Whitehorse Daily Star

Tearful mom speaks of pain of son’s loss

Michael MacPherson was in Yukon Supreme Court this morning

By Chuck Tobin on February 21, 2017

Michael MacPherson was in Yukon Supreme Court this morning for the beginning of his sentencing hearing for fatally stabbing Tanner Sinclair in a fight.

Originally charged with second-degree murder, MacPherson pleaded guilty to manslaughter earlier this month.

The plea to the lesser criminal charge of manslaughter angered Sinclair’s family, many whom have travelled to Whitehorse from Alberta to present victim impact statements.

Sinclair’s mother, Wendy Sinclair, read her victim impact to the court late this morning, continuously sobbing as she described the loving bond she and her 27-year-old son had.

The court convened this morning with Crown prosecutor Eric Marcoux reading the facts of the case into the record.

They indicate there was tension between MacPherson, 34, and Sinclair over a truck MacPherson had obtained from Sinclair.

The two were at a barbecue hosted by Kory Basaraba at his home in Copper Ridge on the night of July 14, 2014.

Basaraba, MacPherson and Sinclair had made their way down to The Ridge pub. A security video showed the three standing around the bar chatting, with no aggressive behaviour apparent.

A short time later, a video overseeing the parking lot seemed to show a bit of aggression between MacPherson and Sinclair.

All three eventually returned to Basaraba’s home on Lazulite Drive, where an encounter between MacPherson and Sinclair began in the backyard.

“By all accounts, everything seemed to be going well until Mr. MacPherson began making comments about the truck that Mr. Sinclair sold him,” reads the agreed statement of facts.

“Mr. Sinclair made a remark to the effect that he should just knock Mr. MacPherson out, to which Mr. MacPherson replied, ‘Just do it.’”

A fight ensued, and Sinclair was stabbed four times by a knife that had been left on a backyard table, after Sinclair had to remove all his tools from his truck because of vehicle problems.

The court heard of several deep stab wounds and how, after being transported to Whitehorse General Hospital, Sinclair died of his wounds several hours later.

The court also heard this morning how MacPherson’s criminal record includes two convictions for assault with a weapon, one in 2001, and one in 2007.

The conviction in 2007 occurred in a bar incident when MacPherson struck a man in the face with a beer glass, after the man became upset by comments MacPherson had made to his girlfriend. The victim received 96 stitches to his face and lost the vision in his right eye.

Before the court was to hear victim impact statements from six to eight people, some of which include Sinclair’s family, the Crown asked Justice Leigh Gower for a brief adjournment to organize the statements.

Following the emotional address to the court by Wendy Sinclair, the court heard from Whitney Sandulak, Sinclair’s widow and the mother of two young daughters, one born within two months of her dad’s death.

Referring to MacPherson only by his last name, she told of how the death of her husband has robbed her and her daughters of a loving husband and father.

She called MacPherson a coward, a coward who has shown no remorse, a coward who turned to the easy life of drugs rather pursuing a life of love and hard work, as her husband had.

“You, MacPherson, will never be the man he was, not even close,” Sandulak said. “You’re a weak coward that took the life of a innocent man. We all know the truth and we all know who Tanner was.

“And you knew, in order to take him down, you would had to catch him by surprise and use force with a weapon because you knew you would never take him man-to-man.”

Sandulak told of how she went to the hospital after going to their neighours’ to see about all the emergency vehicles. After she identified herself as Sinclair’s wife, she was told by the police she should hurry because there’d been a stabbing.

The widow told the court how, after conferring with the doctors, she authorized them to take her husband off life-support at 5:36 a.m.

At that moment, she told Justice Gower, she and her daughter and her unborn daugher were given a life sentence, a “life sentence without any chance of parole.”

Following Sinclair’s death on the morning of July 25, 2014, MacPherson turned himself in to police on Vancouver Island in the company of his lawyer.

He was released on $25,000 bail in May 2015 but was brought back into custody on Jan. 3 of this year for breach of his release conditions.

During a search, authorities turned up a bag of crushed drugs, a bag with fentanyl in it and a bottle with clean urine.

The sentencing hearing was expected to carry on into Wednesday.

Comments (12)

Up 7 Down 12

BB on Feb 24, 2017 at 2:25 pm

JP - you are absolutely correct. I just re-read this. Sinclair was quoted as saying, "I should just knock you out." - which is a threat. I would agree that he started the actual fight which ended in his own death.
If you start a fight and the other person feels like he doesn't stand a chance and grabs a weapon, I'd say you do in fact hold a fair bit of responsibility in terms of how that fight ends.
Sinclair's own wife said in her victim impact statement that McPherson would not have stood a chance in a fist fight with her husband. I guess McPherson felt the same way.
Good eye. Reducing situations to that level does sometimes have consequences that aren't what you planned for.

