Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Yukon Senator Dan Lang, Former Yukon senator Ione Christensen and Premier Darrell Pasloski

Red chamber voice called crucial for Yukoners

Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s latest move in a constitutional chess game was played last Friday when he vowed to not appoint any more senators.

By Aimee O'Connor on July 29, 2015

Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s latest move in a constitutional chess game was played last Friday when he vowed to not appoint any more senators.

By closing the door to the Red Chamber, Harper hopes to put pressure on the nation’s provinces and territories to make plans for Senate reform – and, if they don’t act, “the only way to deal with the status quo is abolition.”

With 22 vacant seats in the 105-seat chamber, the ultimatum will likely hit harder in jurisdictions with fewer seats.

Yukon Senator Dan Lang told the Star this week that his six years in office have shown him the importance of having two voices for the territory in federal politics, the other being Yukon MP Ryan Leef.

“I do think that the provinces, especially smaller provinces and territories, have to be very concerned that they don’t lose these political voices in the Senate,” Lang said.

“They are representatives of the region at the end of the day.”

Former Yukon senator Ione Christensen, who held a Liberal seat for about seven years, said today having a Yukon senator helps to inform federal ministers of northern issues.

“From here, it’s hard to get access to ministers ... and as a parliamentarian, your voice carries a lot further,” she said in an interview today.

Leef told the Star Harper has been consistent in his message, and that his public vow to not appoint new senators is “nothing new.”

Harper has not made a recommendation for a potential senator to the Governor General in about 2 1/2 years.

However, he has appointed 59 senators during his time in office – despite his declaration back in 2004 that he “will not name appointed people to the Senate.”

Harper’s reluctance to put bottoms in the 22 empty seats has already been challenged by Vancouver lawyer Aniz Alani.

Alani argues that Harper is under constitutional obligation to fill Senate seats because provinces are under-represented.

In May, a Federal Court justice rejected the government’s application to dismiss the case.

Christensen told the Star Harper’s move will be shortlived.

“Once he gets to a certain point, by law, he will have to start appointing again.”

Leef echoed the prime minister’s thought process: “If (the Senate) can’t be reformed, it should be abolished.”

If provinces provide comments and options for Senate reform, Leef said, the Yukon needs to be part of that discussion.

Last year, the Supreme Court ruled that abolishing the Senate would require unanimous provincial consent – while reforming could occur with a constitutional amendment approved by at least seven provinces representing 50 per cent of Canada’s population.

That, however, does not include a vote from any of the territories.

“(Harper) has put the ball back into premiers’ hands,” Premier Darrell Pasloski said in an interview.

“It is clear from the Supreme Court that Ottawa cannot make unilateral changes to the Senate.

“As the upcoming chair for the Council of the Federation, that puts me in a good position to help move this forward even though we don’t actually get a vote (constitutionally).”

The role of federation chair goes hand-in-hand with hosting the annual Canada’s Premiers’ Conference, which Whitehorse will be hosting next summer.

“It’s really important for Yukoners to realize that if they say, ‘Abolish the Senate,’ they’re (essentially) saying representation would go from two to one,” Lang said.

Similarly, if Lang were to resign from the chamber, the territory’s voices would also be broken in half – if Harper keeps up the moratorium on senator appointments.

If the worst was to happen, Leef said, it would be a “challenge” for the territory, but Yukoners could “reflect on positive representation (in the Senate) from the past.”

Although the Yukon Party has not yet developed a position on whether the Senate should be reformed or abolished, Pasloski said not having a Yukon senator might negatively impact the territory.

“All of our senators have been very hardworking advocates on behalf of Yukoners,” he said.

After the upcoming federal election, there will be 338 members of Parliament. That is 30 more seats due to legislation introduced back in 2011.

“That’s 443 voices between the Senate and the House of Commons,” Pasloski said. “To have just one voice there is pretty small.

“I think that’s not just a reflection of the Yukon, but the North itself.”

Lang hopes the decision for the Senate’s future will happen sooner, rather than later.

“The Senate has to function. It is part of the Constitution.”

Christensen hopes the continued debate of the Red Chamber’s future will help more people understand what the government body does.

“The big thing is transparency, for the public to be able to see how the Senate is working and how they are available to people,” said Christensen, who is also a former Whitehorse mayor and Yukon commissioner.

“I don’t blame people for not understanding it.”

Comments (22)

Up 52 Down 1

Dr. Dave on Aug 3, 2015 at 5:04 pm

Danny Lang, or should I say Daniel, recommended a missile defence shield to protect us from god knows what, perhaps those pesky Russians. He should take his politics and move to the U.S. where they would be more appreciated. Enough said.

Up 40 Down 2

YukonMax on Aug 2, 2015 at 8:20 am

“They are representatives of the region at the end of the day.”
I wish they would represent the population as well!

