw all land within Whitehorse city limits from staking. It would start a few court battles but at least there'd be a solid answer if the Quartz Mining Act supersedes the Municipal Act.

If the City wants to allow mining in certain areas, that's what the OCP and Zoning Bylaw are for.

Up 25 Down 31

Yukon56 on Jan 23, 2024 at 2:58 pm

Mining made this territory NIMB's go home all Legal

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.