Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

THE DAWN OF A NEW ERA – For the first time since 2002, during Pat Duncan’s tenure as premier, a Liberal government seated itself in the Yukon legislature on Thursday afternoon. Premier Sandy Silver now sits across from the opposition benches, where he was the lone Liberal for several years.

‘It’s a different view over here,’ premier observes

Thursday’s opening of the 34th legislature was not the only one-day session on record. They are rare though.

By Chuck Tobin on January 13, 2017

Thursday’s opening of the 34th legislature was not the only one-day session on record. They are rare though.

But that’s the way Premier Sandy Silver wanted it.

Silver simply wanted to jumpstart the wheels of government by getting Members of the Legislative Assembly appointed to the various standing committees of the legislature, so that they could get on with doing what they were elected to do. That’s what he said.

What he didn’t want was to bring forward any business under the shadow of the current territorial budget he had nothing to do with. That fiscal blueprint was delivered nine months ago by the former Yukon Party government.

Silver said the legislature will reconvene in March when his Liberals will bring forward their own financial strategy to carry the territory forward in the 2017-2018 fiscal year, and beyond.

Thursday’s sitting was largely ceremonial, beginning with Sergeant-in-Arms Doris McLean delivering the mace to the legislature, as more than 100 people filled the gallery to witness the day.

In keeping with parliamentary tradition, Commissioner Doug Phillips entered the assembly escorted by an RCMP officer and a member of the armed forces, but said nothing.

It was the clerk of the assembly who informed the legislature that he had been commanded by the commissioner to inform the house the commissioner would not address the assembly until it had elected a Speaker. And then Phillips left.

Seconds later, the premier was on his feet nominating Riverdale North MLA Nils Clarke as Speaker, with the support of both opposition parties.

Interim Yukon Party Leader Stacey Hassard approached Clarke to welcome him with a handshake, as did MLA Kate White on behalf of the New Democrats.

In his first address to the legislative assembly, Clarke humourously informed his elected colleagues and the audience the Speaker’s chair is not always the best seat in the house.

There was time in history, he said, when the position might have brought peril, such as in 1535, when Speaker Thomas More had his head chopped off after he lost favour with his longtime friend, King Henry XIII.

In a more solemn moment, the Speaker of the 34th legislature thanked former Yukon Party Speakers Ted Staffin and David Laxton for insights into the position. And he called upon the MLAs to work effectively.

“To the honourable members, I ask that you conduct yourselves in debate not only with vigour, creativity, industriousness and passion – which is expected of you – but also with the decorum befitting the special public office that you have been elected to by your fellow citizens,” said Clarke.

“Ultimately, how you treat one another will, in large measure, determine the worth that Yukoners convey upon you and on this legislative assembly.”

Clarke then asked the clerk to inform the commissioner that a Speaker had been selected, and that the legislature was now ready to hear the Speech from the Throne.

Throne speeches are prepared by the premier and are delivered by the commissioner. Generally, they’re lengthy, as they outline the government’s goals and aspirations for their term in office.

Phillips read what was probably one of the shortest on record.

It touched briefly on how the roles and responsibilities of the Yukon government have grown since the territory achieved governing independence from Ottawa with the beginning of party politics in 1978.

It mentioned how many First Nations have become self-governing, and how the Yukon as a whole has matured and its ability to represent itself on the national stage has grown over the last 38 years.

“Over the next two months, my government will be carrying out a review of spending priorities,” said Phillips, reading the Speech from the Throne.

“This review will provide the basis for an appropriation bill for the coming fiscal year, which the government will present to the house in March, along with the supplementary estimates for the current year.

“At that time, my government will also present a Speech from the Throne that will set out in more detail the government’s priorities and its legislative proposals.

“The agenda for this session is to put the machinery of the legislative assembly in place.”

Before the legislature went on with the business of appointing a deputy speaker and members of the legisature’s standing committees, Silver, Hassard and White were provided an opportunity to reply to the throne speech.

“It’s a different view over here,” Silver began, looking across the floor to where he had sat as the lone Liberal for the past five years. “I have to say that I’ve always had friends in this legislative assembly; it’s nice to have colleagues on this side.”

Following a quick congratulations, Hassard became critical of Silver’s decision to hold just a one-day sessions, and for not providing time for question period – an important aspect of holding the government accountable.

