Whitehorse Daily Star

Ice woes have cost Yukon Energy nearly $200,000

Hydro generation at the Whitehorse Rapids Dam was completely shut down by ice Saturday evening, says Yukon Energy spokeswoman Janet Patterson.

By Chuck Tobin on November 18, 2014

Hydro generation at the Whitehorse Rapids Dam was completely shut down by ice Saturday evening, says Yukon Energy spokeswoman Janet Patterson.

Patterson said diesel generators at the dam and in Dawson City and Faro – up to 10 at one time – were brought on line to replace the loss of all four hydro units, including the 20-megawatt number four turbine, the largest unit in the Yukon.

The Aishihik and Mayo hydro plants were also brought up to near capacity to help compensate for the loss, she explained.

Patterson said divers from Vancouver are continuing their underwater work today to steam away the ice, though the number four unit was brought back on line Monday afternoon.

With the return of number four, diesel generation was shut down at 9 p.m. Monday following the period of peak demand, though some was required to get through this morning’s peak, she said.

Patterson said the icing problem cost Yukon Energy nearly $200,000 in diesel fuel.

“Over the weekend, we had some mild temperatures and strong winds, and a combination of those two things caused some ice to break away from the shoreline of Schwatka Lake,” she said.

“The best way to describe the ice was slushy sheet ice, just like a slushy.”

The slush moved north to the dam and when it contacted the cold steel of the underwater debris grates protecting the intake pipes for the hydro units, it turned to solid ice, she said.

Patterson said the penstocks for units one, two and three were completely blocked and the intake pipe for number four was partially blocked.

Hydro generation was replaced with diesel generation at 6 p.m. Saturday, she said.

“So we contacted divers from Vancouver because there is no company here that does this type of work and we flew them in Sunday,” she said.

“They spent yesterday working on one, two and three with a steam wand, putting steam to the ice and melting it.

“They were able to completely clear number three and partially clear number two and they are going to be back working today on one and two.”

Patterson said because the penstock feeding the Fourth Wheel was only partially blocked, it ended up clearing itself.

The divers installed underwater cameras so that ongoing work could be monitored for both operational and safety reasons, she explained.

She said only one diver at a time goes in, and only stays in for an hour so as not to get too cold, but the work is being watched from the surface at all times.

Patterson said this is the type of emergency situation that clearly demonstrates the need for some type of immediate backup generation, whether it’s powered by diesel fuel or natural gas.

“If you think about it, we lost our whole hydro generation in Whitehorse, and nobody lost power,” she said.

Patterson said Yukon Energy is estimating it burned 159,000 litres of diesel fuel as result of the icing, at a total cost of $197,000.

Just as matter of fact, she pointed out, had Yukon Energy’s two new natural gas units been up and running, the publicly owned utility would have saved $34,000 in fuel costs.

Patterson said while problems with frazzle ice occur occasionally at the dam facility, nobody can remember an incident this serious, when the entire hydro capacity was lost.

Environment Canada meteorologist Doug Lundquist said this morning the average daily temperature for Whitehorse has been two degrees above normal over the last 30 days.

Overall, however, the weather so far this fall has not been that unusual, he said.

Comments (7)

Up 0 Down 0

Buba on Jan 2, 2015 at 3:02 am

Something is not right about the facts of this story. It is being portrayed that the ice caused an additional burning of 150,000 ltrs of fuel for a couple of days? 40 thousand gals ? Goes to prove you can't believe everything you read.

Up 92 Down 86

Wilf Carter on Nov 22, 2014 at 6:53 pm

Thanks north of sixty for correcting the facts as you have done for me in some of my comments. We need more of this to bring forth the facts as they are.

Up 113 Down 88

north_of_60 on Nov 19, 2014 at 6:29 pm

@Werner Rhein "Was this happening ever before, that ice that normally floats on top of water blocked the intake grate deep under water?"
Yes, and it's so common that it has a name: "frazil ice". It's happened before and it will happen again. All part of winter in the Yukon.

Up 89 Down 117

Werner Rhein on Nov 19, 2014 at 3:46 pm

Was this happening ever before, that ice that normally floats on top of water blocked the intake grate deep under water? Or is this another global warming phenomenon and will this now occur more and more often?
If so would it then not be much more economical to divest from fossil fuels and invest in alternative renewable energy technology and help to mitigate global warming? Energy sources that would not need to be trucked up the AK HWY and create high risk accident potential and continuation of high cost. Sunshine and wind are free and I hope will stay free for ever. Local fuel sources like wood, which is carbon neutral, would create a lot of local jobs and don't make some already rich dude lying on a sunny beach in a taxheaven even richer.

Up 114 Down 88

Don't Want Back Energy on Nov 19, 2014 at 12:23 pm

So people of the Yukon run down to CT and purchase a back up generator because there are people in the Yukon who don't want back up power at all but can't bring forth any solutions and just want to hear themselves speak.

Up 99 Down 106

Thanks Tips on Nov 19, 2014 at 11:30 am

Just as matter of fact, it cost $40 million to get the LNG back up built, so it would have cost tax payers $40,034,000 if it had been working.
If we didn't get the LNG built it would have cost tax payers $197,000....

Up 104 Down 117

fed up Yukoner on Nov 18, 2014 at 4:09 pm

$200,000 in diesel costs-- add in the cost of setting up and paying for those turkeys and how much it cost to turn the LNG into a workable gas, not just the cost per litre and we won't break even till hell freezes over.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.