Up 11 Down 3

Don tango. on Feb 24, 2017 at 2:24 pm

When has anyone ever walked away from a fight a winner? I get angry...but I will never understand fighting someone over meaningless $h. There are very few actual reasons to fight with someone in this world. People are just stupid. How hard is it to not be a pile of $h, how hard is it not to be a waste of space...how hard is it to actually be a good person and be nice to people? Apparently hard for a lot of people. I hate Whitehorse.

Up 12 Down 2

JP on Feb 24, 2017 at 11:57 am

@BB Actually according to the report above it was Sinclair who started the fight. Not excusing what happened by any means though. Bringing a knife to a fistfight is inexcusable.

Also, nothing ever good comes from a fistfight. You never know how your opponent will react or what weapons they might have, what they might grab, etc. You also might unintentionally kill someone if you land a knockout swing and that person smashes their head off of the pavement or some hard object. Then you end up in jail with a lifelong record.

It's really too bad so many young men are still willing to throw punches despite all those risks. Sadly, this tragedy isn't the first and won't be the last.

Up 21 Down 2

George kilpatrick on Feb 23, 2017 at 5:04 am

New information, to me that he actually filled the truck with gas then blamed Tanner. Have you ever seen what happens to a diesel when you fill it with gas? I have seen those effects, it seizes right up. This boy and I mean boy, has ruined the eye sight of another man and disfigured his face. When will the law realize he has added nothing to society, now he has taken the life of Tanner. How many more victims will the courts be responsible for. Before they deal with him, he seriously has taken way more than he will ever give. It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God, when you don't repent and turn away from wickedness.

Up 25 Down 2

BB on Feb 22, 2017 at 7:59 pm

Too bad the truck didn't blow up with this loser in it. Would have been better for everyone. I can't believe the prosecution agreed to let this be called manslaughter. It wasn't an accident - he started the fight, uttered threats, then stabbed someone 4x with a knife.

My only question would be, why were these people hanging out with this known drug dealer and loser in the first place?

Up 36 Down 5

Neanderthal_On_The_Loose on Feb 22, 2017 at 2:42 pm

Holy **** ! is that true? That he fuelled up a diesel with gasoline, couldn't figure out why the truck failed, and so set about slaughtering the seller? That is beyond retarded. That is sub-Cro-Magnon in lack of intelligence. This cretin should be locked up for eternity, for his own, and society's good !

Up 16 Down 3

Garth on Feb 22, 2017 at 2:04 pm

@jc
While I consistently am amazed at sentences handed down for serious crimes....your suggestion that he won't even be given federal time is a joke. Absolute min would prob be 6, but probably 10+

Up 16 Down 6

Politico on Feb 22, 2017 at 8:41 am

It's amazing so many people complain about the justice system but they keep electing the same politicians who don't change anything. You vote the politicians in, you complain about the system and the politicians you elect don't do anything. Who's really at fault for a broken system?

Up 16 Down 13

Justice on Feb 22, 2017 at 6:50 am

Damien, the "Yukon justice system"? What, like the Yukon has its own separate criminal code?? C'mon people, if you are going to comment on our legal system, at least take the time to familiarize yourself with how it works.
Better that this guy is convicted of manslaughter than going through a trial and being acquitted on second degree charges, because being a betting man, I'd lay money the prosecution felt that a guilty verdict for second degree murder charge was not a foregone conclusion, if it went before a jury.

Up 9 Down 0

Lindsay on Feb 22, 2017 at 2:50 am

Things were not removed from Sinclair's truck that broke down. Clerical error on the reporters part. Basaraba had the broken down truck that things were removed from.

Up 14 Down 2

jc on Feb 21, 2017 at 5:54 pm

2 years less a day less time served? I will be surprised if it's anything more.

Up 114 Down 2

Damien Lankow on Feb 21, 2017 at 3:51 pm

MacPherson is not only a coward but also as sharp as a bowl of jello. The reason that the truck he bought didn't work was because he put gas in it and it was a diesel. But for some reason that's the sellers fault? Using a knife in a fist fight shows your true colours, just like using a bar mug to slice a guys face open. You sure are tough. Eventually you'll pay for this properly rather than just through the pathetic Yukon justice system.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.