Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Hugh Neff

Suspension of Quest musher upheld following hearing by review board

The suspension of Yukon Quest dog musher Hugh Neff has been upheld following a two-day hearing in Fairbanks earlier this month.

By Chuck Tobin on June 27, 2018

The suspension of Yukon Quest dog musher Hugh Neff has been upheld following a two-day hearing in Fairbanks earlier this month.

The three-member review board ruled that Neff did not present any “clear and convincing evidence” to overturn the suspension, the Yukon Quest organization noted in press release issued Tuesday.

Neff’s dog Boppy died Feb. 9 while his team was resting at the Clinton Creek rest stop, just before the halfway point between Fairbanks and Dawson City.

An initial report following the necropsy – animal autopsy – showed the dog died of aspiration pneumonia caused by inhaling vomited stomach contents.

The final report indicated the dog was in poor shape prior to the race, and was suffering from whipworm, stomach ulcers and muscle wasting.

“These things are very disturbing, and this dog was in a bad condition before it even aspirated and that was our biggest concern,” veterinarian Kathleen McGill, chair of the rules committee, told the Star in an April 25 interview.

The suspension was announced April 24, more than two months after Alaskan Quest musher Allen Moore crossed the Whitehorse finish line to win his third Yukon Quest.

The race organization ruled that because of Neff’s breach of dog care standards, he would not be allowed to race in next year’s 1,000-mile Yukon Quest or the Yukon Quest 300. The 300 serves as one of the options for mushers interested in qualifying to run the long distance race.

As part of the suspension, the organization ruled Neff will also have to run a Quest 300 before being allowed to run the 1,000 mile race again.

The rules allowed Neff to request a hearing into the suspension, so that he could present his defence. In keeping with Neff’s request, the three-member board was made up of one musher, one veterinarian and one community member.

“The purpose of the informal hearing was to provide Neff and the Yukon Quest with a full and fair opportunity to present their opposing evidence to a review board. Once the evidence was presented, the review board deliberated and made a decision.

“After two days of confidential testimony, the review board concluded that Hugh Neff did not provide clear and convincing evidence to overturn the censure. The review board voted unanimously to uphold the Yukon Quest censure.”

While Neff declined to be interviewed in the days after the suspension was announced, he did release a YouTube video in which he suggested the motivation behind the suspension was personal.

Comments (1)

Up 4 Down 2

Amil Dupuis-Rossi on Jun 28, 2018 at 9:46 am

Finally, mushers are being held accountable! The race should be held accountable too, nevertheless, congrats of taking a stand! I applaud the Quest for starting this dialogue and for making small steps towards change. It's unacceptable that living beings are being treated this way and even worse how most of us are so cavalier about it. IMO this is a sign of a very disconnected human, which should be seen as very alarming and concerning to everyone! This dog, and others, were essentially being tortured as we all looked on. Shame on all of us for being so resigned to their suffering.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.