Up 56 Down 1

Jwhite on Aug 1, 2015 at 12:46 pm

CJ - the Yukon has only had 3 senators. The first was Lucier, the fireman who immediately moved to BC. Then there was Ms. Christianson, who represented the Yukon well in my opinion. Now we have Mr. Lang, whose major contribution has been to head a committee that recommended Muslim religious leaders should be licensed - we should all be embarassed.

Up 41 Down 126

YTer on Jul 31, 2015 at 6:39 pm

Mary laker
Ione aloof? Do you know her? Give her a call, maybe, if you are polite, she'll have you over for some Sourdough pancakes and have a friendly chat on the senate. Check your 'tude at the door though.

Up 40 Down 121

BnR on Jul 31, 2015 at 6:33 pm

Mary laker
Perhaps you need to delve a bit deeper re. the purpose of the senate. The senate is there for all of Canada, not just the Yukon, that's Ryan's role.
So many people jumping on the abolish the senate bandwagon with no real idea of the workings of our political system, nor with any coherent plan on a replacement.
Sigh......

Up 73 Down 170

CJ on Jul 30, 2015 at 10:16 pm

I'm disappointed Dan Lang has been so insular since he was appointed to the Senate. Not that I agree with his politics, but I don't see why he had to get so elusive. Senators here used to write regular updates in the newspaper. I can't remember if Ione Christensen did, but they helped you remember they were doing something, and it was kind of nice to know they hadn't forgotten their roots. Plus he's given very few interviews even when some very contentious legislation has been discussed.

But I'm not into burning everything to the ground. Unlike Conservatives, I didn't hate everything about Canada as it was before they came on the scene. The Senate could be better, but I'm not losing sleep over it. At least it's providing some entertainment lately.

Up 30 Down 6

mary laker on Jul 30, 2015 at 6:30 pm

Mike:

Ione Christianson worked with FASSY for six years, volunteers to do talks, and helped out on a bird book. Well that's something for the $120,000 a year plus benefits. The fact that she was the mayor and received accolades prior to becoming a senator gives her political credibility, though I would not demand that a person be politically active in order to become a senator.

Thank you for letting me know that Ione has in fact volunteered to do some important work around town. Fact is Mike, I know of many others who do the same. I also volunteer. Without getting too specific, have at times dedicated many, many hours, and dollars, to causes I believe are worthy.

I still do not believe she earns her $120,000 a year plus benefits, and I still believe the senate is on the whole a disgrace. Ione is not a disgrace, but the institution as it stands and the rampant abuses that go on there are. No doubt she is one of the better senators.

Up 7 Down 14

Geoff Capp on Jul 30, 2015 at 6:23 pm

Yukon should hold a Senate election. Harper has happily appointed people who win an electoral choice for senator. Just copy the Alberta legislation, adapt it for a single seat to be filled, and establish the timing to coincide with the next municipal, territorial or federal voting date, whichever comes no less than 37 days after nominations open.

Up 112 Down 5

Mike on Jul 30, 2015 at 3:45 pm

I challenge anyone to point to a single positive thing Lang has done for the Yukon.

Up 33 Down 28

Mike McCann on Jul 30, 2015 at 3:07 pm

To Mary Laker ... you seem to ask what Ione Christensen has been up to and seem to suggest that somehow she is living life large at the tax payers expense. Mrs. Christensen did not and has not sought public recognition for what she did and continues to do either when an elected official or today as an incredibly active volunteer in our community.

Though long retired she willingly offers her time to volunteer organizations and NGOs.

Up until this year she had been the Chair of the Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Society of Yukon for more than six years and continues to be an advocate for persons with intellectual abilities. This coming September 9th you can probably find her down at Shipyards Park flipping hamburgers for FASD International Awareness Day.

In addition she frequently volunteers her time to give talks on the history of Whitehorse and the Yukon at the McBride Museum or talks on Yukon birds.

She was the driving force behind the creation of a wonderful book entitled "Whitehorse: an illustrated history" that was released about a year ago. Over a three year period she volunteered thousands of hours to bring this project to completion.

She was the first woman mayor of Whitehorse (1975) and Commissioner (1979). She was made a Member of the Order of Canada in 1994 and served as the Yukon's Senator from 1999 to 2006.

Ione is one of those rare individuals who gives back without out thought of what she will receive.

So, Mary Laker, if you haven't heard what Ione Christensen has been up to it is because she doesn't seek recognition.
I would respectful suggest that we can all learn something from her regarding selfless community service.

Up 157 Down 275

steve on Jul 30, 2015 at 1:22 pm

First it would be asinine to abolish the senate as it is supposed to be a check against the government.
The only reason Harper wants it abolished is so he can ram more legislation down our throats selling off Canada to the Corps and foreign owners!! He is also pissed most of his appointees are corrupt. Hmmm like him and his government.

The problem is twofold, first the senators are appointed and second are affiliated with a party.

Fix it in three ways
1) The senators are elected for a set term(4 yrs).
2) They should have absolutely no party affiliation.
3) The senators can only spend $10k on election or re-election. Make it open to everyone.

