Whitehorse Daily Star

Layoffs disappoint premier, EMR minister

Another 50 Pelly Construction employees are being laid off at the Minto Mine, the mine announced this morning.

By Chuck Tobin on September 17, 2014

Another 50 Pelly Construction employees are being laid off at the Minto Mine, the mine announced this morning.

Vice-president Cindy Burnett of Capstone Mining said the company has not been able to get a full green light to carry on with the next phase of operations and begin stripping and preparing the new Minto North open-pit deposit.

While the Yukon government has indicated its approval for the company to begin stripping, the Yukon Water Board insists Capstone must first receive an amendment to its water licence or receive a new licence, she explained.

Burnett said Capstone did not want to proceed in light of the water board’s position, and the ore body in the existing open pit has now been all mined out.

“We were working with everyone involved to see if it was something we could do, just could not get there,” Burnett said. “We have chosen the most prudent course of action for the company.”

The Capstone vice-president said the company expects to have the required licences by the end of the year, which would mean going back to full operations in January with a full complement of Pelly Construction employees.

Capstone applied for a new water licence in July.

Pelly is contracted by Capstone to carry out the open pit mining operations and other heavy equipment work at the mine site.

Capstone said in its news release today it will keep 15 Pelly employees for other ongoing work requiring heavy equipment.

It also pointed out the layoffs will not affect production through 2015 because there is enough ore stockpiled and coming from the underground operations to keep the mill running.

Capstone employs approximately 180 directly.

Burnett said Capstone is still assessing whether the layoffs will affect the number of support staff needed at the mine site.

There was a layoff of 44 Pelly employees last January when production in the existing open pit was cut in half to prolong the ore body and keep Pelly working for as long as possible, hopefully until the next phase of stripping and preparing the new pit was allowed.

Burnett said the ore in the existing pit has now been depleted.

The first layoff notices were issued this morning, as there was a crew change occurring this morning, Burnett said.

Capstone applied in July for a new water licence and an amendment to its Quartz Mining Licence.

Pelly Construction vice-president Jennifer Byram said this afternoon the layoffs will be complete in the next week.

With a Pelly crew of 15 staying on, the company is assessing who will remain, she said.

Byram said it’s disappointing, but Pelly Construction and its employees knew there was an issue surrounding the required licensing.

Nonetheless, she said, Pelly only learned of Capstone’s decision this morning; that it was business as usual Tuesday.

Pelly has been assured once the licences are in place, the company will be back to work immediately with the entire 112-person workforce it was at prior to last January’s layoffs of the first 44, she said.

Byram said Pelly is not planning to remove any of its big gear from the mine site, and isn’t even thinking about it.

Capstone has been good to Pelly Construction, she emphasized.

Byram acknowledges another downside to layoffs in addition to the loss of work for employees is the risk of losing those employees to other companies.

“We know that the Yukon government and the water board have done what they could to process those (licences) fairly and without jeopardizing what those permits mean, and we were hoping a solution could happen,” she said.

The government maintains it has the sole authority under its Quartz Mining Licence to allow the Minto Mine to begin the next phase of stripping overburden from the new pit site, without the water board’s approval.

Two years ago, the Minto Mine began stripping the existing open pit with the government’s blessing, but without an amendment to its water licence.

When the water board did issue a new licence several months later in the fall of 2012, it emphasized that it was the board’s position the stripping work conducted that spring did require – but did not have – the board’s approval. The mine was in breach of its water licence when it conducted the stripping in the spring of 2012, the board said.

Burnett said this morning the board has indicated recently in writing the company needs an amendment or a new licence before it can begin the next phase of stripping.

While the water board is a government agency, the Yukon Supreme Court has ruled the board is a quasi-judicial body which operates independently under its own authority, and is not beholding to the Yukon government in any way.

Energy, Mines and Resources Minister Scott Kent released a statement at 12:30 p.m. indicating his disappointment and the disappointment of Premier Darrell Pasloski regarding the layoffs.

The government is still of the mind that the water board’s approval is not needed to begin stripping the next pit, that the work would be covered by the existing water licence and an amendment to the Quartz Mining Licence, Kent said.

He said the required amendment from his department under the mining licence is ready to go.

“Today’s announcement emphasizes the critical importance of our continuing work to harmonize mine licensing and permitting in Yukon,” said the minister. “We have made progress, but there is still important work to complete.

“Our government will continue our work with industry and the water board on the Mine Licence Improvement Initiative, aimed to better clarify roles and reduce uncertainty for companies.”

Comments (12)

Up 21 Down 12

Headline Rewrite on Sep 21, 2014 at 1:49 pm

The headline for this story should have been:
Poor planning by mining company results in layoffs.
What kind of business waits to the last minunte, permitting should be complete well in advance of stripping. Someone at Capstone should be accountable for this.
Don't forget this is the same company that had to release tainted water into the creek there when their dam couldn't hold all the water generated from the mine and naturally. This is a sign that the environment is not a priority for them.
Yukon needs to develop based on science not greed!!