Hassard expressed hope the Liberal government would strive to achieve economic prosperity, in much the same way the Yukon Party committed to during last fall’s election campaign.

But he also expressed despair with what he described as unilateral decisions by the Liberal government in Ottawa that are affecting the territory. Examples are the decision to impose a carbon tax and the recent ban on new drilling leases in the Beaufort Sea.

“Mr. Speaker, in the short time that this government has been in power, we have seen either silence or defence of Ottawa’s decisions,” Hassard said.

“I believe that this is dangerous, and may, in the long term, weaken the powers that so many territorial governments have fought for previously.”

White, the NDP MLA for Takhini-Kopper King, told the legislature she has learned much in her first term in office over the last five years while a member of the-then official Opposition.

White said she has seen both sides of the Yukon government. She has seen government policies make life difficult for Yukoners, and she’s also seen government help lift up people.

“So, in my view, if there is one thing that any government, no matter their political stripe, must make a priority, is to make life better for the people we represent — the people of the Yukon,” White said in her response to the speech. “That’s what it comes down to.”

(NDP Leader Liz Hanson is out of the territory due to a family illness.)

In an interview outside the legislative assembly after the gallery had emptied and the lights went dark, White said she’s ready and willing to work hand-in-hand with the new government, to give the Liberals a chance. Already, she said, she’s optimistic.

White said as an official critic over the last five years, it took her four years before the Yukon Party government would permit her to meet face-to-face with a minister. She said she actually met with two ministers that year.

“It was a big year,” she said sarcastically.

White said while it took a while for Silver to appoint his cabinet, she’s already met once with Community Services Minister John Streicker.

The last five years in the legislative assembly under the Yukon Party were filled with acrimony, with “lateral violence,” she said.

In reference to Hassard’s concern that Silver will not stand up to Ottawa, White said that’s a case of the pot calling the kettle black, alluding to how the Yukon Party cozied up to former prime minister Stephen Harper.

It was in partnership that the two dismantled the territory’s environmental assessment legislation, she pointed out.

As a cheerleader by nature, White said, she’s optimistic she’ll be able to advance a number of files she’s been working on over the last five years with the assistance of the new government.

Hassard said in an interview following the session that while he may not always agree with the new government, he is willing to work co-operatively to advance Yukoners’ interests.

He said he has no issue with a close Liberal relationship between Whitehorse and Ottawa, and in fact sees it as a plus. But the premier must put the Yukon’s interests first in matters such as the carbon tax, health care and the federal transfer payments, he said.

“It is important to stand up for Yukoners when they have those conversations,” Hassard said.

“We do not always have to agree ... we do have to get along. We all have to play in the same sandbox together.”

In his response to his own speech, Silver said his party will govern with accountability, and a mind and a door open to hear what Yukoners have to say.

He and his colleagues have committed to governing with respect, he told the legislature.

“I am truly honoured that Yukoners have entrusted us with a mandate to govern the territory. In the coming years, we will work with energy and diligence to fulfill our commitments to the people of Yukon. We have committed to a respectful and collaborative relationship with Yukon First Nations,” the premier said.

“Tomorrow, I, along with other ministers and government MLAs, will meet with the grand chief of the Council of Yukon First Nations and Yukon First Nation chiefs from across the territory for our first Yukon Forum.”

In a interview in the cabinet offices following the sitting – which lasted one hour and 14 minutes – the premier said the leader of the official Opposition doesn’t have to worry about him standing up for Yukoners.

He is already standing, he said, suggesting anybody who has any doubt can check to see how the Yukon stood and continues to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the provinces against Ottawa in the ongoing national debate over health care funding.

He said he has stressed to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau the importance of involving the Yukon in decisions that affect the North.

“He said he agreed,” Silver said. “We will see if that happens.”

Silver defended the decision to go with a short, one-day session as necessary to provide time for the Liberal team to prepare its first budget, and to avoid having to answer questions about a budget prepared by the previous government.

See editorial in opinion section.

Comments (13)

Up 6 Down 2

Walter on Jan 18, 2017 at 3:04 pm

@North of 60 "Lib" and let "Lib" !

Up 13 Down 7

Just Say'in on Jan 17, 2017 at 9:55 pm

So that was it? A completely incomplete speech from the Throne. Maybe he didn't realize what he was supposed to include in it? They have ZERO experience on that side of the house and can't even put together a direction for the Government, other then to say they will just continue with the direction the out going Yukon Party laid out. WOW now they won't meet again until March. That is crazy. They are so afraid of question period because they know that no one other then Sandy has a clue about anything, and they will be torn apart. It is so obvious. Better get these guys and girls some training.