This should go for Councillors, MLAs and MPs!!!!! Parties only look after the special interest groups and not the public.

Up 66 Down 5

mary laker on Jul 30, 2015 at 12:03 pm

Danny Lang as our 'political voice' carried the motion to reduce environmental reviews of resource extraction projects in the Yukon. The job that YESSA does is getting bigger due to HarperCon reduced reviews in other areas. Danny wants to make sure that those reductions in oversight are meaningful by holding YESSA to limits in their time allowed to do their work. They are playing whack-a-mole with environmental review.

Danny has been a voice for Stephen Harper in the Yukon, period. As is the way of his people in the HarperCon party. The senate is supposed to be non-partisan, but you see Danny at every Harper bbq, and every conservative event. He is a puppet on a string and the senate is a joke.

As for Ione, I have heard nothing from her for years. I am sure she is enjoying the paycheck and benefits. At least I can make statements about Dan Lang while he plays the party hack. At least he is out talking to people. I like Dan Lang. Don't like his politics, don't like his puppet show. Ione strikes me as so aloof that I don't even know her.

Abolish the senate.

Up 20 Down 35

north_of_60 on Jul 30, 2015 at 10:36 am

Abolish the Senate and give each Territory two MPs, with one representing the rural ridings and the other for the capitol city.

Up 251 Down 100

Abolishinist on Jul 30, 2015 at 7:49 am

End needless wanton waste. Abolish the Senate and the Conservatives.

Up 78 Down 10

Mosse101 on Jul 30, 2015 at 5:56 am

Abolish the Senate June Jackson's comments are spot on .

Up 52 Down 7

Joseph Campbell on Jul 29, 2015 at 10:19 pm

The United States is approximately 10 times the size of Canada. Canada has 338 Members of Parliament and 105 Senators. The U.S. have a total of 100 Senators and 100 Congressman/women representing over 300 million people and doing the same job as Canada's MPs and Senators representing about 34 million people. Whats wrong with this picture? Perhaps it's time Canadians did the math and got rid of all our useless Senators and at least half of the incompetent MPs.

Up 39 Down 6

Lost in the Yukon on Jul 29, 2015 at 6:47 pm

If we had a Senator of the stature and integrity of the Honorable Ione Christensen then I would argue to try and fix the Senate; unfortunately we do not.

What we have is a Senator that is merely a puppet for the Conservative Party who has distinguished himself by working against Yukon First Nations (remember Bill S-6 - this will be Mr. Lang's legacy, his total disrespect for Yukon First Nations).

Mr. Lang does not bring value to the table. He has enjoyed his privileged ride at the tax payers expense and it is now time for him to put the spin documents away, look at himself squarely in the mirror and realize he needs to do the honorable thing and exit stage right (after all he is a Conservative and no way would he exit stage left).

Up 21 Down 7

Mark S on Jul 29, 2015 at 6:38 pm

I forgot to say

Santa is important
The Senate is not important

Up 9 Down 150

Yukon 56 on Jul 29, 2015 at 6:08 pm

“That’s 443 voices between the Senate and the House of Commons,” Pasloski said. “To have just one voice there is pretty small. WTF, Is there no one who took history in high school and the Representation by population. crunch the numbers, population as to allocated seats

Up 178 Down 350

YTer on Jul 29, 2015 at 4:59 pm

It's easy for people like June to simply say abolish the senate. However, that's easier said than done. What would we do in it's stead? Re-do our constitution and adopt an American style system? This is akin to saying get rid of oil. Ok, sure. How? Then what? And replace it with??.
The senate doesn't need scrapping, it just needs to have good senators appointed. Of the three leaders, Justin's idea of having all three party's involved in the appointment of non-partisan candidates seems the best idea so far. Look at the RCMP. It's had all sorts of issues, but there is no talk of scrapping that institution. If it's broken, just fix it, don't throw it away.

Up 525 Down 314

Mark S on Jul 29, 2015 at 4:06 pm

I agree with the federal NDP leader, lets just abolish the Senate and move on.

The Yukon will often be an afterthought however politicians love visiting here and they keep giving us money thus we do not need senators like Mr. Lang selling who we are and what we have and do not have.

Up 526 Down 322

June Jackson on Jul 29, 2015 at 3:58 pm

The Senate should be abolished. No matter what anyone calls it, it's nothing but a money pit, it is a rewarded position for party faithful, appointed by Harper but paid for by the taxpayer. The Provinces abolished the provincial senates a long time ago and don't seem to be suffering. Throw all the Chamber of sober second thoughts you want to, its still a graft ridden corrupt hole.

If I were collecting upwards of $120. k a year, perks, pensions, travel, housing allowances, incidentals, per diems I'd be defending that job too. I'd be screaming to the heavens how important that job is. Hmmmm.. I think Lang is looking after Lang.. Lang has been in the gravy boat since 2008..

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.