Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Peter O’Blenes

Bus purchase may be sole-sourced

The city will vote next week on whether to sole-source a contract worth more than $1 million.

By Stephanie Waddell on February 21, 2017

The city will vote next week on whether to sole-source a contract worth more than $1 million.

Peter O’Blenes, the city’s director of infrastructure and operations, brought forward a recommendation Monday night that council waive its standard bidding process and award the contract for two new 12-metre (40-foot) low-floor city buses to Nova Bus.

As O’Blenes explained in a report to council, the city’s capital budget for this year includes the purchase of the two buses through federal and territorial funds.

“These two buses are replacement units for aging pieces of the city’s fleet,” he said.

“It is crucial to ensure that the city has the equipment necessary to conduct transit operation and fleet maintenance.

“As per the purchasing and sales policy, a council resolution is required to waive the bidding process in favour of any supplier, as well as to award any contract in excess of $100,000.”

The city’s full-fleet of 13 buses are Nova brand. The ages will range from 18 months to 13 years when the new buses arrive in 2018, if the city approves the purchase.

Last year, the city came up with replacement plan for the fleet, spacing out the purchase plans for the coming years to ensure no more than two per year are bought.

There is a current back-log on manufacturing, due in part to the funding of transit programs from the federal government.

Consequently, it’s not expected the city would have the new buses for a period of about 14 months after the order is placed, if it is indeed placed by mid-March.

“Delivery time for orders received after mid-March 2017 will be more than 14 months,” O’Blenes said in his report.

“Delays in replacement may cause strain on existing transit services due to failures of aging equipment.”

Moving ahead with a sole-source contract, he said, will mean the buses could be ordered as soon as possible. As well, the city’s transit fleet would remain standardized, which helps in training staff, troubleshooting, getting parts and in fleet maintenance.

“Not proceeding as recommended and releasing a public tender would negate any standardization of the conventional transit fleet,” O’Blenes noted.

“Initial estimates are that operating and maintenance costs could increase as much as $13,000 in retooling and training costs in 2018 if a new supplier is chosen.”

While Coun. Betty Irwin was clear that she is not ordinarily in favour of sole-sourcing, she said in this case, there are many practical reasons to do so, such as the ordering of parts, and the timelines.

In this case, Irwin said, she will be voting in favour of waiving the bidding process.

O’Blenes also confirmed for councillors Jocelyn Curteanu and Dan Boyd that the city went through the bid process on its last bus purchase, with Nova being the winning bid of two.

Curteanu asked if the city might have the ability to negotiate a better price for being loyal customers.

O’Blenes commented that the price for each bus – $520,842 – is already good, being only slightly higher than the city’s last purchase in 2016.

With the current federal funding program for transit, bus manufacturers all over North America are seeing a large increase in demand.

“It’s a great time to be in the bus-building business,” Curtis commented.

Earlier, he had emphasized the benefits of a standardized fleet and the importance of working with the federal government on such funding matters.

Council will vote on the contract next week.

Comments (11)

Up 2 Down 7

As you know BnR I have dyslexia on Feb 25, 2017 at 2:46 pm

which you don't understand makes it hard to write, but a person like you don't get it and call people with disabilities down.
I have to laugh at some of the comments, some people.
I have over 3000 Yukon followers that want me to write opinions because of my background.
Wilf Carter

Up 8 Down 4

The Federal funding requires on Feb 25, 2017 at 11:25 am

green direction for investing. So why is the City purchasing buses that are not green.

Up 10 Down 11

Reality check on Feb 24, 2017 at 1:49 pm

We all want main arteries to be safe, as in cleared of snow and sanded. That means graders and trucks. We all want the gravel removed in the spring, rather than fly into our windshields. That means street sweepers. We want our water/sewer lines steamed when they freeze. That means a generator. All of these things require maintenance, and that requires a building. Have any of you actually seen the city's maintenance building? No. Didn't think so. And as to those smaller buses- what would you suggest we do about morning/evening commute, when current buses are full? Buy twice as many and hire 2x drivers? Buy regular buses for peak and small buses for quiet times ? I take the bus. I've never been on one where I was the sole customer, so many of you are just talking through your hats

Up 5 Down 17

Don't get it on Feb 24, 2017 at 10:59 am

Don't need a building for electric buses and save $12 million, which would purchase whole new fleet of buses for the City and sell existing buses to Vancouver. City can put small wind farm to supply some of the energy for these buses.
You can use solar depends on the angle you place them at so the snow does not cover them up.
How come no cares in the statements about a wilderness green City?
Where is the environmentalist?
Yukon Mayor and Manager show they don't care about our environment!

Up 8 Down 0

Smart mind on Feb 24, 2017 at 10:50 am

Ask the City of Winnipeg how their buses performed at 42 below. That other Cities around the world are moving to the system.
Some countries have to electric driven trains.

Up 13 Down 1

New suggestion on Feb 23, 2017 at 6:18 pm

The NDP want the buses equipped with Latin sails that would be erected by the drivers when the buses are heading with the wind.
This is no more ludicrous than the whole transit system is in regards to efficiency. Do some comparisons with other cities of similar size for transit equipment. 13 full sized buses for 28,000 people that 99% don't use is hard to swallow. Oh, while your at it check and see what kilometres buses are expected to be run up to before replacement and what kilometres are on this fleet. This system was way more efficient when it was originally run by a womens association (Whitehorse Mini Buss Society I believe) using those Fluery motor home type chasis. No more misleading reports with alternative facts either please.

Up 9 Down 12

north_of_60 on Feb 23, 2017 at 2:05 pm

A few smaller electric buses would be a wise addition to the transit fleet for the warm six months when we have a surplus of hydroelectricity that could charge them for next-to-nothing.

As for the idiots who keep flogging the "electric buses in -40" argument, the same can be said for motorcycles, so why do people still buy them and use them for half the year? The "re-outfit the CofW transport fleet with electric powered vehicles" comment is a 'reductio ad absurdum' argument and even more foolish and misinformed.

Up 12 Down 5

BnR on Feb 23, 2017 at 7:13 am

You've been brushing up on your English usage skills eh Wilf?
Wilf, Dawson didn't "purchase" anything. YG funded the plant. They went with the lowest price. Look where that got them. Yours is a completely inaccurate analogy. CofW is going with the proven option. Can you imagine how much it would cost to completely re-outfit the CofW transport fleet with electric powered vehicles?

Up 19 Down 5

post no bills on Feb 22, 2017 at 10:53 pm

haha wilf... electric buses in -40, good luck with that.

Up 6 Down 22

The City has done bad planning on transportation on Feb 22, 2017 at 1:19 pm

WE should have environmental friendly, which are electric drive by batteries.
We are spending millions, on a building, to house the buses, which is not needed.
This will be a worse decision than Dawson purchasing a sewage treatment plant and now we have to sue.
Stop the purchase of transit buses and re-work our transit plan that we need and can afford.
But this mayor and manager can't see the future and will not listen CIty tax payers. Wilf Carter

Up 2 Down 7

jc on Feb 21, 2017 at 5:59 pm

Wise idea!

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.