Up 12 Down 8

Biggest Hold Back to our economy on Sep 21, 2014 at 9:51 am

The Yukon potential in resource development, specialty development in tourism, agriculture, aquaculture, forestry and the real major opportunity is in hydro. How we do it is to see the opportunities and know how to support development. Energy Mines and Resources people have worked very hard on resource development and made it take place. The present government put in place a structure so development can take place. A lot of regions in Canada think the Yukon has one of the best structures for developing resources. One of the hold backs is government departments do not have employees who know anything about development and don't want development because that would mean that they have to take responsibility. The Yukon Government has to retool some key departments so opportunities can be developed, not stopped.

Up 15 Down 11

Community Gal on Sep 20, 2014 at 8:33 am

The private sector, businesses like Capstone Mining, actually generate wealth and boost our economy. Government takes wealth from companies and tries to redistribute it to those in need. Without industry, no new wealth can be generated. When government and NGO agencies think that they are an actual driving force in the economy then we are all in trouble. People actually think that sitting in meetings talking ad nauseum about plans and projects is doing something. Fact is, delays and endless bureaucratic levels drive the cost of doing business through the roof. Result? No wealth or "real" jobs created. Long term result? Young people leave the territory for opportunities elsewhere.

Up 10 Down 8

Josey Wales on Sep 19, 2014 at 6:15 pm

Francis...b power purdy much summed it up. We do and have lived in essentially a welfare state courtesy of the rest of Canada that many seem to loathe at times.

Living off transfer payments as we do and decorating this town and territory with bling to the levels we do really... is like someone on SS who works out at the gym 6 hours a day, then sits on their leather couch in their rented home...and watches their cable TV on a 80" plasma screen whilst skype'n on their laptop to their friends outside...telling them to mind their business when suggestions come up on breaking "the cycle".
Mining cannot do it alone, nor can tourism. We may be able to do it ourselves (feed our economy) but I doubt it. As too many here enjoy the good life, a life heavily subsidized by "outsiders".

And the party I helped put in office is bragging in ads about our "record budget"?
W...T...H...did they borrow the bong from city hall?
Silly me, I forgot with our record budget...they each bought their own.
Really folks it sounds like I'm a jokin'...but I often think our overlords, must be tokin.

Up 10 Down 6

Starman on Sep 19, 2014 at 3:07 pm

Take the money you want too spend on tracking and use it here to help the company and you also have investment in your own territory. Wake up Yukon government.

Up 32 Down 25

CJ on Sep 18, 2014 at 9:18 am

How much of this messaging is about trying to convince the public that the permitting is too onerous for our oh so special and precious mining companies? It feels pretty manipulative to me. The headlines could also be, "Capstone fails to comply with Yukon's regulatory regime at the expense of its workforce and government EI program."

Up 21 Down 9

Yukoner 2 on Sep 18, 2014 at 9:01 am

It's not mining to many new granolas here for that. it's a false economy and when the bottom falls out they can all go home never to return. Wishful thinking Unfortunately between the COW and Gov this place will never be the same.

Up 30 Down 3

b. power on Sep 17, 2014 at 9:01 pm

Francias

Transfer payments from the rest of Canada. seriously, 34,000 people and a budget of over a billion dollars. 90% of which are transfers.

Do the math on the dollars per resident, is shocking how much cash is infused here
That's the true Yukon economy.

Up 26 Down 9

I know on Sep 17, 2014 at 6:26 pm

The question is "What is driving the economy?" The answer "government - federal, territorial, municipal and First Nation" In other words - government bureaucrats, government paper shufflers, government navel gazers". Its a false economy.

Up 27 Down 14

bobbybitman on Sep 17, 2014 at 6:10 pm

Not one mention of what the actual PROBLEM is. Is the water board actually worried about anything? Or are they just pissing on a lampost, showing everyone who's boss. Here we have a Yukon company hiring one would assume, locals, and they are being shut down by a 'quasi-judicial' board. If there were any mention of a specific water related concern, I'd be right there saying, okay, you are doing your job, let's get it figured out. But it seems to be a P-match based on 'this license did not cover that work, and we will determine who gets what and when'.

Up 20 Down 19

BnR on Sep 17, 2014 at 5:05 pm

And the Water Board should operate at arms length from the government, free from any political interference.
These lay offs were completely avoidable by Capstone with some proper planning.

Up 35 Down 9

Francias Pillman on Sep 17, 2014 at 3:42 pm

So what is driving the economy here? Seriously there must be someone here to answer this simple question.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.