Up 27 Down 10

north_of_60 on Jan 15, 2017 at 3:25 pm

@TheCleanAir believes "With the new government in place, everyone is happier, there is more conversation and smiles in the hallways. "

All political honeymoons are like that. Just wait till they start screwing-up like the FED-LIBs are doing after a year in power.

Up 20 Down 14

Jonathan Colby on Jan 15, 2017 at 9:19 am

Yeah Wilf? You're saying that Kate White is lying about trying to meet with YP ministers? One of the most proactive and positive politicians this depopulated triangle has seen in a long time?

Prove it. Where are your precious facts?

Up 10 Down 2

padmalink on Jan 14, 2017 at 7:04 pm

Just as long as you keep your feet on the ground, and strive for the fruition of Yukon peoples noblest aspirations; get the picture?

Up 14 Down 21

TheCleanAir on Jan 14, 2017 at 4:54 pm

If anyone walked around the MAB for a living, and I did....it was such a solemn and unfriendly environment. Everyone working diligently, once in a while poking their heads out and then going about their business.

With the new government in place, everyone is happier, there is more conversation and smiles in the hallways. People are talking about possibilities, opportunities and the hope that lay ahead. You will see the premier, ministers, and their hire staff going from office to office engaging folks, asking questions and getting input and advice. Isn't that what a government does? They work for everyone, with everyone?

I like the respect and dignity this government bestows on all of us, there is a sense of community which has been lacking for some time. For those of us who have disabilities or cognitive impairments, we now have a voice. For First Nations People's they are being recognized as a full, active and equal partner which is long overdue. For the business community there is optimism and hope about the future.

For anyone that has not been to the MAB, go ahead walk around, it's our house to share. Even during the long winter darkness, there is a freshness in the air and a bright that is shining for all of us to guide us in this new journey.

Up 18 Down 18

June Jackson on Jan 13, 2017 at 6:43 pm

I also like Kate White.. well said Northernwoman.

Up 16 Down 25

What I found interesting on Jan 13, 2017 at 6:41 pm

The NDP refused to meet with Yukon Ministers to get the facts on subjects in the Yukon.

Up 27 Down 24

jc on Jan 13, 2017 at 5:25 pm

The Yukon was always know for its gold. Now it turned to silver. That's not progress.

Up 32 Down 20

jc on Jan 13, 2017 at 5:23 pm

Don't get too used to the view. Just ask Pat Duncan.

Up 23 Down 17

Dean Larue on Jan 13, 2017 at 5:19 pm

“Mr. Speaker, in the short time that this government has been in power, we have seen either silence or defence of Ottawa’s decisions,” Hassard said.
LMAO at Hassard's hypocrisy.

Darrell (his former boss) did EXACTLY what Stephen Harper wanted him to do for four years.

Up 28 Down 22

Hassard in a sand box on Jan 13, 2017 at 3:52 pm

Hassard is good at putting sand in any ones face, when he feels like it or a person is no use to him. Look into his past and look at his friends and what they have done.

Up 40 Down 22

NorthernWoman on Jan 13, 2017 at 3:43 pm

"White said as an official critic over the last five years, it took her four years before the Yukon Party government would permit her to meet face-to-face with a minister. She said she actually met with two ministers that year.

“It was a big year,” she said sarcastically.
White said while it took a while for Silver to appoint his cabinet, she’s already met once with Community Services Minister John Streicker.
The last five years in the legislative assembly under the Yukon Party were filled with acrimony, with “lateral violence,” she said.

In reference to Hassard’s concern that Silver will not stand up to Ottawa, White said that’s a case of the pot calling the kettle black, alluding to how the Yukon Party cozied up to former Prime Minister Stephen Harper."

Agreed. Hey, Hassard and any other member of the Ol' Boys Clubs... that way of governing (or dictating) is gone out the window. Acceptance and adaptation is key if members of your 'club' want to survive in the new and improved world of politics. The vote says it all.... that and the photo of our new Premier with, among an awesome and diverse team, 2 strong First Nations Women to his right. I'm hopeful and optimistic, and I haven't been able to say that in a long long time!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.